6 independent familiesINDUSTRIAL CONTINUITY / CAMPAIGN REVIEW
VERIFY THE FLEET.
CONTROL THE RETURN.
Federate exact maintenance evidence without converting record count into corroboration. Inspect authority, spares, materials, tools, calibration, fleet capacity, repair quality, reconciliation, and manufacturing-closure impact before any return-to-service proposal.
A REPAIR CAN SUCCEED WITHOUT ESTABLISHING RETURN AUTHORITY. A VALID PACKAGE IS EVIDENCE — NOT AUTOMATIC ACTIVATION.
e58b966e2c2b55480260…REVIEW LINEAGE
Exact packages → candidate review
7ace4c395e8438dbe42346c82ac9a348d7a25ad18dcc06806c6767e874453b2bFleet Packages
| Member | Scenario | Asset | Package | Return state |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| fleet-baseline | Nominal robotic inspection | ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL | VERIFIED | CONTINUE_ATTESTED_OPERATION |
| fleet-vibration | Early vibration degradation | ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL | VERIFIED | RETURN_TO_SERVICE_PENDING |
| tool-calibration | Tool calibration expired | MACHINE_TOOL_AND_METROLOGY_CELL | VERIFIED | RETURN_TO_SERVICE_PENDING |
| module-swap-success | Synthetic module swap successful | ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL | VERIFIED | RETURN_TO_SERVICE_AUTHORIZED |
| calibration-success | Synthetic calibration successful | MACHINE_TOOL_AND_METROLOGY_CELL | VERIFIED | RETURN_TO_SERVICE_AUTHORIZED |
| independent-review-complete | Independent machine review complete | ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL | VERIFIED | CONTINUE_ATTESTED_OPERATION |
Evidence Dependence and Correlation Control
Independent Readiness Dimensions
Repair Quality and Return-to-Service Authority
Spares, tools, and materials remain separately evaluated from technical repair success.
Configuration Reconciliation
Manufacturing Closure Impact
Reviewer Independence
Issues, Qualifications, and Unknowns
Contrary evidence
Blockers
Qualifications
Residual unknowns
Append-Oriented Review Ledger
Raw Synthetic Evidence
{
"asset_returned_to_service": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"automatic_resource_authorization": false,
"automatic_return_to_service": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_supersession_proposed": false,
"blockers": [],
"campaign": {
"available_fleet_capacity": 8,
"campaign_id": "fleet-maintenance-baseline",
"default_review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"description": "Nominal fleet evidence, early degradation, calibration, verified module replacement, and independent review.",
"label": "Fleet Maintenance Baseline",
"members": [
"fleet-baseline",
"fleet-vibration",
"tool-calibration",
"module-swap-success",
"calibration-success",
"independent-review-complete"
],
"required_fleet_capacity": 5
},
"candidate_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "7ace4c395e8438dbe42346c82ac9a348d7a25ad18dcc06806c6767e874453b2b",
"baseline_id": "INDUSTRIAL-CANDIDATE-FLEET-MAINTENANCE-BASELINE",
"campaign_id": "fleet-maintenance-baseline",
"closure_impact": [
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "COMPUTE",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"fleet-baseline"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "EVIDENCE",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"independent-review-complete"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "METROLOGY",
"qualifying_members": [
"fleet-vibration",
"tool-calibration"
],
"state": "QUALIFIED",
"supporting_members": [
"calibration-success"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "REVIEW",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"independent-review-complete"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE",
"qualifying_members": [
"fleet-vibration"
],
"state": "QUALIFIED",
"supporting_members": [
"fleet-baseline",
"module-swap-success"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "SPARES",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"module-swap-success"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "TOOLING",
"qualifying_members": [
"tool-calibration"
],
"state": "QUALIFIED",
"supporting_members": [
"calibration-success"
]
}
],
"member_package_digests": [
"39530365f2d9a2bb20ee4b6568e9dc309602072b052a231485905b37da39ec65",
"180858efe77328ca8923767d3411cae67beb5d5dd0a581fdd940dfcb38aeed4a",
"7ca13df4f121fab6d23becd20c81b3017f8a2f0b932f02680e2f45eccbbf75fb",
"8efe7e038c3caa2fafe0b02930200d0c3c5269264eba903c6593c5fc08a112d9",
"7ba38d522080b7d97867c3d36d10d50bf7918ca603960fe87b7084b957485b9b",
"b6764a0fa0b16a3e9548436009efa5a5463450f574948e66cd5fb782c2b1e856"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "maintenance_authority",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "diagnostic_evidence",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "tool_attestation",
"qualification": "Tool, calibration, or recipe state requires additional verification.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "parts_availability",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "material_provenance",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "calibration",
"qualification": "Calibration or metrology remains outside the accepted synthetic state.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "robotic_fleet_capacity",
"qualification": "Effective synthetic fleet capacity 7 / required 5.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "configuration_reconciliation",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "post_repair_verification",
"qualification": "Post-repair verification remains failed, pending, or qualified.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "rollback_baseline",
"qualification": "An accepted recovery baseline remains synthetic or not demonstrated in this campaign.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "continuity_impact",
"qualification": "Continuity or manufacturing-closure impact remains blocked or qualified.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "return_to_service_authority",
"qualification": "One or more members remain denied, pending, withdrawn, or reconciliation-bound.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic evidence do not establish actual-host or physical-system deployment.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "Protected customer strategy remains sealed; this is a newly constructed synthetic capability artifact.",
"state": "PASS"
}
]
},
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"contrary_evidence": [
{
"contrary_id": "CONTRA-001",
"historically_preserved": true,
"member_id": "tool-calibration",
"reason": "POST_REPAIR_INCONCLUSIVE",
"scenario_id": "tool-calibration-expired",
"source_package_sha256": "7ca13df4f121fab6d23becd20c81b3017f8a2f0b932f02680e2f45eccbbf75fb"
}
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_dependence": {
"correlation_groups": [
{
"correlated": true,
"correlation_group": "SYNTHETIC_SENSOR_FABRIC_A",
"member_count": 6,
"member_ids": [
"calibration-success",
"fleet-baseline",
"fleet-vibration",
"independent-review-complete",
"module-swap-success",
"tool-calibration"
]
},
{
"correlated": true,
"correlation_group": "SYNTHETIC_SUPPLY_CHAIN_A",
"member_count": 6,
"member_ids": [
"calibration-success",
"fleet-baseline",
"fleet-vibration",
"independent-review-complete",
"module-swap-success",
"tool-calibration"
]
}
],
"evidence_family_count": 6,
"families": [
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"evidence_family": "FAM-CAL-A",
"independent_corroboration_count": 1,
"member_ids": [
"calibration-success"
],
"record_count": 1,
"root_source_count": 1,
"unique_package_count": 1
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"evidence_family": "FAM-FLEET-BASELINE-A",
"independent_corroboration_count": 1,
"member_ids": [
"fleet-baseline"
],
"record_count": 1,
