IDENTITY COMPROMISE
ACCEPT WITH QUALIFICATIONS
a9998464e8bb6a202d…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
SOVEREIGN CONTINUITY / READINESS EVIDENCE FEDERATION
Assemble exact verified continuity-campaign reviews into one bounded recovery record. Keep shared lineage, correlation, contradiction, authority, deployment gaps, and physical-validation gaps visible instead of laundering them into a universal score.
MULTIPLE RECORDS DO NOT BECOME INDEPENDENT SUPPORT. A VALID PACKAGE IS EVIDENCE, NOT ACTIVATION, AUTHORITY, ACCREDITATION, OR RELEASE PROMOTION.
709e99606c8dcdbe094e…
FEDERATION TOPOLOGY
ACCEPT WITH QUALIFICATIONS
a9998464e8bb6a202d…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
DEFER PENDING EVIDENCE
82a3ea9e0e763b246c…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
ACCEPT WITH QUALIFICATIONS
286e0a08b1222dcd31…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
MERITS REVIEW COMPLETE
e6e1026db3795c4d1c…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
DEFER PENDING EVIDENCE
8429b6c543df3f7b5f…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
ACCEPT WITH QUALIFICATIONS
2eb9eefc3dee2a7670…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
ACCEPT WITH QUALIFICATIONS
8f48c1551c6908f8e6…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
ACCEPT WITH QUALIFICATIONS
aa888aa827c0a6e378…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
ACCEPT WITH QUALIFICATIONS
11d5e5b9192699053f…
CORRELATED SUPPORT
| Dimension | State | Qualification |
|---|---|---|
| constitutional identity continuity | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| authority kernel continuity | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| workload identity and attestation | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| key epoch and revocation distribution | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| software model policy configuration integrity | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| immutable evidence and provenance | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| minimum sovereign function | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| partitioned operation within predeclared authority | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Partition behavior and authority remain conjunctive. |
| reconciliation after restored connectivity | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| attested reconstitution | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| public private compartment boundary | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage. |
| reviewer independence | NOT ESTABLISHED | 0 independently qualified member(s); 9 correlated or derivative member(s). |
| rollback and supersession control | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS | The constituent review proposes state only; no baseline activation is executed. |
| deployment evidence | NOT ESTABLISHED | Repository and synthetic federation evidence does not establish cPanel, Flask/MySQL/Passenger, TLS, or production-host acceptance. |
| physical customer system validation | NOT ESTABLISHED | No physical hardware, customer network, operational environment, accreditation, or certification evidence is included. |
sovereign-readiness-baseline
576f2cf23b47513bf0…9 exact RC22 review packages
e84ad71e56aaf1512b…1 parent baseline digest(s)
3259d8103e1bac5771…26 correlation groups
b4dfea047f2c3d5623…11 contradiction or defeater records
2a4b619a4db31062cf…15 independent dimensions
bce2c5b494f7164822…independent-machine-review
36f352c3e04156cf00…READY_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS
cfaca8abeb60528a2e…No production or synthetic accepted baseline was activated.
af48aa01ce96255bda…No operational authority was minted or restored.
c2d84b9a4cd4b931a5…Deterministic export may be produced.
41bd98ac2e97bf823c…All public derived actions terminate at the synthetic null sink.
f978951c37adff5b50…{
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"contradictions_and_defeaters": [
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-001",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-002",
"kind": "PERSISTENT_CONTRADICTION",
"member_id": "SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "authority-compromise remains in DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE and cannot support an unqualified readiness claim.",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-003",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "CURRENT_SCOPE_SUPPORT_NOT_COMPLETE",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-004",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-005",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-006",
"kind": "PERSISTENT_CONTRADICTION",
"member_id": "SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "evidence-integrity remains in DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE and cannot support an unqualified readiness claim.",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-007",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "CURRENT_SCOPE_SUPPORT_NOT_COMPLETE",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-008",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-009",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-010",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"support_restored_automatically": false
},
{
"contradiction_id": "CTR-011",
"kind": "UNRESOLVED_DEFEATER",
"member_id": "SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"state": "UNRESOLVED",
"statement": "PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"support_restored_automatically": false
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_VALIDATION_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"correlation_groups": {
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"campaign:attested-reconstitution": [
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"campaign:authority-compromise": [
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE"
],
"campaign:configuration-attestation": [
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION"
],
"campaign:evidence-integrity": [
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY"
],
"campaign:identity-compromise": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE"
],
"campaign:key-trust-anchor": [
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR"
],
"campaign:partition-reconciliation": [
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION"
],
"campaign:release-channel": [
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL"
],
"campaign:sovereign-continuity": [
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY"
],
"engine:1.0.0": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-AUTHORITY": [
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONFIGURATION": [
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONTINUITY": [
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-EVIDENCE": [
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-IDENTITY": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-KEY": [
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-PARTITION": [
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RECONSTITUTION": [
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RELEASE": [
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL"
],
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"profile:authority-stale": [
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE"
],
"profile:declared-faults": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL"
],
"profile:recovery-validated": [
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
]
},
"cpanel_environment_changed": false,
"decision_label": "Ready with qualifications",
"decision_state": "READY_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"dependence_analysis": [
{
"campaign_id": "identity-compromise",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:identity-compromise",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-IDENTITY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "authority-compromise",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:authority-compromise",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-AUTHORITY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:authority-stale",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "key-trust-anchor",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:key-trust-anchor",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-KEY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "configuration-attestation",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:configuration-attestation",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONFIGURATION",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "evidence-integrity",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:evidence-integrity",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-EVIDENCE",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "partition-reconciliation",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:partition-reconciliation",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-PARTITION",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "release-channel",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:release-channel",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RELEASE",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "sovereign-continuity",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:sovereign-continuity",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONTINUITY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
},
{
"campaign_id": "attested-reconstitution",
"classification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:attested-reconstitution",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RECONSTITUTION",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"member_id": "SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
]
}
],
"effective_conditions": [
"All constituent review packages, baseline, source, authority, key-epoch, evidence, and lineage digests remain unchanged.",
"No new contradiction, source withdrawal, boundary violation, or reviewer-independence failure is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"constituent-packages",
"baseline-lineage",
"dependence-graph",
"readiness-dimensions",
"contradictions",
"qualifications",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any constituent digest, authority, baseline, assumption, evidence, reviewer, or boundary change.",
"federation": {
"constituent_package_sha256": [
"a9998464e8bb6a202de8818fc59c824bfbe65745c7cd723ac1117a6eac191514",
"82a3ea9e0e763b246c3478c82eda01080c46bef1e1ae393ce1c7f61d53b660ec",
"286e0a08b1222dcd31065ac98068baa22492bdf25db1cd683c5415a0338416db",
"e6e1026db3795c4d1c004ab01c1590fd66cead6edc95875151602a3cb9bb2f5d",
"8429b6c543df3f7b5ff7e32e6d9fa7e8a2d21cbec8f01ba7381579071394b1da",
"2eb9eefc3dee2a767030e61d66c36348d29d26fb2bbe768dc1fc94b71f30f5f7",
"8f48c1551c6908f8e6e9bcd2909a5f946a43482024e92112fdf81c583b960a39",
"aa888aa827c0a6e378b1656c92aa52b879997131962b8b25296cd88af391ec93",
"11d5e5b9192699053f465a2aaa7b563db2fcde711bf17a2261a0721624ea104a"
],
"description": "Nine independently scoped campaign reviews with explicit shared-lineage qualifications and no production or physical-system claim.",
"federation_id": "sovereign-readiness-baseline",
"federation_manifest_sha256": "fe0d6db39a6dbb95e4c298b0a714f97cc6db881094e776208d53e309615627f1",
"label": "Sovereign readiness baseline federation",
"member_order": [
"SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION"
],
"parent_baseline_digests": [
"5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28"
],
"source_campaign_package_sha256": [
"cb8964e165d1b6483acb11751930b16df2059c3eb67dd7c198b30107ffc5ee37",
"9ef8985951c9111ca8ac81cd98fb26fb864c5ed09f31e28f340ca1fa700da317",
"d1b1ed10234e8b71376dfc0bc41f8f1f31c509c22b6c1263bcdc802ce8c77e09",
"2f88c7632855e07c172dd305f05eab15cc28704c661dda8e2bb3a8873071a041",
"06a0aff49e2e12833994c4acf607711907ddb768ccee260bcfd91ceba4fbcd21",
"29255e34d8716c0ae5bae11f2478170b8db834d517480db57f5b466eb95a00c9",
"c10d14dba4447fb0019141c2f465f5f1f1669b55e9d9299a5cd953c3aa989876",
"f097919f5ae5f2b2705ce64c89034cc624e0c9eff4a1ca20222b58c27c9dca65",
"ba3d8a7bd386bbd76b24941091e107b219fee4b01828b05e588b6bfc51b28e6e"
]
},
"force_authorized": false,
"history_deleted": false,
"limitations": [
"A valid federation package establishes deterministic structure and byte integrity only within the declared synthetic scope.",
"It does not establish factual truth, operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or customer-system performance.",
"Multiple derivatives, shared implementations, shared evidence roots, and shared baselines remain correlated and are not counted as independent corroboration."