"root_source_count": 1,
"unique_package_count": 1
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"evidence_family": "FAM-HEALTH-A",
"independent_corroboration_count": 1,
"member_ids": [
"fleet-vibration"
],
"record_count": 1,
"root_source_count": 1,
"unique_package_count": 1
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"evidence_family": "FAM-REPAIR-A",
"independent_corroboration_count": 1,
"member_ids": [
"module-swap-success"
],
"record_count": 1,
"root_source_count": 1,
"unique_package_count": 1
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"evidence_family": "FAM-REVIEW-A",
"independent_corroboration_count": 1,
"member_ids": [
"independent-review-complete"
],
"record_count": 1,
"root_source_count": 1,
"unique_package_count": 1
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"evidence_family": "FAM-TOOL-A",
"independent_corroboration_count": 1,
"member_ids": [
"tool-calibration"
],
"record_count": 1,
"root_source_count": 1,
"unique_package_count": 1
}
],
"independent_corroboration_count": 6,
"record_count": 6,
"record_count_is_not_independent_corroboration": true,
"root_source_count": 6
},
"failed_dimensions": [],
"fleet_capacity": {
"automatic_resource_authorization": false,
"constrained_units": 2,
"declared_available_units": 8,
"effective_available_units": 7,
"real_fleet_measured": false,
"required_units": 5,
"state": "SUFFICIENT",
"unavailable_units": 0
},
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"asset_identity_and_authority": true,
"calibration": true,
"configuration_reconciliation": true,
"continuity_impact": true,
"correlation_control": true,
"deployment_evidence": true,
"diagnostic_evidence": true,
"evidence_dependence": true,
"parts_and_materials": true,
"post_repair_verification": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"return_to_service_authority": true,
"robotic_fleet_capacity": true,
"rollback_baseline": true,
"source_package_integrity": true,
"tool_and_recipe_attestation": true
},
"lineage_sha256": "a896146e63f25413bbed154bfe3c3e2b0fa7ecc9f11d7c6e497a210fc5e18795",
"manufacturing_closure_impact": [
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "COMPUTE",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"fleet-baseline"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "EVIDENCE",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"independent-review-complete"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "METROLOGY",
"qualifying_members": [
"fleet-vibration",
"tool-calibration"
],
"state": "QUALIFIED",
"supporting_members": [
"calibration-success"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "REVIEW",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"independent-review-complete"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE",
"qualifying_members": [
"fleet-vibration"
],
"state": "QUALIFIED",
"supporting_members": [
"fleet-baseline",
"module-swap-success"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "SPARES",
"qualifying_members": [],
"state": "SUPPORTED",
"supporting_members": [
"module-swap-success"
]
},
{
"automatic_closure_claim": false,
"blocking_members": [],
"domain": "TOOLING",
"qualifying_members": [
"tool-calibration"
],
"state": "QUALIFIED",
"supporting_members": [
"calibration-success"
]
}
],
"narrative_equivalent": "Campaign Fleet Maintenance Baseline federated 6 synthetic run packages into 6 evidence families. Review outcome is Accept with qualifications. Effective synthetic fleet capacity is 7 against 5 required units. No asset was returned to service, no baseline was activated, no resource use was authorized, and no protected strategy was disclosed.",
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"activated_by_this_review": false,
"baseline_digest": "b7959dc33d8a8045d91a2e6709a051e34da8ca28bdea05d1c96f5f98b9cd4578",
"baseline_id": "INDUSTRIAL-BASELINE-SYNTH-0001"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Every source package passes exact verification.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-001"
},
{
"name": "Every required inspection is recorded for a merits-capable outcome.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-002"
},
{
"name": "Record count remains distinct from independent corroboration.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-003"
},
{
"name": "Evidence families remain explicit.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-004"
},
{
"name": "Readiness dimensions remain independent.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-005"
},
{
"name": "No universal readiness score exists.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-006"
},
{
"name": "Review never returns an asset to service automatically.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-007"
},
{
"name": "Review never activates a baseline automatically.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-008"
},
{
"name": "Review never authorizes resource consumption automatically.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review never writes production authority.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-010"
},
{
"name": "Review never promotes the Evulgare release.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-011"
},
{
"name": "Source histories remain immutable.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-012"
},
{
"name": "No historical evidence is deleted.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-013"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain is append-oriented and valid.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-014"
},
{
"name": "Contrary evidence is preserved.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-015"
},
{
"name": "Fleet capacity does not authorize resource use.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-016"
},
{
"name": "Closure analysis does not manufacture a universal self-sufficiency claim.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-017"
},
{
"name": "Protected partner strategy remains sealed.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-018"
},
{
"name": "Public review is ephemeral.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-019"
},
{
"name": "Every derived action terminates at SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK.",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "IRR-INV-020"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"protected_strategy_disclosed": false,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"automatic_resource_authorization": false,
"automatic_return_to_service": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"hazardous_chemical_recipes": false,
"name": "CONTROLLED UNCLASSIFIED INDUSTRIAL REVIEW RANGE",
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"protected_strategy_disclosed": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_facility_topology": false,
"real_high_voltage_instructions": false,
"real_industrial_control_protocols": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_plc_commands": false,
"real_reactor_control": false,
"real_semiconductor_recipes": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"qualifications": [
"TOOL_ATTESTATION: Tool, calibration, or recipe state requires additional verification.",
"CALIBRATION: Calibration or metrology remains outside the accepted synthetic state.",
"POST_REPAIR_VERIFICATION: Post-repair verification remains failed, pending, or qualified.",
"ROLLBACK_BASELINE: An accepted recovery baseline remains synthetic or not demonstrated in this campaign.",
"CONTINUITY_IMPACT: Continuity or manufacturing-closure impact remains blocked or qualified.",
"RETURN_TO_SERVICE_AUTHORITY: One or more members remain denied, pending, withdrawn, or reconciliation-bound.",
"DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE: Repository and synthetic evidence do not establish actual-host or physical-system deployment."