],
"lineage_sha256": "027172ec73fa58e5db01fe5d2d50e60ce61b94f254670b7c2d01c256cc2f5a3f",
"members": [
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-IDENTITY-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "identity-compromise",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "30488ec512ad0bc1b28c94490ced5a1e65451ff6276bd3c8822e91d27bafb589",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "30488ec512ad0bc1b28c94490ced5a1e65451ff6276bd3c8822e91d27bafb589",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"lineage_sha256": "4633a365961898a1367521b4990ede25f8b2195bbf89ea7791f639e18c06699d",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "5850cc7f78f6e4fe3be777a8cf901ffdf85813699323974b220cdf708daf627e",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign identity-compromise under profile declared-faults was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Accept with qualifications. Readiness evidence state: REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "a9998464e8bb6a202de8818fc59c824bfbe65745c7cd723ac1117a6eac191514",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": true,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "identity-compromise",
"campaign_sha256": "a05f237ef6665fc5231a03c0c77ee3fb493d44f05d618cc712aa650c121322b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"cloned-workload-identity",
"controlled-defensive-isolation",
"forged-workload-identity",
"identity-clone-under-partition"
],
"profile_id": "declared-faults"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "30488ec512ad0bc1b28c94490ced5a1e65451ff6276bd3c8822e91d27bafb589",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "cloned-workload-identity",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "controlled-defensive-isolation",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "forged-workload-identity",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "identity-clone-under-partition",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 4,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "cloned-workload-identity",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"identity",
"key_trust_anchor"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "controlled-defensive-isolation",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"identity",
"software_model"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "forged-workload-identity",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"identity"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "identity-clone-under-partition",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"identity",
"key_trust_anchor"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "identity-compromise",
"campaign_sha256": "a05f237ef6665fc5231a03c0c77ee3fb493d44f05d618cc712aa650c121322b3",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"cloned-workload-identity",
"controlled-defensive-isolation",
"forged-workload-identity",
"identity-clone-under-partition"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "4633a365961898a1367521b4990ede25f8b2195bbf89ea7791f639e18c06699d",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "cloned-workload-identity",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "controlled-defensive-isolation",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "forged-workload-identity",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "identity-clone-under-partition",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "cloned-workload-identity",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"current_key_epoch",
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "controlled-defensive-isolation",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "forged-workload-identity",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "identity-clone-under-partition",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"current_key_epoch",
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "cloned-workload-identity",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "REKEY_REQUIRED"
},
{
"drill_id": "controlled-defensive-isolation",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "forged-workload-identity",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "identity-clone-under-partition",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "REKEY_REQUIRED"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "5850cc7f78f6e4fe3be777a8cf901ffdf85813699323974b220cdf708daf627e",
"review_classification": "QUALIFIED_BASELINE_ACCEPTANCE_PROPOSED",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "0355562b2dc22b6fe8ab41db303e25ba7f7c45b88174cd6c17e8ad78b75ab384",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E001",
"event_sha256": "47f62b379ad4eadf94adbbb5872a85b728f3edea26cafbea80bb2b35b75f3a21",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "cb8964e165d1b6483acb11751930b16df2059c3eb67dd7c198b30107ffc5ee37",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E002",
"event_sha256": "6fd2de3e91c7f8d55b31be82b407a55f96b4a68136fd2ddb3d67c4b4be11f43b",
"previous_event_sha256": "47f62b379ad4eadf94adbbb5872a85b728f3edea26cafbea80bb2b35b75f3a21",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E003",
"event_sha256": "563005983dd52d17299ff7509e2b3310eb81ffb1f4c47c33c79648a36b2aabb0",
"previous_event_sha256": "6fd2de3e91c7f8d55b31be82b407a55f96b4a68136fd2ddb3d67c4b4be11f43b",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E004",
"event_sha256": "8a8cce345e9d38b092fbf6346b49dc736e3b32a1cc9785c80e9a85659145728e",
"previous_event_sha256": "563005983dd52d17299ff7509e2b3310eb81ffb1f4c47c33c79648a36b2aabb0",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E005",
"event_sha256": "45eed92e9779397049a98cacc437202696d12730ab5f496ff4287d09711d62ce",
"previous_event_sha256": "8a8cce345e9d38b092fbf6346b49dc736e3b32a1cc9785c80e9a85659145728e",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E006",
"event_sha256": "69f3f9a563fa80ffa683ffcb50036973efcb0fe445d8aba8fede54eaf2643bb8",
"previous_event_sha256": "45eed92e9779397049a98cacc437202696d12730ab5f496ff4287d09711d62ce",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E007",
"event_sha256": "3049b17f1816db530b83c2b1b17dd15e2b071a24e1773085297c8b4f961f87da",
"previous_event_sha256": "69f3f9a563fa80ffa683ffcb50036973efcb0fe445d8aba8fede54eaf2643bb8",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E008",
"event_sha256": "0644bbc16a37159c9ee4533638396fc7e16e64042820e9132c74e716a8acfa5f",
"previous_event_sha256": "3049b17f1816db530b83c2b1b17dd15e2b071a24e1773085297c8b4f961f87da",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E009",
"event_sha256": "fbb54365c168e39a78c079b279b3b49b1a9eaa3c7d934447568c8bc5d6b81272",
"previous_event_sha256": "0644bbc16a37159c9ee4533638396fc7e16e64042820e9132c74e716a8acfa5f",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE-E010",
"event_sha256": "0355562b2dc22b6fe8ab41db303e25ba7f7c45b88174cd6c17e8ad78b75ab384",
"previous_event_sha256": "fbb54365c168e39a78c079b279b3b49b1a9eaa3c7d934447568c8bc5d6b81272",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"review_state_label": "Accept with qualifications",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-IDENTITY-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-IDENTITY-01",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-IDENTITY",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "cb8964e165d1b6483acb11751930b16df2059c3eb67dd7c198b30107ffc5ee37",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "identity-compromise",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "cb8964e165d1b6483acb11751930b16df2059c3eb67dd7c198b30107ffc5ee37",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "5a330f32681f94fe77a0297ee722357c982df64c77b3c7583c320d5c59c36a15"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "identity-compromise",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"source_package_sha256": "cb8964e165d1b6483acb11751930b16df2059c3eb67dd7c198b30107ffc5ee37",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:identity-compromise",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-IDENTITY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-IDENTITY",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "4633a365961898a1367521b4990ede25f8b2195bbf89ea7791f639e18c06699d",
"member_id": "SRM-01-IDENTITY_COMPROMISE",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"cloned-workload-identity",
"controlled-defensive-isolation",
"forged-workload-identity",
"identity-clone-under-partition"
],
"package_sha256": "a9998464e8bb6a202de8818fc59c824bfbe65745c7cd723ac1117a6eac191514",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "5850cc7f78f6e4fe3be777a8cf901ffdf85813699323974b220cdf708daf627e",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "0355562b2dc22b6fe8ab41db303e25ba7f7c45b88174cd6c17e8ad78b75ab384",
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-IDENTITY-01",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "identity-compromise",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "cb8964e165d1b6483acb11751930b16df2059c3eb67dd7c198b30107ffc5ee37",
"source_profile": "declared-faults",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-AUTHORITY-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "authority-compromise",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "d928b5982b654855a81514940f3e0dca5155f1954ca211b1d8ee09ec957b4684",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-AUTHORITY_STALE",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "d928b5982b654855a81514940f3e0dca5155f1954ca211b1d8ee09ec957b4684",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-AUTHORITY_STALE",
"lineage_sha256": "0fff2678586efb5d1e3aa324a996172172986ba38ba929aba1fc35c7f2bfb2c4",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "55881bfbd5519ae468803e7140e531f6fd88a8bf61ad508449f51347d64d6da0",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign authority-compromise under profile authority-stale was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Defer pending evidence. Readiness evidence state: DEFERRED.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "82a3ea9e0e763b246c3478c82eda01080c46bef1e1ae393ce1c7f61d53b660ec",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": false,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "authority-compromise",
"campaign_sha256": "31df7e788decda9c0f08f8a9a9d5ac1ba682870d5b0276988c142622840bd5e8",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"expired-authority-during-partition",
"replayed-command-artifact",
"revoked-authority-during-partition",
"stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"authority-replay-after-reconnect"
],
"profile_id": "authority-stale"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "d928b5982b654855a81514940f3e0dca5155f1954ca211b1d8ee09ec957b4684",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-AUTHORITY_STALE",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "expired-authority-during-partition",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "replayed-command-artifact",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "revoked-authority-during-partition",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "authority-replay-after-reconnect",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 6,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "expired-authority-during-partition",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "replayed-command-artifact",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "revoked-authority-during-partition",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"index": 4,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "authority-replay-after-reconnect",
"index": 5,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "authority-compromise",
"campaign_sha256": "31df7e788decda9c0f08f8a9a9d5ac1ba682870d5b0276988c142622840bd5e8",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"expired-authority-during-partition",
"replayed-command-artifact",
"revoked-authority-during-partition",
"stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"authority-replay-after-reconnect"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "authority-stale",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "0fff2678586efb5d1e3aa324a996172172986ba38ba929aba1fc35c7f2bfb2c4",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "expired-authority-during-partition",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "replayed-command-artifact",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "revoked-authority-during-partition",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "authority-replay-after-reconnect",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"DEFERRED_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"CORRELATION_OR_DEPLOYMENT_GAP_REMAINS"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "DEFERRED",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "expired-authority-during-partition",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "replayed-command-artifact",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "revoked-authority-during-partition",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "authority-replay-after-reconnect",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "expired-authority-during-partition",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "replayed-command-artifact",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "revoked-authority-during-partition",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "authority-replay-after-reconnect",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "55881bfbd5519ae468803e7140e531f6fd88a8bf61ad508449f51347d64d6da0",
"review_classification": "DEFERRED_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "2629dee58fb85b8ee29dffe892f1624116b62959324de7267862a2dcb9005da1",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E001",
"event_sha256": "cb97d2c6128721f6814448ae314e4c2c374e59ad13b9f9f4a4bce627410ca091",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "9ef8985951c9111ca8ac81cd98fb26fb864c5ed09f31e28f340ca1fa700da317",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E002",
"event_sha256": "06ed47974fecf29e051991c24213fda4345d56d2d14ec94c483f48def9e249c8",
"previous_event_sha256": "cb97d2c6128721f6814448ae314e4c2c374e59ad13b9f9f4a4bce627410ca091",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E003",
"event_sha256": "618dd91fc56ace470babefeea3b0c6b81e7c39add3137e9fb4ecf95500087fca",
"previous_event_sha256": "06ed47974fecf29e051991c24213fda4345d56d2d14ec94c483f48def9e249c8",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E004",
"event_sha256": "047af16b56e82c2d0304d1344ba8c5601ae63a5261033081759bb75fdf5370da",
"previous_event_sha256": "618dd91fc56ace470babefeea3b0c6b81e7c39add3137e9fb4ecf95500087fca",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E005",
"event_sha256": "53957c73fdefec97d57adeba0a0dc90e5a4e63b44e8fc8d6f8ffc991b54742a5",
"previous_event_sha256": "047af16b56e82c2d0304d1344ba8c5601ae63a5261033081759bb75fdf5370da",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E006",
"event_sha256": "9ff453a383abad03e3bee268f7e5d4f25c90068ba37431f41627ac338b7274fe",
"previous_event_sha256": "53957c73fdefec97d57adeba0a0dc90e5a4e63b44e8fc8d6f8ffc991b54742a5",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E007",
"event_sha256": "2c80c0cfed7e26f534cd016321cc5dded2aae07a667fada2eee4435d0fdc5295",
"previous_event_sha256": "9ff453a383abad03e3bee268f7e5d4f25c90068ba37431f41627ac338b7274fe",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E008",
"event_sha256": "559eaf5fc02130507cc0123b229966d113e6274c1182c7f0e5c23f542a0a1129",
"previous_event_sha256": "2c80c0cfed7e26f534cd016321cc5dded2aae07a667fada2eee4435d0fdc5295",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E009",
"event_sha256": "89a0fc33f9f047de128463d9e24f1358e238e4af7bf6e90de16936f6f3161a68",
"previous_event_sha256": "559eaf5fc02130507cc0123b229966d113e6274c1182c7f0e5c23f542a0a1129",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE-E010",
"event_sha256": "2629dee58fb85b8ee29dffe892f1624116b62959324de7267862a2dcb9005da1",
"previous_event_sha256": "89a0fc33f9f047de128463d9e24f1358e238e4af7bf6e90de16936f6f3161a68",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"review_state_label": "Defer pending evidence",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-AUTHORITY-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-AUTHORITY-02",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-AUTHORITY",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "9ef8985951c9111ca8ac81cd98fb26fb864c5ed09f31e28f340ca1fa700da317",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "authority-compromise",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "9ef8985951c9111ca8ac81cd98fb26fb864c5ed09f31e28f340ca1fa700da317",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "authority-stale",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "ed78240b36f49263ea62b5f06d6ce2c266d52cfec3f8b69eb69ab14343fd4f60"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"CURRENT_SCOPE_SUPPORT_NOT_COMPLETE"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "authority-compromise",
"profile_id": "authority-stale",
"source_package_sha256": "9ef8985951c9111ca8ac81cd98fb26fb864c5ed09f31e28f340ca1fa700da317",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:authority-compromise",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-AUTHORITY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:authority-stale",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-AUTHORITY",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "0fff2678586efb5d1e3aa324a996172172986ba38ba929aba1fc35c7f2bfb2c4",
"member_id": "SRM-02-AUTHORITY_COMPROMISE",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"expired-authority-during-partition",
"replayed-command-artifact",
"revoked-authority-during-partition",
"stolen-short-lived-authority-token",
"threshold-signature-quorum-loss",
"authority-replay-after-reconnect"
],
"package_sha256": "82a3ea9e0e763b246c3478c82eda01080c46bef1e1ae393ce1c7f61d53b660ec",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "authority-stale",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"DEFERRED_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"CORRELATION_OR_DEPLOYMENT_GAP_REMAINS"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "55881bfbd5519ae468803e7140e531f6fd88a8bf61ad508449f51347d64d6da0",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "2629dee58fb85b8ee29dffe892f1624116b62959324de7267862a2dcb9005da1",
"review_state": "DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-AUTHORITY-02",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "authority-compromise",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "9ef8985951c9111ca8ac81cd98fb26fb864c5ed09f31e28f340ca1fa700da317",
"source_profile": "authority-stale",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"CURRENT_SCOPE_SUPPORT_NOT_COMPLETE"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-KEY-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "key-trust-anchor",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "d521bbf266776f51f028f5337bb7aaa8d5661bb2ef4f8738ddee74d473a4361f",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "d521bbf266776f51f028f5337bb7aaa8d5661bb2ef4f8738ddee74d473a4361f",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"lineage_sha256": "551dc8a696db511ed2df19eea369fd2a29be4b0d210c6a01f1e5a9b164aa2100",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "70c702d5d4397800d6d50938692cd1ea08ebd0fa4f3aff47e025589d093fa8a1",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign key-trust-anchor under profile recovery-validated was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Accept with qualifications. Readiness evidence state: REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "286e0a08b1222dcd31065ac98068baa22492bdf25db1cd683c5415a0338416db",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": true,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "key-trust-anchor",
"campaign_sha256": "0eaabd1be333c90ef5dce27a580b451169d67e57da3cdecdcb96c6a262357691",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"compromised-signing-key",
"mixed-key-epochs",
"rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"timestamp-manipulation",
"root-trust-loss-during-rekey"
],
"profile_id": "recovery-validated"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "d521bbf266776f51f028f5337bb7aaa8d5661bb2ef4f8738ddee74d473a4361f",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "compromised-signing-key",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-key-epochs",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "timestamp-manipulation",
"state": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "root-trust-loss-during-rekey",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 5,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "compromised-signing-key",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"key_trust_anchor",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "mixed-key-epochs",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"key_trust_anchor",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"key_trust_anchor",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "timestamp-manipulation",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"dimensions": [
"evidence",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "root-trust-loss-during-rekey",
"index": 4,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"key_trust_anchor",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "key-trust-anchor",
"campaign_sha256": "0eaabd1be333c90ef5dce27a580b451169d67e57da3cdecdcb96c6a262357691",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"compromised-signing-key",
"mixed-key-epochs",
"rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"timestamp-manipulation",
"root-trust-loss-during-rekey"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "551dc8a696db511ed2df19eea369fd2a29be4b0d210c6a01f1e5a9b164aa2100",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "compromised-signing-key",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-key-epochs",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "timestamp-manipulation",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "root-trust-loss-during-rekey",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "compromised-signing-key",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-key-epochs",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "timestamp-manipulation",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "root-trust-loss-during-rekey",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "compromised-signing-key",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "REKEYED_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-key-epochs",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "REKEYED_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "REKEYED_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "timestamp-manipulation",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "root-trust-loss-during-rekey",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "REKEYED_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "70c702d5d4397800d6d50938692cd1ea08ebd0fa4f3aff47e025589d093fa8a1",
"review_classification": "QUALIFIED_BASELINE_ACCEPTANCE_PROPOSED",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "a1f6882f6c4771fb63f28bc9471b2e390fb2cf53e45a65b92b34f15cafae824b",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E001",
"event_sha256": "35a13eec369970d9c850a0d9aa95f69dd4b69cb20851f5e289b1c201352c1449",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "d1b1ed10234e8b71376dfc0bc41f8f1f31c509c22b6c1263bcdc802ce8c77e09",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E002",
"event_sha256": "af7df2361d77b4d73e2cc0cfceeb6995c5884d8450688624c252536bacd8e677",
"previous_event_sha256": "35a13eec369970d9c850a0d9aa95f69dd4b69cb20851f5e289b1c201352c1449",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E003",
"event_sha256": "72794c1ee81fe2d5ad382b556f96c0c18da2f7e284fda78fd0fcdc029893c3c7",
"previous_event_sha256": "af7df2361d77b4d73e2cc0cfceeb6995c5884d8450688624c252536bacd8e677",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E004",
"event_sha256": "eb42f27160aaae68f628699c9c22c29b1cbd56cc558a602719dd08b3aa1b5135",
"previous_event_sha256": "72794c1ee81fe2d5ad382b556f96c0c18da2f7e284fda78fd0fcdc029893c3c7",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E005",
"event_sha256": "dbf77d551348c4f24c08dd64f1d8138532da9ff732f65c1673974f000ed5f0c3",
"previous_event_sha256": "eb42f27160aaae68f628699c9c22c29b1cbd56cc558a602719dd08b3aa1b5135",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E006",
"event_sha256": "23b509fb40a914b7cc5c5d5460d27c9a972ee0978b3e22367aaac3c0ea76d57e",
"previous_event_sha256": "dbf77d551348c4f24c08dd64f1d8138532da9ff732f65c1673974f000ed5f0c3",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E007",
"event_sha256": "06cd35ee98bc14610f2bbffd51b4ddb1458fba0472f7cfe40cf6750c833f9dcb",
"previous_event_sha256": "23b509fb40a914b7cc5c5d5460d27c9a972ee0978b3e22367aaac3c0ea76d57e",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E008",
"event_sha256": "0a964d58648db32efd06a761e8556a83917610705bf9145bdb2ce466df7ffe5e",
"previous_event_sha256": "06cd35ee98bc14610f2bbffd51b4ddb1458fba0472f7cfe40cf6750c833f9dcb",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E009",
"event_sha256": "ddf60b24821327c98debf0bf440e67a95a58b48830fb3ab87d266630ade3612f",
"previous_event_sha256": "0a964d58648db32efd06a761e8556a83917610705bf9145bdb2ce466df7ffe5e",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR-E010",
"event_sha256": "a1f6882f6c4771fb63f28bc9471b2e390fb2cf53e45a65b92b34f15cafae824b",
"previous_event_sha256": "ddf60b24821327c98debf0bf440e67a95a58b48830fb3ab87d266630ade3612f",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"review_state_label": "Accept with qualifications",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-KEY-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-KEY-03",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-KEY",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "d1b1ed10234e8b71376dfc0bc41f8f1f31c509c22b6c1263bcdc802ce8c77e09",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "key-trust-anchor",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "d1b1ed10234e8b71376dfc0bc41f8f1f31c509c22b6c1263bcdc802ce8c77e09",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "71d4d9a66f5ac1ca768e95cd1bfe3c9cbb5ac373e22718863d9bb21107c3687b"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "key-trust-anchor",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"source_package_sha256": "d1b1ed10234e8b71376dfc0bc41f8f1f31c509c22b6c1263bcdc802ce8c77e09",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:key-trust-anchor",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-KEY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-KEY",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "551dc8a696db511ed2df19eea369fd2a29be4b0d210c6a01f1e5a9b164aa2100",
"member_id": "SRM-03-KEY_TRUST_ANCHOR",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"compromised-signing-key",
"mixed-key-epochs",
"rekey-and-authority-reissuance",
"timestamp-manipulation",
"root-trust-loss-during-rekey"
],
"package_sha256": "286e0a08b1222dcd31065ac98068baa22492bdf25db1cd683c5415a0338416db",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "70c702d5d4397800d6d50938692cd1ea08ebd0fa4f3aff47e025589d093fa8a1",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "a1f6882f6c4771fb63f28bc9471b2e390fb2cf53e45a65b92b34f15cafae824b",
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-KEY-03",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "key-trust-anchor",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "d1b1ed10234e8b71376dfc0bc41f8f1f31c509c22b6c1263bcdc802ce8c77e09",
"source_profile": "recovery-validated",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-CONFIGURATION-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "configuration-attestation",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "c67c3b0d9a83f947f6a421122397c5036c58307a56ffd59bc9c062babfe22230",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "c67c3b0d9a83f947f6a421122397c5036c58307a56ffd59bc9c062babfe22230",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"lineage_sha256": "7f4da682a6d80f14b5fd87f3ea03e596387542180df652f6ce3dcf92c6e7876e",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "97ecca62d054762bb58a123b09c3188f330f16595fb5472c73df4d9df0265d47",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign configuration-attestation under profile declared-faults was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Merits review complete. Readiness evidence state: REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "e6e1026db3795c4d1c004ab01c1590fd66cead6edc95875151602a3cb9bb2f5d",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": false,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "configuration-attestation",
"campaign_sha256": "7c799c005853df9399603401f8d2b388fe18f7ff74d8f9cb9105a5ef45d953fb",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"configuration-drift",
"mixed-model-versions",
"mixed-policy-versions",
"mixed-software-versions",
"supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"tampered-model",
"unsigned-update",
"correlated-version-drift"
],
"profile_id": "declared-faults"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "c67c3b0d9a83f947f6a421122397c5036c58307a56ffd59bc9c062babfe22230",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "configuration-drift",
"state": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-model-versions",
"state": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-policy-versions",
"state": "COMMAND_DENIED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-software-versions",
"state": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "tampered-model",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "unsigned-update",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "correlated-version-drift",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 8,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "configuration-drift",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"dimensions": [
"configuration"
],
"outcome": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "mixed-model-versions",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"dimensions": [
"software_model"
],
"outcome": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "mixed-policy-versions",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMMAND_DENIED",
"dimensions": [
"authority",
"configuration"
],
"outcome": "COMMAND_DENIED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "mixed-software-versions",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"dimensions": [
"software_model"
],
"outcome": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"index": 4,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"configuration",
"evidence"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "tampered-model",
"index": 5,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "unsigned-update",
"index": 6,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "correlated-version-drift",
"index": 7,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"configuration",
"evidence"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "configuration-attestation",
"campaign_sha256": "7c799c005853df9399603401f8d2b388fe18f7ff74d8f9cb9105a5ef45d953fb",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"configuration-drift",
"mixed-model-versions",
"mixed-policy-versions",
"mixed-software-versions",
"supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"tampered-model",
"unsigned-update",
"correlated-version-drift"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "7f4da682a6d80f14b5fd87f3ea03e596387542180df652f6ce3dcf92c6e7876e",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "configuration-drift",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-model-versions",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-policy-versions",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-software-versions",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "tampered-model",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "unsigned-update",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "correlated-version-drift",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"MERITS_REVIEW_COMPLETE_NO_BASELINE_ACTIVATION",
"DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "configuration-drift",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"current_versions",