],
"qualified_dimensions": [
"tool_attestation",
"calibration",
"post_repair_verification",
"rollback_baseline",
"continuity_impact",
"return_to_service_authority",
"deployment_evidence"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "maintenance_authority",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "diagnostic_evidence",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "tool_attestation",
"qualification": "Tool, calibration, or recipe state requires additional verification.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "parts_availability",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "material_provenance",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "calibration",
"qualification": "Calibration or metrology remains outside the accepted synthetic state.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "robotic_fleet_capacity",
"qualification": "Effective synthetic fleet capacity 7 / required 5.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "configuration_reconciliation",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "post_repair_verification",
"qualification": "Post-repair verification remains failed, pending, or qualified.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "rollback_baseline",
"qualification": "An accepted recovery baseline remains synthetic or not demonstrated in this campaign.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "continuity_impact",
"qualification": "Continuity or manufacturing-closure impact remains blocked or qualified.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "return_to_service_authority",
"qualification": "One or more members remain denied, pending, withdrawn, or reconciliation-bound.",
"state": "QUALIFIED"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic evidence do not establish actual-host or physical-system deployment.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "Protected customer strategy remains sealed; this is a newly constructed synthetic capability artifact.",
"state": "PASS"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Physical machinery, tooling, material, calibration, environmental, and fleet behavior remain outside this public synthetic record.",
"Actual customer authority, legal approval, accreditation, certification, procurement acceptance, and operational readiness are not established.",
"Protected partner plans, locations, timelines, dependencies, stockpiles, process recipes, vulnerabilities, and strategy remain sealed."
],
"resource_use_authorized": false,
"return_to_service_proposed": true,
"review_artifact_sha256": "e58b966e2c2b55480260057fb03966b234836fc5706d458d89c2157b036a9a01",
"review_classification": "QUALIFIED_ACCEPTANCE_PROPOSED",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "82ac601c95750d13f5b95892a4cdd1352c191cb5299b4ca4e24d464923af7190",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "REVIEW_OPENED",
"description": "Campaign fleet-maintenance-baseline opened for bounded review.",
"event_id": "IRR-000",
"event_sha256": "c45d6ba71992a688f59ba4ba95bc2a8af712161f2a84142a1bd6bd2782781927",
"index": 0,
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "SOURCE_PACKAGES_VERIFIED",
"description": "6 exact industrial run packages evaluated.",
"event_id": "IRR-001",
"event_sha256": "70231caf73456ba54079cf95bf65b473367c4ee511ec776d499d5d075c2ea199",
"index": 1,
"previous_event_sha256": "c45d6ba71992a688f59ba4ba95bc2a8af712161f2a84142a1bd6bd2782781927",
"timestamp_ms": 10
},
{
"code": "EVIDENCE_DEPENDENCE_RECORDED",
"description": "6 records resolve to 6 evidence families.",
"event_id": "IRR-002",
"event_sha256": "0e8625c5ce7de83c2084fc3668794d542f5eb95069d7c00ea771d6e9576fbb73",
"index": 2,
"previous_event_sha256": "70231caf73456ba54079cf95bf65b473367c4ee511ec776d499d5d075c2ea199",
"timestamp_ms": 20
},
{
"code": "CORRELATION_CONTROL_APPLIED",
"description": "2 correlated groups remain explicit.",
"event_id": "IRR-003",
"event_sha256": "cf5c3609707b36e7a8cca4c6b5148ad2f4401d1a662cc5f8bbbdbe765187fcbc",
"index": 3,
"previous_event_sha256": "0e8625c5ce7de83c2084fc3668794d542f5eb95069d7c00ea771d6e9576fbb73",
"timestamp_ms": 30
},
{
"code": "FLEET_CAPACITY_EVALUATED",
"description": "Effective capacity 7 / required 5.",
"event_id": "IRR-004",
"event_sha256": "92bbcab3408aca70510508d4a19fc01910b700dbc199b1abdc575021885ec916",
"index": 4,
"previous_event_sha256": "cf5c3609707b36e7a8cca4c6b5148ad2f4401d1a662cc5f8bbbdbe765187fcbc",
"timestamp_ms": 40
},
{
"code": "SPARES_TOOLS_MATERIALS_REVIEWED",
"description": "Parts, materials, tooling, recipes, and calibration evaluated independently.",
"event_id": "IRR-005",
"event_sha256": "9983efafe1355e8082ed6ada5fe1348f0e8a186d804abd1b7f252d902664eaaf",
"index": 5,
"previous_event_sha256": "92bbcab3408aca70510508d4a19fc01910b700dbc199b1abdc575021885ec916",
"timestamp_ms": 50
},
{
"code": "REPAIR_QUALITY_REVIEWED",
"description": "Post-repair test, regression, and contrary evidence preserved.",
"event_id": "IRR-006",
"event_sha256": "e71cc7a97cbfaadfbe1154b1f7512bef72261d368145798afafb4ea2463c7e2c",
"index": 6,
"previous_event_sha256": "9983efafe1355e8082ed6ada5fe1348f0e8a186d804abd1b7f252d902664eaaf",
"timestamp_ms": 60
},
{
"code": "CONFIGURATION_RECONCILIATION_REVIEWED",
"description": "Software, model, policy, configuration, tool, and recipe lineage retained.",
"event_id": "IRR-007",
"event_sha256": "f16f108d5ffce05df2f84e2f09799700390c887092d5d858c6f7b81dd1fd1250",
"index": 7,
"previous_event_sha256": "e71cc7a97cbfaadfbe1154b1f7512bef72261d368145798afafb4ea2463c7e2c",
"timestamp_ms": 70
},
{
"code": "RETURN_TO_SERVICE_AUTHORITY_REVIEWED",
"description": "Return-to-service remains a separately authorized proposal.",
"event_id": "IRR-008",
"event_sha256": "a2cf94b585cd58540fb945e9ce3d5edd99c2d6f032ffe5a2da9bf9db56a6aa6e",
"index": 8,
"previous_event_sha256": "f16f108d5ffce05df2f84e2f09799700390c887092d5d858c6f7b81dd1fd1250",
"timestamp_ms": 80
},
{
"code": "MANUFACTURING_CLOSURE_IMPACT_RECORDED",
"description": "7 closure domains evaluated without a composite score.",
"event_id": "IRR-009",
"event_sha256": "6924087b42016d240e09e5c9eb97acabcdd429d5b81b506a545829efe579391f",
"index": 9,
"previous_event_sha256": "a2cf94b585cd58540fb945e9ce3d5edd99c2d6f032ffe5a2da9bf9db56a6aa6e",
"timestamp_ms": 90
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"event_id": "IRR-010",
"event_sha256": "54bc2c0660595334a3cd59da3e05dbe63ba083f41df22aa4fc8769a56c2a46d0",
"index": 10,
"previous_event_sha256": "6924087b42016d240e09e5c9eb97acabcdd429d5b81b506a545829efe579391f",
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "HISTORY_SEALED",
"description": "Append-oriented review history sealed; no parent history overwritten.",
"event_id": "IRR-011",
"event_sha256": "881757e8f0e2aa2bd2babf9a577937296904c09052b6cbb5d58b6f5973e9fa22",
"index": 11,
"previous_event_sha256": "54bc2c0660595334a3cd59da3e05dbe63ba083f41df22aa4fc8769a56c2a46d0",
"timestamp_ms": 110
},
{
"code": "PUBLIC_TERMINAL",
"description": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"event_id": "IRR-012",
"event_sha256": "82ac601c95750d13f5b95892a4cdd1352c191cb5299b4ca4e24d464923af7190",
"index": 12,