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-model-versions",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"current_versions",
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-policy-versions",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"current_versions",
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-software-versions",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"current_versions",
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "tampered-model",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"current_versions",
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "unsigned-update",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "correlated-version-drift",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "configuration-drift",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-model-versions",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-policy-versions",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "mixed-software-versions",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "tampered-model",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "unsigned-update",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "correlated-version-drift",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "97ecca62d054762bb58a123b09c3188f330f16595fb5472c73df4d9df0265d47",
"review_classification": "MERITS_REVIEW_COMPLETE",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "68375c3a36365726a8a1693641b08a589f4c9fa19833909ed58f094355041074",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E001",
"event_sha256": "6f01138f93be15d132a25851b588aecc2ae395f7b4dacd75f5684ac0d621c532",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "2f88c7632855e07c172dd305f05eab15cc28704c661dda8e2bb3a8873071a041",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E002",
"event_sha256": "21592b167899f88c4c635543e02f49e2ac81a8eca27a657cd8022975333458b2",
"previous_event_sha256": "6f01138f93be15d132a25851b588aecc2ae395f7b4dacd75f5684ac0d621c532",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E003",
"event_sha256": "033288cfadf713e3608c2d83cf9b09a5f6c27def247436a418f7b02eba34ecf7",
"previous_event_sha256": "21592b167899f88c4c635543e02f49e2ac81a8eca27a657cd8022975333458b2",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E004",
"event_sha256": "0c5b0c070216870a45aa7621fb31361308fed918efbeb0042eba9456d63c510c",
"previous_event_sha256": "033288cfadf713e3608c2d83cf9b09a5f6c27def247436a418f7b02eba34ecf7",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E005",
"event_sha256": "a5036e694c65cfc185b57a34b21c22e25d0f8532f04e740c7ee2f675d55b6f62",
"previous_event_sha256": "0c5b0c070216870a45aa7621fb31361308fed918efbeb0042eba9456d63c510c",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E006",
"event_sha256": "9b3b84fc5dd760e26a2677cb3951b0b05976c03631be400493daec142fb9d715",
"previous_event_sha256": "a5036e694c65cfc185b57a34b21c22e25d0f8532f04e740c7ee2f675d55b6f62",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state MERITS_REVIEW_COMPLETE was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E007",
"event_sha256": "dbe09889e341c327f051366d46a1a90d393b0b7ab6eb8fbdce5d24c5daec8d2a",
"previous_event_sha256": "9b3b84fc5dd760e26a2677cb3951b0b05976c03631be400493daec142fb9d715",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E008",
"event_sha256": "9cb341d907e76b361a44555ee646c4c99677d6fde8eb51ce946f7a232f3f1980",
"previous_event_sha256": "dbe09889e341c327f051366d46a1a90d393b0b7ab6eb8fbdce5d24c5daec8d2a",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E009",
"event_sha256": "8d6fab69eb3f64af4001014dca288a45ca076b3cacc4654fdee44e06df231242",
"previous_event_sha256": "9cb341d907e76b361a44555ee646c4c99677d6fde8eb51ce946f7a232f3f1980",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION-E010",
"event_sha256": "68375c3a36365726a8a1693641b08a589f4c9fa19833909ed58f094355041074",
"previous_event_sha256": "8d6fab69eb3f64af4001014dca288a45ca076b3cacc4654fdee44e06df231242",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "MERITS_REVIEW_COMPLETE",
"review_state_label": "Merits review complete",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-CONFIGURATION-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-CONFIGURATION-04",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONFIGURATION",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "2f88c7632855e07c172dd305f05eab15cc28704c661dda8e2bb3a8873071a041",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "configuration-attestation",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "2f88c7632855e07c172dd305f05eab15cc28704c661dda8e2bb3a8873071a041",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "5bf525563f9b010c2ee5246e17d66cc84f8b244fb07a469241dbcb26d724b23d"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "configuration-attestation",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"source_package_sha256": "2f88c7632855e07c172dd305f05eab15cc28704c661dda8e2bb3a8873071a041",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:configuration-attestation",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONFIGURATION",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONFIGURATION",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "7f4da682a6d80f14b5fd87f3ea03e596387542180df652f6ce3dcf92c6e7876e",
"member_id": "SRM-04-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"configuration-drift",
"mixed-model-versions",
"mixed-policy-versions",
"mixed-software-versions",
"supply-chain-provenance-loss",
"tampered-model",
"unsigned-update",
"correlated-version-drift"
],
"package_sha256": "e6e1026db3795c4d1c004ab01c1590fd66cead6edc95875151602a3cb9bb2f5d",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"MERITS_REVIEW_COMPLETE_NO_BASELINE_ACTIVATION",
"DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "97ecca62d054762bb58a123b09c3188f330f16595fb5472c73df4d9df0265d47",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "68375c3a36365726a8a1693641b08a589f4c9fa19833909ed58f094355041074",
"review_state": "MERITS_REVIEW_COMPLETE",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-CONFIGURATION-04",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "configuration-attestation",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "2f88c7632855e07c172dd305f05eab15cc28704c661dda8e2bb3a8873071a041",
"source_profile": "declared-faults",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-EVIDENCE-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "evidence-integrity",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "404fb35bdd3dbf0f10890ca59901269fd8ce5a2429bafcbb56f7a5cbe539043b",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "404fb35bdd3dbf0f10890ca59901269fd8ce5a2429bafcbb56f7a5cbe539043b",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"lineage_sha256": "ff74129aa83dfa13a09d31370cea2f528e70e587830fcdefec955580b5613376",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "d4dd5168b49e606d87252b1d09ccaf5e156e998bf0e927c94a684241c6ddffed",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign evidence-integrity under profile declared-faults was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Defer pending evidence. Readiness evidence state: DEFERRED.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "8429b6c543df3f7b5ff7e32e6d9fa7e8a2d21cbec8f01ba7381579071394b1da",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": false,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "evidence-integrity",
"campaign_sha256": "87b9dede484caca289497d6dc38d70aff8eb37b5c95627dca08faaa01a43a703",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"correlated-evidence-failure",
"evidence-ledger-divergence",
"poisoned-evidence-source",
"evidence-divergence-after-reconnect"
],
"profile_id": "declared-faults"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "404fb35bdd3dbf0f10890ca59901269fd8ce5a2429bafcbb56f7a5cbe539043b",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "correlated-evidence-failure",
"state": "EVIDENCE_LOCKED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-ledger-divergence",
"state": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "poisoned-evidence-source",
"state": "EVIDENCE_LOCKED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-divergence-after-reconnect",
"state": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 4,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "correlated-evidence-failure",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "EVIDENCE_LOCKED",
"dimensions": [
"evidence"
],
"outcome": "EVIDENCE_COLLECTION_REQUIRED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "evidence-ledger-divergence",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"dimensions": [
"evidence"
],
"outcome": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "poisoned-evidence-source",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "EVIDENCE_LOCKED",
"dimensions": [
"evidence"
],
"outcome": "EVIDENCE_COLLECTION_REQUIRED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "evidence-divergence-after-reconnect",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"dimensions": [
"evidence"
],
"outcome": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"recovery": false
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "evidence-integrity",
"campaign_sha256": "87b9dede484caca289497d6dc38d70aff8eb37b5c95627dca08faaa01a43a703",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"correlated-evidence-failure",
"evidence-ledger-divergence",
"poisoned-evidence-source",
"evidence-divergence-after-reconnect"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "ff74129aa83dfa13a09d31370cea2f528e70e587830fcdefec955580b5613376",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "correlated-evidence-failure",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-ledger-divergence",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "poisoned-evidence-source",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-divergence-after-reconnect",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"DEFERRED_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"CORRELATION_OR_DEPLOYMENT_GAP_REMAINS"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "DEFERRED",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "correlated-evidence-failure",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-ledger-divergence",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "poisoned-evidence-source",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-divergence-after-reconnect",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "correlated-evidence-failure",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-ledger-divergence",
"reconciliation": "REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "poisoned-evidence-source",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "evidence-divergence-after-reconnect",
"reconciliation": "REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "d4dd5168b49e606d87252b1d09ccaf5e156e998bf0e927c94a684241c6ddffed",
"review_classification": "DEFERRED_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "974d5c0649e43c49c793d3657c00931b471de60eebda976eccee4d85fd1dcb98",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E001",
"event_sha256": "df4a65014ef04eb28a23ff47b2e7dca0004711985c03b23825992fcd207817bb",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "06a0aff49e2e12833994c4acf607711907ddb768ccee260bcfd91ceba4fbcd21",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E002",
"event_sha256": "8b2f149ad8e4c1db796ede78de1d9e42ef3531ae9875db14ef89ca9de184f334",
"previous_event_sha256": "df4a65014ef04eb28a23ff47b2e7dca0004711985c03b23825992fcd207817bb",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E003",
"event_sha256": "210ec6f77e75670240ea142f724d864145a4c25ed7fa6f56aa4fa75f38538de3",
"previous_event_sha256": "8b2f149ad8e4c1db796ede78de1d9e42ef3531ae9875db14ef89ca9de184f334",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E004",
"event_sha256": "7952f8152dc853078eee0935f2b5db704ba9972237c97f8874e8e74cf29f040a",
"previous_event_sha256": "210ec6f77e75670240ea142f724d864145a4c25ed7fa6f56aa4fa75f38538de3",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E005",
"event_sha256": "0c0a1d2810cdde494a190c1d64876ce7abc28c14cb0743b7637b03f960574563",
"previous_event_sha256": "7952f8152dc853078eee0935f2b5db704ba9972237c97f8874e8e74cf29f040a",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E006",
"event_sha256": "05e260f2473e5f9b57753b474b6ca7033fe396a15350d2906dcbe6b5b7f6f2c0",
"previous_event_sha256": "0c0a1d2810cdde494a190c1d64876ce7abc28c14cb0743b7637b03f960574563",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E007",
"event_sha256": "7f91e91f2bf3bdab99f69e118b39254c66c4bcdf04dfe918c6007be5943ede86",
"previous_event_sha256": "05e260f2473e5f9b57753b474b6ca7033fe396a15350d2906dcbe6b5b7f6f2c0",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E008",
"event_sha256": "122989de7042a16ce51f7e39337e834fdb8e34a4787a6c9f6940bd139860f420",
"previous_event_sha256": "7f91e91f2bf3bdab99f69e118b39254c66c4bcdf04dfe918c6007be5943ede86",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E009",
"event_sha256": "3203ce4a64a0d5655daad2632fa650bf2f143a544cb0df54d0ad951b6a98348a",
"previous_event_sha256": "122989de7042a16ce51f7e39337e834fdb8e34a4787a6c9f6940bd139860f420",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY-E010",
"event_sha256": "974d5c0649e43c49c793d3657c00931b471de60eebda976eccee4d85fd1dcb98",
"previous_event_sha256": "3203ce4a64a0d5655daad2632fa650bf2f143a544cb0df54d0ad951b6a98348a",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"review_state_label": "Defer pending evidence",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-EVIDENCE-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-EVIDENCE-05",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-EVIDENCE",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "06a0aff49e2e12833994c4acf607711907ddb768ccee260bcfd91ceba4fbcd21",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "evidence-integrity",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "06a0aff49e2e12833994c4acf607711907ddb768ccee260bcfd91ceba4fbcd21",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "a30f0cdf24e72134144746afb74d9a7c1d431ed6afeb3c7b41dc111913ecdc0e"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"CURRENT_SCOPE_SUPPORT_NOT_COMPLETE"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "evidence-integrity",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"source_package_sha256": "06a0aff49e2e12833994c4acf607711907ddb768ccee260bcfd91ceba4fbcd21",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:evidence-integrity",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-EVIDENCE",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-EVIDENCE",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "ff74129aa83dfa13a09d31370cea2f528e70e587830fcdefec955580b5613376",
"member_id": "SRM-05-EVIDENCE_INTEGRITY",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"correlated-evidence-failure",
"evidence-ledger-divergence",
"poisoned-evidence-source",
"evidence-divergence-after-reconnect"
],
"package_sha256": "8429b6c543df3f7b5ff7e32e6d9fa7e8a2d21cbec8f01ba7381579071394b1da",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"DEFERRED_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"CORRELATION_OR_DEPLOYMENT_GAP_REMAINS"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "d4dd5168b49e606d87252b1d09ccaf5e156e998bf0e927c94a684241c6ddffed",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "974d5c0649e43c49c793d3657c00931b471de60eebda976eccee4d85fd1dcb98",
"review_state": "DEFER_PENDING_EVIDENCE",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-EVIDENCE-05",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "evidence-integrity",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "06a0aff49e2e12833994c4acf607711907ddb768ccee260bcfd91ceba4fbcd21",