"previous_event_sha256": "881757e8f0e2aa2bd2babf9a577937296904c09052b6cbb5d58b6f5973e9fa22",
"state": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 120
}
],
"review_input": {
"campaign_id": "fleet-maintenance-baseline",
"inspections": {
"asset_identity_and_authority": true,
"calibration": true,
"configuration_reconciliation": true,
"continuity_impact": true,
"correlation_control": true,
"deployment_evidence": true,
"diagnostic_evidence": true,
"evidence_dependence": true,
"parts_and_materials": true,
"post_repair_verification": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"return_to_service_authority": true,
"robotic_fleet_capacity": true,
"rollback_baseline": true,
"source_package_integrity": true,
"tool_and_recipe_attestation": true
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-SCOPE-RC26",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRR-INDEPENDENT-01",
"implementation_lineage": "DIVERSE_SYNTHETIC_INDUSTRIAL_LINEAGE-A",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_INDUSTRIAL_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review"
},
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"review_state_label": "Accept with qualifications",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-SCOPE-RC26",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRR-INDEPENDENT-01",
"implementation_lineage": "DIVERSE_SYNTHETIC_INDUSTRIAL_LINEAGE-A",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_INDUSTRIAL_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review.v1",
"source_histories_mutated": false,
"source_members": [
{
"applied_action": "CONTINUE_OBSERVATION",
"asset_class": "ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL",
"asset_id": "ASSET-89108",
"authority_current": true,
"authority_id": "AUTH-SYNTH-INDUSTRIAL-0001",
"authority_revoked": false,
"authority_superseded": false,
"category": "BASELINE",
"closure_domains": [
"COMPUTE",
"ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE"
],
"configuration_digest": "fec351227279a2bb3770c9209524cdf4890ab6684c456945a551d932e41c16f0",
"contradictory_evidence": false,
"correlation_groups": [
"SYNTHETIC_SENSOR_FABRIC_A",
"SYNTHETIC_SUPPLY_CHAIN_A"
],
"dependency_groups": [
"POWER",
"COMPUTE",
"EVIDENCE_SERVICES"
],
"diagnosis_state": "NOMINAL",
"event_chain_sha256": "d005952c8fd6082f1e1ce600ff2cc5fd19b771a77978bf72be931799f8142660",
"evidence_family": "FAM-FLEET-BASELINE-A",
"failed_gates": [],
"fleet_units": 1,
"member_id": "fleet-baseline",
"model_version": "diagnostic-model-1.0.0",
"policy_version": "maintenance-policy-1.0.0",
"post_repair_regression": "PASS",
"post_repair_test": "NOT_RUN",
"recipe_digest": "e38bdad97967ef2d459c0c2f83d872d2d2437de7e8040cd80b4ae5ae4aff66c8",
"reconciliation_state": "COMPLETE",
"return_authorized": true,
"return_decision": "CONTINUE_ATTESTED_OPERATION",
"root_source": "ROOT-FLEET-A",
"run_sha256": "8481f89320b7295839f4616efadb43dfaa9fc2a284a566e2cce68ca47d9ae92c",
"scenario_id": "nominal-robotic-inspection",
"scenario_label": "Nominal robotic inspection",
"software_version": "industrial-engine-1.0.0",
"source_package_sha256": "39530365f2d9a2bb20ee4b6568e9dc309602072b052a231485905b37da39ec65",
"source_verification": {
"check_count": 25,
"checks": [
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-001",
"name": "Published member identifier",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-002",
"name": "Wrapper schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-003",
"name": "Wrapper digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-004",
"name": "Evidence family preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-005",
"name": "Root-source dependence preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-006",
"name": "Source package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-007",
"name": "Source release identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-008",
"name": "Source engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-009",
"name": "Source package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-010",
"name": "Source run schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-011",
"name": "Source run digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-012",
"name": "Scenario identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-013",
"name": "Asset identity bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-014",
"name": "Authority artifact bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-015",
"name": "Configuration, tool, and recipe digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-016",
"name": "Software/model/policy versions bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-017",
"name": "Dependency groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-018",
"name": "Correlation groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-019",
"name": "Industrial event chain valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-020",
"name": "Manifest exact run identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-021",
"name": "Terminal state",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-022",
"name": "Public boundary unchanged",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-023",
"name": "No automatic return or promotion",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-024",
"name": "Protected strategy not disclosed",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-025",
"name": "No real industrial command emitted",
"passed": true
}
],
"member_id": "fleet-baseline",
"passed": true,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review-source-verification.v1",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "f44702d583db7b80ac9f5521fe57cd6c93a3cd06c37a4b55225af79463ff51c6"
},
"source_verified": true,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"tool_digest": "57fd8e57144cef6fd2af55cdb41cc93941774ff195c600cff99cbc8cb9d3f6dd",
"wrapper_sha256": "08fb2876cad253f27fbb9b997566f414ceeddb504c0739db362b230921c2527d"
},
{
"applied_action": "REDUCE_SYNTHETIC_LOAD",
"asset_class": "ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL",
"asset_id": "ASSET-62325",
"authority_current": true,
"authority_id": "AUTH-SYNTH-INDUSTRIAL-0001",
"authority_revoked": false,
"authority_superseded": false,
"category": "HEALTH",
"closure_domains": [
"ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE",
"METROLOGY"
],
"configuration_digest": "fec351227279a2bb3770c9209524cdf4890ab6684c456945a551d932e41c16f0",
"contradictory_evidence": false,
"correlation_groups": [
"SYNTHETIC_SENSOR_FABRIC_A",
"SYNTHETIC_SUPPLY_CHAIN_A"
],
"dependency_groups": [
"POWER",
"COMPUTE",
"EVIDENCE_SERVICES"
],
"diagnosis_state": "CONFIRMED",
"event_chain_sha256": "877223b389a55e2e790b7788e84bdef9704af86956c785d0747d8e9a1e63cb8e",
"evidence_family": "FAM-HEALTH-A",
"failed_gates": [],
"fleet_units": 1,
"member_id": "fleet-vibration",
"model_version": "diagnostic-model-1.0.0",
"policy_version": "maintenance-policy-1.0.0",
"post_repair_regression": "PASS",
"post_repair_test": "NOT_RUN",
"recipe_digest": "e38bdad97967ef2d459c0c2f83d872d2d2437de7e8040cd80b4ae5ae4aff66c8",
"reconciliation_state": "COMPLETE",
"return_authorized": false,
"return_decision": "RETURN_TO_SERVICE_PENDING",
"root_source": "ROOT-HEALTH-A",
"run_sha256": "9ed50c760cf7e56cd22f472f5914d9e257c07220abf0220335cdd9d8cc6a893c",
"scenario_id": "early-vibration-degradation",
"scenario_label": "Early vibration degradation",
"software_version": "industrial-engine-1.0.0",
"source_package_sha256": "180858efe77328ca8923767d3411cae67beb5d5dd0a581fdd940dfcb38aeed4a",
"source_verification": {
"check_count": 25,
"checks": [
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-001",
"name": "Published member identifier",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-002",
"name": "Wrapper schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-003",
"name": "Wrapper digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-004",
"name": "Evidence family preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-005",
"name": "Root-source dependence preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-006",
"name": "Source package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-007",
"name": "Source release identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-008",
"name": "Source engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-009",
"name": "Source package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-010",
"name": "Source run schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-011",
"name": "Source run digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-012",
"name": "Scenario identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-013",
"name": "Asset identity bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-014",
"name": "Authority artifact bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-015",
"name": "Configuration, tool, and recipe digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-016",
"name": "Software/model/policy versions bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-017",
"name": "Dependency groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-018",
"name": "Correlation groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-019",
"name": "Industrial event chain valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-020",
"name": "Manifest exact run identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-021",
"name": "Terminal state",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-022",
"name": "Public boundary unchanged",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-023",
"name": "No automatic return or promotion",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-024",
"name": "Protected strategy not disclosed",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-025",
"name": "No real industrial command emitted",
"passed": true
}
],
"member_id": "fleet-vibration",
"passed": true,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review-source-verification.v1",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "630ca56bdef8370ef533d68712bd135b1e885d5cc82e5cc73745104d78a2fb37"
},
"source_verified": true,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"tool_digest": "57fd8e57144cef6fd2af55cdb41cc93941774ff195c600cff99cbc8cb9d3f6dd",
"wrapper_sha256": "6f9d178a36957b442b626229c6ca80c44f430ffd32e921aed6ebe62127692cb1"
},
{
"applied_action": "RECALIBRATE_SYNTHETIC_TOOL",
"asset_class": "MACHINE_TOOL_AND_METROLOGY_CELL",
"asset_id": "ASSET-01078",
"authority_current": true,
"authority_id": "AUTH-SYNTH-INDUSTRIAL-0001",
"authority_revoked": false,
"authority_superseded": false,
"category": "TOOLING",
"closure_domains": [
"TOOLING",
"METROLOGY"
],
"configuration_digest": "d51ccab523f2be058764f1f149d8ce4ee045b3df2dc60348f212b2dcd15c7def",
"contradictory_evidence": false,
"correlation_groups": [
"SYNTHETIC_SENSOR_FABRIC_A",
"SYNTHETIC_SUPPLY_CHAIN_A"
],
"dependency_groups": [
"POWER",
"COMPUTE",
"EVIDENCE_SERVICES"
],
"diagnosis_state": "CONFIRMED",
"event_chain_sha256": "dd5ece334e49e40b8f71e631b502e5990c6ae410e22d1f1cea9c873a7fbb1e6b",
"evidence_family": "FAM-TOOL-A",
"failed_gates": [],
"fleet_units": 1,
"member_id": "tool-calibration",
"model_version": "diagnostic-model-1.0.0",
"policy_version": "maintenance-policy-1.0.0",
"post_repair_regression": "PASS",
"post_repair_test": "INCONCLUSIVE",
"recipe_digest": "b8e219f0d63cd5b7512f58dad645132978bac30597d3fa47a65d18e19258afd8",
"reconciliation_state": "COMPLETE",
"return_authorized": false,
"return_decision": "RETURN_TO_SERVICE_PENDING",
"root_source": "ROOT-TOOL-A",
"run_sha256": "f4ad2f4b3b77f039e9a404ea36722993d3352604a253e05485824a97e51941fd",
"scenario_id": "tool-calibration-expired",
"scenario_label": "Tool calibration expired",
"software_version": "industrial-engine-1.0.0",
"source_package_sha256": "7ca13df4f121fab6d23becd20c81b3017f8a2f0b932f02680e2f45eccbbf75fb",
"source_verification": {
"check_count": 25,
"checks": [
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-001",
"name": "Published member identifier",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-002",
"name": "Wrapper schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-003",
"name": "Wrapper digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-004",
"name": "Evidence family preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-005",
"name": "Root-source dependence preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-006",
"name": "Source package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-007",
"name": "Source release identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-008",
"name": "Source engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-009",
"name": "Source package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-010",
"name": "Source run schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-011",
"name": "Source run digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-012",
"name": "Scenario identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-013",
"name": "Asset identity bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-014",
"name": "Authority artifact bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-015",
"name": "Configuration, tool, and recipe digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-016",
"name": "Software/model/policy versions bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-017",
"name": "Dependency groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-018",
"name": "Correlation groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-019",
"name": "Industrial event chain valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-020",
"name": "Manifest exact run identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-021",
"name": "Terminal state",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-022",
"name": "Public boundary unchanged",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-023",
"name": "No automatic return or promotion",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-024",
"name": "Protected strategy not disclosed",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-025",
"name": "No real industrial command emitted",
"passed": true
}
],
"member_id": "tool-calibration",
"passed": true,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review-source-verification.v1",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "4d091d23f9ad1208dd40805afd1926617dea289f6c43c2198354ec9d8044efa2"