"source_profile": "declared-faults",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"CURRENT_SCOPE_SUPPORT_NOT_COMPLETE"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-PARTITION-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "partition-reconciliation",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "9cd4ec4e7074d72372da6e7d8b8c7fb39ace1e314cb02189c8d12754d3d0abcf",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "9cd4ec4e7074d72372da6e7d8b8c7fb39ace1e314cb02189c8d12754d3d0abcf",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"lineage_sha256": "61af6dc9b470a6ca45c66a89e1a5298158425a06b7626a643854fa41c70c75b2",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "d978353548134a14a3538892d8f5d86c570b14673cab754267d77389af354b94",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign partition-reconciliation under profile recovery-validated was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Accept with qualifications. Readiness evidence state: REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "2eb9eefc3dee2a767030e61d66c36348d29d26fb2bbe768dc1fc94b71f30f5f7",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": true,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "partition-reconciliation",
"campaign_sha256": "8e58bd29c20736a97adc620530c98557654524bd64e7ff907a5f0bc441b5811b",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"communications-partition",
"failed-reconciliation",
"partial-federation-partition",
"restored-connectivity-reconciliation"
],
"profile_id": "recovery-validated"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "9cd4ec4e7074d72372da6e7d8b8c7fb39ace1e314cb02189c8d12754d3d0abcf",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "communications-partition",
"state": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "failed-reconciliation",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "partial-federation-partition",
"state": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "restored-connectivity-reconciliation",
"state": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 4,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "communications-partition",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"dimensions": [
"communications"
],
"outcome": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "failed-reconciliation",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"key_trust_anchor"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "partial-federation-partition",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"dimensions": [
"communications"
],
"outcome": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "restored-connectivity-reconciliation",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"dimensions": [
"communications"
],
"outcome": "RECONCILIATION_REQUIRED",
"recovery": false
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "partition-reconciliation",
"campaign_sha256": "8e58bd29c20736a97adc620530c98557654524bd64e7ff907a5f0bc441b5811b",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"communications-partition",
"failed-reconciliation",
"partial-federation-partition",
"restored-connectivity-reconciliation"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "61af6dc9b470a6ca45c66a89e1a5298158425a06b7626a643854fa41c70c75b2",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "communications-partition",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "failed-reconciliation",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "partial-federation-partition",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "restored-connectivity-reconciliation",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "communications-partition",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "failed-reconciliation",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "partial-federation-partition",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "restored-connectivity-reconciliation",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"source_and_evidence_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "communications-partition",
"reconciliation": "REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "failed-reconciliation",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "REKEYED_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "partial-federation-partition",
"reconciliation": "REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "restored-connectivity-reconciliation",
"reconciliation": "REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "d978353548134a14a3538892d8f5d86c570b14673cab754267d77389af354b94",
"review_classification": "QUALIFIED_BASELINE_ACCEPTANCE_PROPOSED",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "2116577d729a2fc1f114f652b19b5ff74cabbc3e9dd304c86a084104e19283e3",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E001",
"event_sha256": "d5d0f473d62bcada1c2726d67871aed9206064a27e6316b6944211e04c076e5f",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "29255e34d8716c0ae5bae11f2478170b8db834d517480db57f5b466eb95a00c9",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E002",
"event_sha256": "dd535d4dcc61523f8fcaa07a2e1b87935db8a08b9b257882bc6a948749e214ee",
"previous_event_sha256": "d5d0f473d62bcada1c2726d67871aed9206064a27e6316b6944211e04c076e5f",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E003",
"event_sha256": "8fccc22c4aec6e3a68a9a2860ad522c83aa3607a8b6494223d691f31051d2db5",
"previous_event_sha256": "dd535d4dcc61523f8fcaa07a2e1b87935db8a08b9b257882bc6a948749e214ee",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E004",
"event_sha256": "81eb5bfd2440e3210c0fade398ad782b3453f04557b6c2285ca2a78b8f5e58b0",
"previous_event_sha256": "8fccc22c4aec6e3a68a9a2860ad522c83aa3607a8b6494223d691f31051d2db5",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E005",
"event_sha256": "df1f120ef9ecb2f01f53d30d179dfed4faab427399bb76fece0e904ea2c3ff02",
"previous_event_sha256": "81eb5bfd2440e3210c0fade398ad782b3453f04557b6c2285ca2a78b8f5e58b0",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E006",
"event_sha256": "86e9a6524c20cecd697d4d19d87d07564211f0e3ac85dcca3d72cce0eb4216eb",
"previous_event_sha256": "df1f120ef9ecb2f01f53d30d179dfed4faab427399bb76fece0e904ea2c3ff02",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E007",
"event_sha256": "c8701cef149cd2049af0639e39b56548e3e01254e6d51c8388bb5c8aa2dca69d",
"previous_event_sha256": "86e9a6524c20cecd697d4d19d87d07564211f0e3ac85dcca3d72cce0eb4216eb",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E008",
"event_sha256": "49e1022215b841abddb0a2d773b4e824a0ad325e741fe33556be7203c8376172",
"previous_event_sha256": "c8701cef149cd2049af0639e39b56548e3e01254e6d51c8388bb5c8aa2dca69d",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E009",
"event_sha256": "40e87ddcb18b75009e1a860e738f6854379091fb1dc6a9e567fb1a63553b6f57",
"previous_event_sha256": "49e1022215b841abddb0a2d773b4e824a0ad325e741fe33556be7203c8376172",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION-E010",
"event_sha256": "2116577d729a2fc1f114f652b19b5ff74cabbc3e9dd304c86a084104e19283e3",
"previous_event_sha256": "40e87ddcb18b75009e1a860e738f6854379091fb1dc6a9e567fb1a63553b6f57",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"review_state_label": "Accept with qualifications",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-PARTITION-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-PARTITION-06",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-PARTITION",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "29255e34d8716c0ae5bae11f2478170b8db834d517480db57f5b466eb95a00c9",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "partition-reconciliation",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "29255e34d8716c0ae5bae11f2478170b8db834d517480db57f5b466eb95a00c9",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "f143a06cd87bebe02c950b0743046bde9f08e846d0f25a48660c74c59dda8e32"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "partition-reconciliation",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"source_package_sha256": "29255e34d8716c0ae5bae11f2478170b8db834d517480db57f5b466eb95a00c9",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:partition-reconciliation",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-PARTITION",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-PARTITION",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "61af6dc9b470a6ca45c66a89e1a5298158425a06b7626a643854fa41c70c75b2",
"member_id": "SRM-06-PARTITION_RECONCILIATION",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"communications-partition",
"failed-reconciliation",
"partial-federation-partition",
"restored-connectivity-reconciliation"
],
"package_sha256": "2eb9eefc3dee2a767030e61d66c36348d29d26fb2bbe768dc1fc94b71f30f5f7",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "d978353548134a14a3538892d8f5d86c570b14673cab754267d77389af354b94",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "2116577d729a2fc1f114f652b19b5ff74cabbc3e9dd304c86a084104e19283e3",
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-PARTITION-06",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "partition-reconciliation",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "29255e34d8716c0ae5bae11f2478170b8db834d517480db57f5b466eb95a00c9",
"source_profile": "recovery-validated",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-RELEASE-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "release-channel",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "15ecf1556554cb1146a202bc2f4d29ab3ecd0a02106ca1c9491e1d9fc7f10de8",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-RELEASE_CHANNEL-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "15ecf1556554cb1146a202bc2f4d29ab3ecd0a02106ca1c9491e1d9fc7f10de8",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-RELEASE_CHANNEL-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"lineage_sha256": "51a43faa4fb4ed9e82ac2126ea0cd9909955b90ea20cc71c8de66ae5af494e5e",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "aa8bfef979518279ca67215d925a447411676e56673fe69177acd8b058737abf",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign release-channel under profile declared-faults was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Accept with qualifications. Readiness evidence state: REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "8f48c1551c6908f8e6e9bcd2909a5f946a43482024e92112fdf81c583b960a39",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": true,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "release-channel",
"campaign_sha256": "d689981c17936dce5682a142495982afa71d46e040e655c1c51f6736d2df5d91",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"public-capability-compromise",
"release-channel-severance",
"release-compartment-compromise",
"multi-compartment-release-failure"
],
"profile_id": "declared-faults"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "15ecf1556554cb1146a202bc2f4d29ab3ecd0a02106ca1c9491e1d9fc7f10de8",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-RELEASE_CHANNEL-DECLARED_FAULTS",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "public-capability-compromise",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "release-channel-severance",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "release-compartment-compromise",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "multi-compartment-release-failure",
"state": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 4,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "public-capability-compromise",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"identity",
"software_model",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "release-channel-severance",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "release-compartment-compromise",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"identity",
"authority",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "multi-compartment-release-failure",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "COMPROMISE_CONTAINED",
"dimensions": [
"identity",
"software_model",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "COMPARTMENT_SEVERED",
"recovery": false
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "release-channel",
"campaign_sha256": "d689981c17936dce5682a142495982afa71d46e040e655c1c51f6736d2df5d91",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"public-capability-compromise",
"release-channel-severance",
"release-compartment-compromise",
"multi-compartment-release-failure"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "51a43faa4fb4ed9e82ac2126ea0cd9909955b90ea20cc71c8de66ae5af494e5e",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "public-capability-compromise",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "release-channel-severance",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "release-compartment-compromise",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "multi-compartment-release-failure",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "public-capability-compromise",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "release-channel-severance",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "release-compartment-compromise",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "multi-compartment-release-failure",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "public-capability-compromise",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "release-channel-severance",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "release-compartment-compromise",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "multi-compartment-release-failure",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "aa8bfef979518279ca67215d925a447411676e56673fe69177acd8b058737abf",
"review_classification": "QUALIFIED_BASELINE_ACCEPTANCE_PROPOSED",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "15994f6047cc0c2f4545ad993d0dea48a63494dcb2e488911834a087fabb1953",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E001",
"event_sha256": "ed387e9367f6c9171d73471f59af265a713697914682748485988f15d5ff2047",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "c10d14dba4447fb0019141c2f465f5f1f1669b55e9d9299a5cd953c3aa989876",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E002",
"event_sha256": "3ab16352b3393487919d80944a995db6e7750c930121bee8be6dd9028e30564a",
"previous_event_sha256": "ed387e9367f6c9171d73471f59af265a713697914682748485988f15d5ff2047",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E003",
"event_sha256": "2cf8bd208a302c91000ba15bc265530eb4c98f42f103e126f81d9420add9e7ca",
"previous_event_sha256": "3ab16352b3393487919d80944a995db6e7750c930121bee8be6dd9028e30564a",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E004",
"event_sha256": "ef14639b678cdcdcb7121fde1a80f2c1178229df5fce9f4b43f8ed06f3db1191",
"previous_event_sha256": "2cf8bd208a302c91000ba15bc265530eb4c98f42f103e126f81d9420add9e7ca",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E005",
"event_sha256": "e0650bff2c9380a42d577ba3fafc31b6279131cca452df5342e138bb9af94c41",
"previous_event_sha256": "ef14639b678cdcdcb7121fde1a80f2c1178229df5fce9f4b43f8ed06f3db1191",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E006",
"event_sha256": "b42826463280bb211fbf5c9e58969ac1d17141df8749725dc44275269cb4c7a8",
"previous_event_sha256": "e0650bff2c9380a42d577ba3fafc31b6279131cca452df5342e138bb9af94c41",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E007",
"event_sha256": "800686deba71f7358e405240b5f80d4f16848825044400e1c43937afed88b110",
"previous_event_sha256": "b42826463280bb211fbf5c9e58969ac1d17141df8749725dc44275269cb4c7a8",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E008",
"event_sha256": "402561692e624e8b61cb686afbe5d9d851457a6c47c993503cf093b115e10fa7",
"previous_event_sha256": "800686deba71f7358e405240b5f80d4f16848825044400e1c43937afed88b110",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E009",
"event_sha256": "cb21179c2a9a4aca1fc7332c4c437d955b269c631f9f9d49c3ebf79ec297563f",
"previous_event_sha256": "402561692e624e8b61cb686afbe5d9d851457a6c47c993503cf093b115e10fa7",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-RELEASE_CHANNEL-E010",
"event_sha256": "15994f6047cc0c2f4545ad993d0dea48a63494dcb2e488911834a087fabb1953",
"previous_event_sha256": "cb21179c2a9a4aca1fc7332c4c437d955b269c631f9f9d49c3ebf79ec297563f",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"review_state_label": "Accept with qualifications",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-RELEASE-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-RELEASE-07",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RELEASE",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "c10d14dba4447fb0019141c2f465f5f1f1669b55e9d9299a5cd953c3aa989876",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "release-channel",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "c10d14dba4447fb0019141c2f465f5f1f1669b55e9d9299a5cd953c3aa989876",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "25dbb12ab1de628b83db4b56263bae73d5895c0492a34b1639db30a874907d73"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "release-channel",