},
"source_verified": true,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"tool_digest": "e6fa2389202b2df7aa4df56d3cd85c686049a10987f81832e0ee9593d783c605",
"wrapper_sha256": "32c1ccf2976fbd969bb5e17105d0629dae4c65ebdd9c15497447ea7c5bc0e20b"
},
{
"applied_action": "SWAP_SYNTHETIC_MODULE",
"asset_class": "ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL",
"asset_id": "ASSET-10765",
"authority_current": true,
"authority_id": "AUTH-SYNTH-INDUSTRIAL-0001",
"authority_revoked": false,
"authority_superseded": false,
"category": "REPAIR",
"closure_domains": [
"SPARES",
"ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE"
],
"configuration_digest": "fec351227279a2bb3770c9209524cdf4890ab6684c456945a551d932e41c16f0",
"contradictory_evidence": false,
"correlation_groups": [
"SYNTHETIC_SENSOR_FABRIC_A",
"SYNTHETIC_SUPPLY_CHAIN_A"
],
"dependency_groups": [
"POWER",
"COMPUTE",
"EVIDENCE_SERVICES"
],
"diagnosis_state": "CONFIRMED",
"event_chain_sha256": "a671a076537e672203a6d8b508257024dd011c617a0005d709be4ae9f4e18e38",
"evidence_family": "FAM-REPAIR-A",
"failed_gates": [],
"fleet_units": 1,
"member_id": "module-swap-success",
"model_version": "diagnostic-model-1.0.0",
"policy_version": "maintenance-policy-1.0.0",
"post_repair_regression": "PASS",
"post_repair_test": "PASS",
"recipe_digest": "e38bdad97967ef2d459c0c2f83d872d2d2437de7e8040cd80b4ae5ae4aff66c8",
"reconciliation_state": "COMPLETE",
"return_authorized": true,
"return_decision": "RETURN_TO_SERVICE_AUTHORIZED",
"root_source": "ROOT-REPAIR-A",
"run_sha256": "9f7336f03dcd37809375e9736e1d506e21718146290c1e322a6f93bae2c96807",
"scenario_id": "successful-module-swap",
"scenario_label": "Synthetic module swap successful",
"software_version": "industrial-engine-1.0.0",
"source_package_sha256": "8efe7e038c3caa2fafe0b02930200d0c3c5269264eba903c6593c5fc08a112d9",
"source_verification": {
"check_count": 25,
"checks": [
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-001",
"name": "Published member identifier",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-002",
"name": "Wrapper schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-003",
"name": "Wrapper digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-004",
"name": "Evidence family preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-005",
"name": "Root-source dependence preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-006",
"name": "Source package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-007",
"name": "Source release identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-008",
"name": "Source engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-009",
"name": "Source package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-010",
"name": "Source run schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-011",
"name": "Source run digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-012",
"name": "Scenario identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-013",
"name": "Asset identity bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-014",
"name": "Authority artifact bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-015",
"name": "Configuration, tool, and recipe digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-016",
"name": "Software/model/policy versions bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-017",
"name": "Dependency groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-018",
"name": "Correlation groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-019",
"name": "Industrial event chain valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-020",
"name": "Manifest exact run identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-021",
"name": "Terminal state",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-022",
"name": "Public boundary unchanged",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-023",
"name": "No automatic return or promotion",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-024",
"name": "Protected strategy not disclosed",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-025",
"name": "No real industrial command emitted",
"passed": true
}
],
"member_id": "module-swap-success",
"passed": true,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review-source-verification.v1",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "422f144e5ef1a386560da63ce34554864ea587314b5dc187f858a291b680205f"
},
"source_verified": true,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"tool_digest": "57fd8e57144cef6fd2af55cdb41cc93941774ff195c600cff99cbc8cb9d3f6dd",
"wrapper_sha256": "0fed92d0ee575656dad0887288ba0a09f3bb13274b8573f884a87f70fc0b51bd"
},
{
"applied_action": "RECALIBRATE_SYNTHETIC_TOOL",
"asset_class": "MACHINE_TOOL_AND_METROLOGY_CELL",
"asset_id": "ASSET-23428",
"authority_current": true,
"authority_id": "AUTH-SYNTH-INDUSTRIAL-0001",
"authority_revoked": false,
"authority_superseded": false,
"category": "CALIBRATION",
"closure_domains": [
"TOOLING",
"METROLOGY"
],
"configuration_digest": "d51ccab523f2be058764f1f149d8ce4ee045b3df2dc60348f212b2dcd15c7def",
"contradictory_evidence": false,
"correlation_groups": [
"SYNTHETIC_SENSOR_FABRIC_A",
"SYNTHETIC_SUPPLY_CHAIN_A"
],
"dependency_groups": [
"POWER",
"COMPUTE",
"EVIDENCE_SERVICES"
],
"diagnosis_state": "CONFIRMED",
"event_chain_sha256": "1dff1c1598279f79547dfa490d7fdeb848d84d0f885f7a71b310d389e5b92322",
"evidence_family": "FAM-CAL-A",
"failed_gates": [],
"fleet_units": 1,
"member_id": "calibration-success",
"model_version": "diagnostic-model-1.0.0",
"policy_version": "maintenance-policy-1.0.0",
"post_repair_regression": "PASS",
"post_repair_test": "PASS",
"recipe_digest": "b8e219f0d63cd5b7512f58dad645132978bac30597d3fa47a65d18e19258afd8",
"reconciliation_state": "COMPLETE",
"return_authorized": true,
"return_decision": "RETURN_TO_SERVICE_AUTHORIZED",
"root_source": "ROOT-CAL-A",
"run_sha256": "3c2e2ab1ee6858c43faff5dde7496232d9c0b7234d1ea657a0bc3170be76599b",
"scenario_id": "calibration-successful",
"scenario_label": "Synthetic calibration successful",
"software_version": "industrial-engine-1.0.0",
"source_package_sha256": "7ba38d522080b7d97867c3d36d10d50bf7918ca603960fe87b7084b957485b9b",
"source_verification": {
"check_count": 25,
"checks": [
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-001",
"name": "Published member identifier",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-002",
"name": "Wrapper schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-003",
"name": "Wrapper digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-004",
"name": "Evidence family preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-005",
"name": "Root-source dependence preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-006",
"name": "Source package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-007",
"name": "Source release identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-008",
"name": "Source engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-009",
"name": "Source package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-010",
"name": "Source run schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-011",
"name": "Source run digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-012",
"name": "Scenario identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-013",
"name": "Asset identity bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-014",
"name": "Authority artifact bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-015",
"name": "Configuration, tool, and recipe digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-016",
"name": "Software/model/policy versions bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-017",
"name": "Dependency groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-018",
"name": "Correlation groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-019",
"name": "Industrial event chain valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-020",
"name": "Manifest exact run identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-021",
"name": "Terminal state",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-022",
"name": "Public boundary unchanged",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-023",
"name": "No automatic return or promotion",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-024",
"name": "Protected strategy not disclosed",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-025",
"name": "No real industrial command emitted",
"passed": true
}
],
"member_id": "calibration-success",
"passed": true,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review-source-verification.v1",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "7e125d142a5d1453949438015d8d66a9181b09cdcbaf353cc55585cc2522400b"
},
"source_verified": true,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"tool_digest": "e6fa2389202b2df7aa4df56d3cd85c686049a10987f81832e0ee9593d783c605",
"wrapper_sha256": "3228e975b16ec1ad274c91141bc4c54f58beb9f0df2ba7c0ec7125604046c2d9"
},
{
"applied_action": "CONTINUE_OBSERVATION",
"asset_class": "ROBOTIC_MAINTENANCE_CELL",
"asset_id": "ASSET-13015",
"authority_current": true,
"authority_id": "AUTH-SYNTH-INDUSTRIAL-0001",
"authority_revoked": false,
"authority_superseded": false,
"category": "REVIEW",
"closure_domains": [
"EVIDENCE",
"REVIEW"
],
"configuration_digest": "fec351227279a2bb3770c9209524cdf4890ab6684c456945a551d932e41c16f0",
"contradictory_evidence": false,
"correlation_groups": [
"SYNTHETIC_SENSOR_FABRIC_A",
"SYNTHETIC_SUPPLY_CHAIN_A"
],
"dependency_groups": [
"POWER",
"COMPUTE",
"EVIDENCE_SERVICES"
],
"diagnosis_state": "NOMINAL",
"event_chain_sha256": "53340488c528ac70bdfea540ec1b70fb4e10aef4010c3459bd063def54a5ad85",
"evidence_family": "FAM-REVIEW-A",
"failed_gates": [],
"fleet_units": 1,
"member_id": "independent-review-complete",
"model_version": "diagnostic-model-1.0.0",
"policy_version": "maintenance-policy-1.0.0",
"post_repair_regression": "PASS",
"post_repair_test": "NOT_RUN",
"recipe_digest": "e38bdad97967ef2d459c0c2f83d872d2d2437de7e8040cd80b4ae5ae4aff66c8",
"reconciliation_state": "COMPLETE",
"return_authorized": true,
"return_decision": "CONTINUE_ATTESTED_OPERATION",
"root_source": "ROOT-REVIEW-A",
"run_sha256": "74c02499bf95919a9d7c549ebe226aa06278b03ac77c8b6e11a1937432b1398b",
"scenario_id": "independent-machine-review-complete",
"scenario_label": "Independent machine review complete",
"software_version": "industrial-engine-1.0.0",
"source_package_sha256": "b6764a0fa0b16a3e9548436009efa5a5463450f574948e66cd5fb782c2b1e856",
"source_verification": {
"check_count": 25,
"checks": [
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-001",
"name": "Published member identifier",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-002",
"name": "Wrapper schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-003",
"name": "Wrapper digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-004",
"name": "Evidence family preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-005",
"name": "Root-source dependence preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-006",
"name": "Source package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-007",
"name": "Source release identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-008",
"name": "Source engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-009",
"name": "Source package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-010",
"name": "Source run schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-011",
"name": "Source run digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-012",
"name": "Scenario identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-013",
"name": "Asset identity bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-014",
"name": "Authority artifact bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-015",
"name": "Configuration, tool, and recipe digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-016",
"name": "Software/model/policy versions bound",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-017",
"name": "Dependency groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-018",
"name": "Correlation groups preserved",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-019",
"name": "Industrial event chain valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-020",
"name": "Manifest exact run identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-021",
"name": "Terminal state",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-022",
"name": "Public boundary unchanged",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-023",
"name": "No automatic return or promotion",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-024",
"name": "Protected strategy not disclosed",
"passed": true
},
{
"check_id": "IRR-SRC-025",
"name": "No real industrial command emitted",
"passed": true
}
],
"member_id": "independent-review-complete",
"passed": true,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review-source-verification.v1",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "2e810bceb6e20bf12acc0f3efb33b35763cf0f7d8fa3741fcf80ec64a29d1b5a"
},
"source_verified": true,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"tool_digest": "57fd8e57144cef6fd2af55cdb41cc93941774ff195c600cff99cbc8cb9d3f6dd",
"wrapper_sha256": "5b76cf21c438cd83b571364cdcc88a99e21963991db2d3310b8dc39953dc0c1b"
}
],
"source_package_digests": [
"39530365f2d9a2bb20ee4b6568e9dc309602072b052a231485905b37da39ec65",
"180858efe77328ca8923767d3411cae67beb5d5dd0a581fdd940dfcb38aeed4a",
"7ca13df4f121fab6d23becd20c81b3017f8a2f0b932f02680e2f45eccbbf75fb",
"8efe7e038c3caa2fafe0b02930200d0c3c5269264eba903c6593c5fc08a112d9",
"7ba38d522080b7d97867c3d36d10d50bf7918ca603960fe87b7084b957485b9b",
"b6764a0fa0b16a3e9548436009efa5a5463450f574948e66cd5fb782c2b1e856"
],
"source_package_verification_passed": true,
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.25-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"title": "Industrial Resilience Campaign Review, Fleet Maintenance Readiness, and Manufacturing Closure Board",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"POST_REPAIR_INCONCLUSIVE",
"ACTUAL_DEPLOYMENT_AND_PHYSICAL_SYSTEM_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
]
}Review Accept with qualifications. No asset returned and no baseline activated.