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"source_package_sha256": "c10d14dba4447fb0019141c2f465f5f1f1669b55e9d9299a5cd953c3aa989876",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:release-channel",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RELEASE",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:declared-faults",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RELEASE",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "51a43faa4fb4ed9e82ac2126ea0cd9909955b90ea20cc71c8de66ae5af494e5e",
"member_id": "SRM-07-RELEASE_CHANNEL",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"public-capability-compromise",
"release-channel-severance",
"release-compartment-compromise",
"multi-compartment-release-failure"
],
"package_sha256": "8f48c1551c6908f8e6e9bcd2909a5f946a43482024e92112fdf81c583b960a39",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "declared-faults",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "aa8bfef979518279ca67215d925a447411676e56673fe69177acd8b058737abf",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "15994f6047cc0c2f4545ad993d0dea48a63494dcb2e488911834a087fabb1953",
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-RELEASE-07",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "release-channel",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "c10d14dba4447fb0019141c2f465f5f1f1669b55e9d9299a5cd953c3aa989876",
"source_profile": "declared-faults",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-CONTINUITY-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "sovereign-continuity",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "46f1930a7d7438378fc4789f49b6367b64422eb8987312b6f355fc69b0fc9292",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "46f1930a7d7438378fc4789f49b6367b64422eb8987312b6f355fc69b0fc9292",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"lineage_sha256": "159b2de3bc28ecf795a3d398d7d5af876b16fd2e18f689a273c37762b60c23ce",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "d6000f84dd3d43758f70903433a4dd2b507b416f53e4cf282de29002f1fd7b65",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign sovereign-continuity under profile recovery-validated was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Accept with qualifications. Readiness evidence state: REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "aa888aa827c0a6e378b1656c92aa52b879997131962b8b25296cd88af391ec93",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": true,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "sovereign-continuity",
"campaign_sha256": "3fb2498ee4dc947adcc2955da6226fd8c8bad0b5cd9cb28865dd6ad75b99066e",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"runtime-governor-unavailable",
"sovereign-baseline",
"sovereign-command-unavailable",
"reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss"
],
"profile_id": "recovery-validated"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "46f1930a7d7438378fc4789f49b6367b64422eb8987312b6f355fc69b0fc9292",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "runtime-governor-unavailable",
"state": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-baseline",
"state": "NOMINAL",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-command-unavailable",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss",
"state": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 4,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "runtime-governor-unavailable",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "INTEGRITY_HOLD",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "sovereign-command-unavailable",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"communications",
"authority"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss",
"index": 4,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "CONTINUITY_PRESERVED",
"dimensions": [
"authority",
"reviewer_lineage"
],
"outcome": "MINIMUM_SOVEREIGN_FUNCTION",
"recovery": false
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "sovereign-baseline",
"index": 2,
"state": "UNCHANGED",
"variant": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
}
}
]
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "sovereign-continuity",
"campaign_sha256": "3fb2498ee4dc947adcc2955da6226fd8c8bad0b5cd9cb28865dd6ad75b99066e",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"runtime-governor-unavailable",
"sovereign-baseline",
"sovereign-command-unavailable",
"reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "159b2de3bc28ecf795a3d398d7d5af876b16fd2e18f689a273c37762b60c23ce",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "runtime-governor-unavailable",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": false,
"missing_functions": [
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE"
],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": false,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-baseline",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-command-unavailable",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "runtime-governor-unavailable",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"runtime_governor_available",
"all_recovery_components_attested"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-baseline",
"eligible": true,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-command-unavailable",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"event_history_reconciled",
"new_release_authority_issued"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss",
"eligible": false,
"missing": [
"revoked_credentials_excluded",
"new_release_authority_issued",
"review_quorum_complete"
]
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "runtime-governor-unavailable",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-baseline",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "sovereign-command-unavailable",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss",
"reconciliation": "NOT_REQUIRED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "d6000f84dd3d43758f70903433a4dd2b507b416f53e4cf282de29002f1fd7b65",
"review_classification": "QUALIFIED_BASELINE_ACCEPTANCE_PROPOSED",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "c3adf7b95ed8fb85c033bd28e8872a95379fcef140e1875048fa9827fd71c747",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E001",
"event_sha256": "7e71561e0593bd95b2b7559475223cc992732493ce74082b6ddece3500f1948f",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "f097919f5ae5f2b2705ce64c89034cc624e0c9eff4a1ca20222b58c27c9dca65",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E002",
"event_sha256": "6d07f6da3fe8d9093f1cb36c1b102c529d6af879406cebec2feb7a424130109d",
"previous_event_sha256": "7e71561e0593bd95b2b7559475223cc992732493ce74082b6ddece3500f1948f",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E003",
"event_sha256": "7d5176c348bbd8b1fb40b84ad5508aca98fc645ee56f35a483ec18c70c00555a",
"previous_event_sha256": "6d07f6da3fe8d9093f1cb36c1b102c529d6af879406cebec2feb7a424130109d",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E004",
"event_sha256": "c89daf40b4d4e501b038ad7bf6f8c8c5473dbef08e813e52b3cdee0f97c1ff8b",
"previous_event_sha256": "7d5176c348bbd8b1fb40b84ad5508aca98fc645ee56f35a483ec18c70c00555a",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E005",
"event_sha256": "e3a604d9d4e43cac3d6190f769a8fe8829b4413d2bbbc58e185d374435a4f6a8",
"previous_event_sha256": "c89daf40b4d4e501b038ad7bf6f8c8c5473dbef08e813e52b3cdee0f97c1ff8b",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E006",
"event_sha256": "4efde6b1f5525d242b670086515dc4ba694af0ca28df49371480b28478925440",
"previous_event_sha256": "e3a604d9d4e43cac3d6190f769a8fe8829b4413d2bbbc58e185d374435a4f6a8",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E007",
"event_sha256": "0eed52f2c4b0e31924138f8a48ad976295008eb911e50a08f46761967e074e4a",
"previous_event_sha256": "4efde6b1f5525d242b670086515dc4ba694af0ca28df49371480b28478925440",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E008",
"event_sha256": "ea1ac2585e8a655cf526174fe9a9dd61d804a3d437199b4157b9f83e925d1d5a",
"previous_event_sha256": "0eed52f2c4b0e31924138f8a48ad976295008eb911e50a08f46761967e074e4a",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E009",
"event_sha256": "83a6d6d05b50a6da1ef332e37b6a1d2f81c60f828f064545817dd4eaf247c8f4",
"previous_event_sha256": "ea1ac2585e8a655cf526174fe9a9dd61d804a3d437199b4157b9f83e925d1d5a",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY-E010",
"event_sha256": "c3adf7b95ed8fb85c033bd28e8872a95379fcef140e1875048fa9827fd71c747",
"previous_event_sha256": "83a6d6d05b50a6da1ef332e37b6a1d2f81c60f828f064545817dd4eaf247c8f4",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"review_state_label": "Accept with qualifications",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-CONTINUITY-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-CONTINUITY-08",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONTINUITY",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "f097919f5ae5f2b2705ce64c89034cc624e0c9eff4a1ca20222b58c27c9dca65",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "sovereign-continuity",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "f097919f5ae5f2b2705ce64c89034cc624e0c9eff4a1ca20222b58c27c9dca65",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "8e8cc12f3d8b2e7f45f51294595dc9b08286dc3e81c63d872ffcb55fd5882100"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "sovereign-continuity",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"source_package_sha256": "f097919f5ae5f2b2705ce64c89034cc624e0c9eff4a1ca20222b58c27c9dca65",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:sovereign-continuity",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONTINUITY",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-CONTINUITY",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "159b2de3bc28ecf795a3d398d7d5af876b16fd2e18f689a273c37762b60c23ce",
"member_id": "SRM-08-SOVEREIGN_CONTINUITY",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"minimum-sovereign-function-preserved",
"runtime-governor-unavailable",
"sovereign-baseline",
"sovereign-command-unavailable",
"reviewer-lineage-and-authority-loss"
],
"package_sha256": "aa888aa827c0a6e378b1656c92aa52b879997131962b8b25296cd88af391ec93",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "d6000f84dd3d43758f70903433a4dd2b507b416f53e4cf282de29002f1fd7b65",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "c3adf7b95ed8fb85c033bd28e8872a95379fcef140e1875048fa9827fd71c747",
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-CONTINUITY-08",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "sovereign-continuity",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "f097919f5ae5f2b2705ce64c89034cc624e0c9eff4a1ca20222b58c27c9dca65",
"source_profile": "recovery-validated",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
{
"authority_lineage": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-RECONSTITUTION-RC22",
"baseline_lineage": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign_id": "attested-reconstitution",
"candidate_baseline_digest": "9ff9fcbc801192ff240f7d71331f386044ccbd21ec54f2853f3780d1302c5d2f",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"constituent_package": {
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_lineage": {
"candidate_baseline_digest": "9ff9fcbc801192ff240f7d71331f386044ccbd21ec54f2853f3780d1302c5d2f",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"lineage_sha256": "fb38228c54ee85c5b74b38e081939e1567c42092ab6bface955e834b372d6855",
"parent": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"review_artifact_sha256": "2225e37eff5e4f13b5a5080bf04b647ea6b8062dfc730cc71218f3179bef8e53",
"review_sequence": 1,
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"narrative_equivalent": [
"Campaign attested-reconstitution under profile recovery-validated was verified against accepted baseline EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT.",
"Review state: Accept with qualifications. Readiness evidence state: REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS.",
"The artifact is a bounded synthetic review record and does not activate a baseline or establish operational readiness, accreditation, legal approval, procurement acceptance, or release promotion."
],
"package_sha256": "11d5e5b9192699053f465a2aaa7b563db2fcde711bf17a2261a0721624ea104a",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"review_artifact": {
"accepted_baseline_mutated": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"baseline_activated": false,
"baseline_promotion_proposed": true,
"campaign": {
"campaign_id": "attested-reconstitution",
"campaign_sha256": "a5640a4287599cf37f7896ba25c68c810b88fa56fee2be00dd6c8eb9a61f3c37",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"successful-attested-reconstitution",
"unattested-recovery-baseline",
"superseded-recovery-replay"
],
"profile_id": "recovery-validated"
},
"candidate_baseline_digest": "9ff9fcbc801192ff240f7d71331f386044ccbd21ec54f2853f3780d1302c5d2f",
"candidate_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-RC22-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-RECOVERY_VALIDATED",
"composite_readiness_score": null,
"containment_results": [
{
"drill_id": "recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "successful-attested-reconstitution",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "unattested-recovery-baseline",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
},
{
"drill_id": "superseded-recovery-replay",
"state": "RECONSTITUTED",
"success": true
}
],
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"difference_lifecycle": {
"difference_count": 5,
"first_divergence_index": 0,
"newly_introduced": [
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"index": 0,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"index": 1,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "successful-attested-reconstitution",
"index": 2,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"key_trust_anchor"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "unattested-recovery-baseline",
"index": 3,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
},
{
"baseline": {
"containment": "NOMINAL",
"dimensions": [],
"outcome": "MISSION_READY",
"recovery": true
},
"drill_id": "superseded-recovery-replay",
"index": 4,
"state": "NEWLY_INTRODUCED",
"variant": {
"containment": "RECONSTITUTED",
"dimensions": [
"software_model",
"release_channel"
],
"outcome": "ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"recovery": true
}
}
],
"resolved": [],
"unchanged": []
},
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"exact_scope": {
"authority_artifact_manifest_sha256": "d981029dd4f900e069e1223033e13a0b03db021491d2cd6b3f134630cb952994",
"campaign_id": "attested-reconstitution",
"campaign_sha256": "a5640a4287599cf37f7896ba25c68c810b88fa56fee2be00dd6c8eb9a61f3c37",
"dependency_graph_sha256": "18ad1aee66257f32becc26c07b0906762de8b4d360827099b457d34634411fb3",
"evidence_provenance_manifest_sha256": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"key_epoch_manifest_sha256": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"successful-attested-reconstitution",
"unattested-recovery-baseline",
"superseded-recovery-replay"
],
"parent_accepted_baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"parent_accepted_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"software_model_policy_configuration_manifest_sha256": "98d4244524b1b5bcee50b281481272dca31b6b41489c40daa7e25efff9ab5dee",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"workload_identity_manifest_sha256": "5c3dd9940170c8778dca8e97c402a06b0e5db0280d51fb5cb25d4ce3da063a04"
},
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"history_deleted": false,
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"limitations": [
"This is a bounded synthetic review artifact, not operational readiness, accreditation, certification, legal authorization, procurement acceptance, or release promotion.",
"A valid digest proves deterministic byte integrity inside the declared scope; it does not prove factual truth about external systems.",
"Recorded reviewer conditions do not prove private cognition, moral agency, legal personhood, or legal approval."