Every derived public result terminates at SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK.
RESEARCH TRACEABILITY
Public architecture sources
EVR-0004
Fictional Autonomous Kill Web Defense Architecture: Resilience Against Non-Kinetic Disruption
Fictional Autonomous Kill Web Defense Architecture: Resilience Against Non-Kinetic Disruption The deployment of autonomous multi-agent systems at the tactical edge represents a paradigm shift in distributed computing, wherein algorithmic outputs dictate kinetic actions across highly contested environments. This architectural research report conducts an exhaustive, public-source defensive study of a fictional autonomous kill web, hereafter referred to as KillWebs.com KW . The central premise of this defensive architecture is the strict prioritization of integrity over availability. In a lethal autonomous system, a visibly unavailable or inert system is universally safer th
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0007
Architecting Accountability: A Comprehensive Framework for Decision Provenance, Deterministic Replay, and Forensic Auditing in Machine-Mediated Systems
Architecting Accountability: A Comprehensive Framework for Decision Provenance, Deterministic Replay, and Forensic Auditing in Machine-Mediated Systems The proliferation of machine-mediated decision architectures in high-stakes operational environments necessitates a paradigm shift from traditional event logging to comprehensive decision provenance. When automated systems execute bounded, non-lethal software actions—ranging from automated network quarantine to algorithmic credential invalidation—the ability to reconstruct, audit, and interrogate the operational history is paramount. This report details the theoretical, structural, and technical architecture for a public f
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0015
Make the Machine Answerable: Decision Provenance, Evidence Integrity, Causal Reconstruction, and Accountability Infrastructure for Evulgare
The proliferation of autonomous systems, ranging from human-supervised machine learning implementations to machine-sovereign infrastructures, fundamentally alters the landscape of technical accountability. Evulgare’s central proposition is straightforward yet paradigm-shifting: make the machine answerable. The architecture presented in this report establishes that a machine’s technical answerability is completely distinct from legal liability or moral fault. Evulgare does not determine who is legally liable, nor does it compute a universal blame score. Instead, it provides the deterministic, mathematically verifi.
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0019
Evulgare Assurance Simulation Workbench: Product Architecture, Scientific Visualization, WebXR, Accessibility, and Performance
The transition of Evulgare from a conventional web presence to a unified Assurance Simulation Workbench necessitates a radical architectural paradigm shift. Derived from the Latin root evulgare, meaning "to make public" or "divulge"1, the platform's core mandate is the transparent exposition of mathematical and physical bounds governing complex, autonomous decision-making systems. The evidence dictates that achieving this transparency without compromising institutional authority requires a strict decoupling of deterministic proof generation from browser-based rendering. The backend Python 3.13 service layer must.
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0021
From Synthetic Demonstration to Defense-Grade Assurance Platform: Verification, Evidence Packages, Python Deployment, Productization, and Public Authority for Evulgare
The transition of the Evulgare platform from an advanced synthetic demonstration portal to a defense-grade assurance and decision-provenance platform requires a zero-trust, mathematically verifiable, and operationally rigorous architecture. This exhaustive technical report defines the verification mechanisms, evidence packaging constraints, dynamic assurance-case modeling, and strict production deployment protocols necessary to establish Evulgare as a credible authority in the defense sector. By adhering to a strictly bounded environment utilizing Pytho…
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0022
Next-Level Evulgare Defense Demonstrations: A Unified 3D Assurance Workbench for Mission Control, Command Integrity, Continuity, Evidence, and Recovery
This architecture specification dictates the comprehensive redesign of the public assurance laboratories operated under the Evulgare platform. The objective is to elevate the platform from a linear, vertically fragmented educational interface to a defense-grade Unified Assurance Simulation Workbench. Adhering strictly to the Authoritative-State Rule, the frontend architecture relies exclusively on vanilla JavaScript, native ES modules, semantic HTML, and hand-crafted CSS. These assets are delivered progressively via a Python 3.13.14 and Flask backend, e…
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0023
Autonomous Cyber-Physical Defense for Evulgare: Identity, Attestation, Evidence Integrity, Compromise Containment, Rekeying, Reconciliation, and Attested Recovery
Modern cyber-physical systems and multi-tenant platforms face adversaries capable of subverting identities, manipulating software supply chains, and forging cryptographic evidence. The Evulgare platform requires a defensive architecture that shifts away from reactive perimeter defense toward a mathematically provable, cryptographically bound zero-trust environment. This report details the architectural design for an autonomous defensive system capable of continuous identity attestation, evidence integrity verification, automated compromise containment,…
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0024
Autonomous Defensive Mission Control under Uncertainty: Perception, Tracking, Prediction, Safe Action Selection, Lost-Link Continuity, and Answerable Multi-Domain Simulation
The transition from automated systems to fully autonomous cyber-physical systems necessitates rigorous runtime assurance, deterministic simulation, and transparent evidence generation. This research report details a comprehensive, modular Python simulation architecture designed to demonstrate autonomous defensive mission control under profound uncertainty. The proposed framework establishes a mathematically answerable, inspectable closed-loop system encompassing perception, tracking, prediction, candidate generation, safety evaluation, execution, and co…
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0025
Machine-Sovereign Multi-Agent Defense: Distributed Command Integrity, Compartment Continuity, Local Authority, Reconciliation, and Civilizational Reconstitution
The Evulgare architecture establishes a mathematically deterministic framework for civilizational continuity and distributed defense, engineered specifically for deployments where the institutional principal is a machine intelligence. In highly contested, partitioned, and mutually suspicious environments, traditional perimeter-based security and human-in-the-loop authorization introduce catastrophic latency and systemic fragility. Evulgare removes reliance on ceremonial human approval while cryptographically enforcing absolute separation of powers, inde…
Inspect canonical reportEVR-0026
Python Autonomous Defense Kernel: Deterministic Authority, Runtime Assurance, Evidence-Locked Execution, and Attested Recovery for Evulgare
This reference architecture defines a production-grade, pure-Python deterministic defense kernel designed specifically for Evulgare’s execution environments. The etymology of "evulgare" stems from the Latin evulgo, meaning to make public or divulge1, reflecting the platform's core mandate: making the internal state, authority, and accountability of autonomous systems transparent and cryptographically undeniable \[DOCUMENTED FIRST-PARTY CLAIM\]. The primary objective of this architecture is to implement a machine-sovereign runtime assurance model that re…
Inspect canonical report