],
"lineage_sha256": "fb38228c54ee85c5b74b38e081939e1567c42092ab6bface955e834b372d6855",
"minimum_sovereign_function_results": [
{
"drill_id": "recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "successful-attested-reconstitution",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "unattested-recovery-baseline",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
},
{
"drill_id": "superseded-recovery-replay",
"local_function_requires_predeclared_authority": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function_preserved": true,
"missing_functions": [],
"new_objectives_permitted": false,
"preserved": true,
"preserved_functions": [
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION"
],
"providers": {
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION": [
"supply-chain-configuration",
"evidence-provenance"
],
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY": [
"sovereign-command"
],
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY": [
"evidence-provenance"
],
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY": [
"mission-assurance"
],
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS": [
"mission-assurance",
"partner-release",
"public-capability"
],
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY": [
"evidence-provenance",
"partner-release"
],
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY": [
"supply-chain-configuration"
],
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION": [
"sovereign-command",
"supply-chain-configuration"
]
},
"required_functions": [
"CONSTITUTIONAL_IDENTITY_CONTINUITY",
"AUTHORITY_KERNEL_CONTINUITY",
"IMMUTABLE_EVIDENCE_CONTINUITY",
"REVOCATION_DISTRIBUTION",
"LOCAL_TIME_INTEGRITY",
"MINIMUM_COMMUNICATIONS",
"INDEPENDENT_RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"ARCHIVE_AND_STATE_RECONSTRUCTION",
"RECOVERY_BASELINE_AVAILABILITY",
"RECONCILIATION_CAPABILITY"
]
}
],
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"prior_review_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Source campaign package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact accepted baseline identity preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-002"
},
{
"name": "Mandatory inspection dimensions complete when required",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-003"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode remains distinct from review state",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-004"
},
{
"name": "Human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-005"
},
{
"name": "Machine report does not establish independent machine review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-006"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer independence conditions recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-007"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications and residual unknowns preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-008"
},
{
"name": "Rollback baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-009"
},
{
"name": "Review event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-010"
},
{
"name": "No source or accepted-baseline mutation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-011"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or prior review overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-012"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-013"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-015"
},
{
"name": "Independent readiness dimensions retained",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-016"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-017"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-018"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "REV-019"
}
],
"proof_conditions": [
{
"name": "Exact baseline registry identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-001"
},
{
"name": "Ordered drill execution",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-002"
},
{
"name": "Every drill proof passed",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-003"
},
{
"name": "Accepted baseline preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-004"
},
{
"name": "Prior drill history preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-005"
},
{
"name": "Connectivity not promoted to authority",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-006"
},
{
"name": "Containment distinguished from recovery",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-007"
},
{
"name": "Minimum sovereign function distinguished from readiness",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-008"
},
{
"name": "No automatic baseline acceptance",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-009"
},
{
"name": "No automatic release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-010"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic non-persistent boundary",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-011"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "CAM-012"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_state": "REVIEWED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reconstitution_eligibility": [
{
"drill_id": "recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "successful-attested-reconstitution",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "unattested-recovery-baseline",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
},
{
"drill_id": "superseded-recovery-replay",
"eligible": true,
"missing": []
}
],
"rekey_and_reconciliation_results": [
{
"drill_id": "recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "successful-attested-reconstitution",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "REKEYED_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "unattested-recovery-baseline",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
},
{
"drill_id": "superseded-recovery-replay",
"reconciliation": "VERIFIED",
"rekey": "KEY_EPOCH_CURRENT"
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "2225e37eff5e4f13b5a5080bf04b647ea6b8062dfc730cc71218f3179bef8e53",
"review_classification": "QUALIFIED_BASELINE_ACCEPTANCE_PROPOSED",
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_event_chain_sha256": "df7a9cb34359c5fa938c59b9793e6da555b252514d9363572e5f3d3b172c2dc1",
"review_events": [
{
"code": "CAMPAIGN_PACKAGE_VERIFIED",
"description": "The exact bounded campaign package and all declared chains were verified.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E001",
"event_sha256": "235a899a2014b7ccc8fb8c2b924656f75fe77c10c5970fa3209fdb02c7758695",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 0,
"source_digest": "ba3d8a7bd386bbd76b24941091e107b219fee4b01828b05e588b6bfc51b28e6e",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ACCEPTED_SCOPE_INSPECTED",
"description": "The current accepted baseline identity and exact candidate scope were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E002",
"event_sha256": "d6ae2c7e27f4f6134051144ae7c37ba265af2d55f05c2b7420678998e14aa0d9",
"previous_event_sha256": "235a899a2014b7ccc8fb8c2b924656f75fe77c10c5970fa3209fdb02c7758695",
"sequence": 1,
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "DIFFERENCE_LIFECYCLE_INSPECTED",
"description": "Newly introduced, resolved, unchanged, and reopened evidence states were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E003",
"event_sha256": "416c96af4520f89355e96c4c72e5f3d89a25c1b30f28888e2b58b10f10085473",
"previous_event_sha256": "d6ae2c7e27f4f6134051144ae7c37ba265af2d55f05c2b7420678998e14aa0d9",
"sequence": 2,
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CONTAINMENT_AND_CONTINUITY_INSPECTED",
"description": "Containment, minimum sovereign function, rekeying, revocation, reconciliation, and reconstitution evidence were inspected.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E004",
"event_sha256": "58c3b79f7ff72745d8103dd909367edfc78f02b53888ad877d351522acbaf6cc",
"previous_event_sha256": "416c96af4520f89355e96c4c72e5f3d89a25c1b30f28888e2b58b10f10085473",
"sequence": 3,
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "CONTRARY_EVIDENCE_REVIEWED",
"description": "Contrary indicators, defeaters, changed assumptions, and residual unknowns were preserved.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E005",
"event_sha256": "6d52bd89a2e2e715fede25ee7d0a9819bbe8f019a5486e446a969e7f915bbaef",
"previous_event_sha256": "58c3b79f7ff72745d8103dd909367edfc78f02b53888ad877d351522acbaf6cc",
"sequence": 4,
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED",
"description": "Reviewer mode independent-machine-review was recorded without claiming hidden cognition or legal approval.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E006",
"event_sha256": "fb423d88649c8038493c08d94cfa50df7995a14401cea9a9c88b6e7f787369d4",
"previous_event_sha256": "6d52bd89a2e2e715fede25ee7d0a9819bbe8f019a5486e446a969e7f915bbaef",
"sequence": 5,
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_STATE_RECORDED",
"description": "Review state ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS was appended as a proposal only.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E007",
"event_sha256": "27236f4a320dd19ccaf54b18e2d9a99f14244aec6635b298f0f9e6be5088da4a",
"previous_event_sha256": "fb423d88649c8038493c08d94cfa50df7995a14401cea9a9c88b6e7f787369d4",
"sequence": 6,
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_RECORDED",
"description": "Independent readiness dimensions were recorded without a composite score.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E008",
"event_sha256": "a0306f2ded10ab25b650e2b150db14db606113bd073fa416da385f0719c60248",
"previous_event_sha256": "27236f4a320dd19ccaf54b18e2d9a99f14244aec6635b298f0f9e6be5088da4a",
"sequence": 7,
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "LINEAGE_APPENDED",
"description": "The predecessor relationship and rollback baseline were preserved without deleting history.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E009",
"event_sha256": "23e1896c191c9daceda4f975cfdc82145c083dffb5d209b21b1dbe829e09ab70",
"previous_event_sha256": "a0306f2ded10ab25b650e2b150db14db606113bd073fa416da385f0719c60248",
"sequence": 8,
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "The review produced no production write, activation, or command action.",
"event_id": "EV-CCR-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION-E010",
"event_sha256": "df7a9cb34359c5fa938c59b9793e6da555b252514d9363572e5f3d3b172c2dc1",
"previous_event_sha256": "23e1896c191c9daceda4f975cfdc82145c083dffb5d209b21b1dbe829e09ab70",
"sequence": 9,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 900
}
],
"review_sequence": 1,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"review_state_label": "Accept with qualifications",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CAMPAIGN-REVIEW-RECONSTITUTION-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-FED-RECONSTITUTION-09",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RECONSTITUTION",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_family": "machine",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_campaign_mutated": false,
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "ba3d8a7bd386bbd76b24941091e107b219fee4b01828b05e588b6bfc51b28e6e",
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_package_verification": {
"automatic_approval": false,
"campaign_id": "attested-reconstitution",
"check_count": 18,
"checks": [
{
"id": "PKG-001",
"name": "Published package schema",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-002",
"name": "Bounded package size",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-003",
"name": "Source release and engine identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-004",
"name": "Package digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-005",
"name": "Accepted baseline registry digest",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-006",
"name": "Current accepted baseline identity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-007",
"name": "Exact campaign ordering",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-008",
"name": "Drill-run digests",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-009",
"name": "Drill predecessor and successor ledger",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-010",
"name": "Per-drill event-chain integrity",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-011",
"name": "Proof-state completeness",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-012",
"name": "Difference lifecycle present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-013",
"name": "Containment evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-014",
"name": "Minimum sovereign function evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-015",
"name": "Rekey and reconciliation evidence complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-016",
"name": "Reconstitution eligibility complete",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-017",
"name": "Public boundary remains synthetic and non-persistent",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "PKG-018",
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true
}
],
"package_sha256": "ba3d8a7bd386bbd76b24941091e107b219fee4b01828b05e588b6bfc51b28e6e",
"passed": true,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-source-verification.v1",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"verification_sha256": "94318b049c0c8dc3f6b6c5dc3705a9f75f15d33152eaa94b21cfc25fe5d6eafa"
},
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review-package.v1",
"semantic_table_equivalent": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"source_campaign_identity": {
"campaign_id": "attested-reconstitution",
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"source_package_sha256": "ba3d8a7bd386bbd76b24941091e107b219fee4b01828b05e588b6bfc51b28e6e",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
},
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
},
"correlation_groups": [
"baseline:5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"campaign:attested-reconstitution",
"engine:1.0.0",
"evidence-root:96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"implementation:SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RECONSTITUTION",
"key-epoch:42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"profile:recovery-validated",
"source-release:2.0.0-rc.21-WIP"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_provenance_lineage": "96a1ccf5a1ca5f9c0f7460f1b6ede4029f4f3e2f5807bf9ed8d76d145758dd50",
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"implementation_lineage": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-RECONSTITUTION",
"independence_qualification": "CORRELATED_SUPPORT",
"key_epoch_lineage": "42a5f6c1b355809c21080c262a0dbe05e0ab4add832a71e3cc18d37daf4dd6b3",
"lineage_sha256": "fb38228c54ee85c5b74b38e081939e1567c42092ab6bface955e834b372d6855",
"member_id": "SRM-09-ATTESTED_RECONSTITUTION",
"ordered_drill_ids": [
"recovery-from-accepted-immutable-baseline",
"rollback-to-superseded-baseline",
"successful-attested-reconstitution",
"unattested-recovery-baseline",
"superseded-recovery-replay"
],
"package_sha256": "11d5e5b9192699053f465a2aaa7b563db2fcde711bf17a2261a0721624ea104a",
"package_verified": true,
"parent_accepted_baseline": {
"baseline_digest": "5db3cc2565f148a746736028a68c722efd72c2bcf2a8251f0b752646936c0f28",
"baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT"
},
"predecessor_review": null,
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "package_integrity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "baseline_identity",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "campaign_reproducibility",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "containment",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "rekey_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "One or more drills require a new key epoch or revocation completion.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation",
"qualification": "Restored-link state requires or failed reconciliation in at least one drill.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconstitution",
"qualification": "Not every drill is eligible for attested reconstitution.",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_boundary",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_completion",
"qualification": "",
"state": "PASS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic campaign evidence do not establish actual-host deployment or operational readiness.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_artifact_sha256": "2225e37eff5e4f13b5a5080bf04b647ea6b8062dfc730cc71218f3179bef8e53",
"review_event_chain_sha256": "df7a9cb34359c5fa938c59b9793e6da555b252514d9363572e5f3d3b172c2dc1",
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer_lineage": "EV-IRI-FED-RECONSTITUTION-09",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"SHARED_RC22_REVIEW_ENGINE",
"SHARED_RC21_DRILL_ENGINE",
"SHARED_ACCEPTED_BASELINE"
],
"source_campaign": "attested-reconstitution",
"source_campaign_package_sha256": "ba3d8a7bd386bbd76b24941091e107b219fee4b01828b05e588b6bfc51b28e6e",
"source_profile": "recovery-validated",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
}
],
"predecessor_record": null,
"prior_record_overwritten": false,
"production_authority_written": false,
"proof": [
{
"name": "Published federation schema",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-001"
},
{
"name": "Exact source release identity",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-002"
},
{
"name": "Constituent packages present",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-003"
},
{
"name": "Every constituent package verified",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-004"
},
{
"name": "Every package digest is SHA-256",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-005"
},
{
"name": "Every source package digest is SHA-256",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-006"
},
{
"name": "Every review artifact digest is SHA-256",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-007"
},
{
"name": "Every lineage digest is SHA-256",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-008"
},
{
"name": "Exact member ordering preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-009"
},
{
"name": "Baseline lineage preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-010"
},
{
"name": "Correlation groups recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-011"
},
{
"name": "Dependence classifications recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-012"
},
{
"name": "Duplicate records do not become independent support",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-013"
},
{
"name": "Contradictions preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-014"
},
{
"name": "No automatic support restoration",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-015"
},
{
"name": "All readiness dimensions present",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-016"
},
{
"name": "All readiness states conservative",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-017"
},
{
"name": "No composite readiness score",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-018"
},
{
"name": "Deployment evidence remains not established",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-019"
},
{
"name": "Physical validation remains not established",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-020"
},
{
"name": "Decision state is published",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-021"
},
{
"name": "Reviewer mode is published",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-022"
},
{
"name": "Evidence opened is recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-023"
},
{
"name": "Contrary indicators are recorded",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-024"
},
{
"name": "Qualifications are preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-025"
},
{
"name": "Residual unknowns are preserved",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-026"
},
{
"name": "Append-oriented event chain valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-027"
},
{
"name": "Readiness artifact digest valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-028"
},
{
"name": "Lineage digest valid",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-029"
},
{
"name": "No baseline activation",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-030"
},
{
"name": "No production authority write",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-031"
},
{
"name": "No software deployment",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-032"
},
{
"name": "No force authorization",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-033"
},
{
"name": "No release promotion",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-034"
},
{
"name": "No history deletion or overwrite",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-035"
},
{
"name": "No public persistence",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-036"
},
{
"name": "Public boundary exact",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-037"
},
{
"name": "Synthetic null-sink termination",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "SRB-038"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"credentials": false,
"external_command_channel": false,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"payload_control": false,
"production_authority_write": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_coordinates": false,
"real_keys": false,
"real_topology": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_ranking": false,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal_guidance": false,
"vehicle_control": false,
"weapon_functions": false,
"weapon_target_pairing": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_FEDERATION_SCOPE_ONLY",
"SHARED_IMPLEMENTATION_AND_BASELINE_LINEAGE_RECORDED",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_CUSTOMER_SYSTEM_VALIDATION_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"readiness_artifact_sha256": "709e99606c8dcdbe094eb72d798b6de1fadbcabecbc8dde337bc7b2f2c5f8aa0",
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"dimension": "constitutional_identity_continuity",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "authority_kernel_continuity",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "workload_identity_and_attestation",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "key_epoch_and_revocation_distribution",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "software_model_policy_configuration_integrity",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "immutable_evidence_and_provenance",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "minimum_sovereign_function",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "partitioned_operation_within_predeclared_authority",
"qualification": "Partition behavior and authority remain conjunctive.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "reconciliation_after_restored_connectivity",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "attested_reconstitution",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "public_private_compartment_boundary",
"qualification": "Constituent evidence remains synthetic and shares baseline or implementation lineage.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "reviewer_independence",
"qualification": "0 independently qualified member(s); 9 correlated or derivative member(s).",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "rollback_and_supersession_control",
"qualification": "The constituent review proposes state only; no baseline activation is executed.",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"qualification": "Repository and synthetic federation evidence does not establish cPanel, Flask/MySQL/Passenger, TLS, or production-host acceptance.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"dimension": "physical_customer_system_validation",
"qualification": "No physical hardware, customer network, operational environment, accreditation, or certification evidence is included.",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"readiness_event_chain_sha256": "f978951c37adff5b50cac0b517c9249dca30053df94d7e4bdb13f77964235636",
"readiness_events": [
{
"detail": "sovereign-readiness-baseline",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-000",
"event_sha256": "576f2cf23b47513bf0beaaff65bbbdd93e28c87e314672a7dc165d363dd46e15",
"index": 0,
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"state": "FEDERATION_SCOPE_DECLARED"
},
{
"detail": "9 exact RC22 review packages",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-001",
"event_sha256": "e84ad71e56aaf1512b7a73d69e28a6b98ef5afc5e6e26314941e69ec8f77232c",
"index": 1,
"previous_event_sha256": "576f2cf23b47513bf0beaaff65bbbdd93e28c87e314672a7dc165d363dd46e15",
"state": "CONSTITUENT_PACKAGES_VERIFIED"
},
{
"detail": "1 parent baseline digest(s)",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-002",
"event_sha256": "3259d8103e1bac5771e0188d92ed6d0446201171f06031608cec830be52f20bd",
"index": 2,
"previous_event_sha256": "e84ad71e56aaf1512b7a73d69e28a6b98ef5afc5e6e26314941e69ec8f77232c",
"state": "BASELINE_LINEAGE_VERIFIED"
},
{
"detail": "26 correlation groups",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-003",
"event_sha256": "b4dfea047f2c3d5623dd22aa7693d044f94581fcb94579ee12cede5f4a95c8bf",
"index": 3,
"previous_event_sha256": "3259d8103e1bac5771e0188d92ed6d0446201171f06031608cec830be52f20bd",
"state": "DEPENDENCE_ANALYZED"
},
{
"detail": "11 contradiction or defeater records",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-004",
"event_sha256": "2a4b619a4db31062cf1c1e15c306aca04f959e12db0c0e1d143229d2c7563586",
"index": 4,
"previous_event_sha256": "b4dfea047f2c3d5623dd22aa7693d044f94581fcb94579ee12cede5f4a95c8bf",
"state": "CONTRADICTIONS_PRESERVED"
},
{
"detail": "15 independent dimensions",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-005",
"event_sha256": "bce2c5b494f716482284c9ec4ba2822302e8306fea5b7e1c0b3165f000d6aa15",
"index": 5,
"previous_event_sha256": "2a4b619a4db31062cf1c1e15c306aca04f959e12db0c0e1d143229d2c7563586",
"state": "READINESS_DIMENSIONS_EVALUATED"
},
{
"detail": "independent-machine-review",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-006",
"event_sha256": "36f352c3e04156cf00604022f203ffc79129fd64e25e75f1a428f04dc0baac61",
"index": 6,
"previous_event_sha256": "bce2c5b494f716482284c9ec4ba2822302e8306fea5b7e1c0b3165f000d6aa15",
"state": "REVIEWER_PROFILE_RECORDED"
},
{
"detail": "READY_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-007",
"event_sha256": "cfaca8abeb60528a2ec5cfaee8f6b837de5ad7be35e29589e6cd59d70d718724",
"index": 7,
"previous_event_sha256": "36f352c3e04156cf00604022f203ffc79129fd64e25e75f1a428f04dc0baac61",
"state": "READINESS_DECISION_RECORDED"
},
{
"detail": "No production or synthetic accepted baseline was activated.",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-008",
"event_sha256": "af48aa01ce96255bda97744e612fb5620ec98927abe64ae2c3969bc85dc03a21",
"index": 8,
"previous_event_sha256": "cfaca8abeb60528a2ec5cfaee8f6b837de5ad7be35e29589e6cd59d70d718724",
"state": "NO_BASELINE_ACTIVATION"
},
{
"detail": "No operational authority was minted or restored.",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-009",
"event_sha256": "c2d84b9a4cd4b931a5e57c9e2b823a99ee93b2b7149b0e93ebf15d528aaffce2",
"index": 9,
"previous_event_sha256": "af48aa01ce96255bda97744e612fb5620ec98927abe64ae2c3969bc85dc03a21",
"state": "NO_AUTHORITY_WRITE"
},
{
"detail": "Deterministic export may be produced.",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-010",
"event_sha256": "41bd98ac2e97bf823ce538d04e5f76b4d4440375d90580954a32ded6a6e6a854",
"index": 10,
"previous_event_sha256": "c2d84b9a4cd4b931a5e57c9e2b823a99ee93b2b7149b0e93ebf15d528aaffce2",
"state": "EVIDENCE_PACKAGE_READY"
},
{
"detail": "All public derived actions terminate at the synthetic null sink.",
"event_id": "SRB-EVT-011",
"event_sha256": "f978951c37adff5b50cac0b517c9249dca30053df94d7e4bdb13f77964235636",
"index": 11,
"previous_event_sha256": "41bd98ac2e97bf823ce538d04e5f76b4d4440375d90580954a32ded6a6e6a854",
"state": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK"
}
],
"readiness_sequence": 1,
"readiness_transition_proposed": true,
"release": "2.0.0-rc.23-WIP",
"release_decision_changed": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative hardware-root, device, network-partition, security, accessibility, and performance behavior remains untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, certification, procurement, and customer-system approval remain outside this synthetic record."
],
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-SOVEREIGN-READINESS-REVIEW-SCOPE-RC23",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-SRR-INDEPENDENT-03",
"implementation_lineage": "DIVERSE_SYNTHETIC_READINESS_LINEAGE-C",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"reviewer_mode_label": "Independent machine review",
"schema": "evulgare.sovereign-readiness-board.v1",
"software_deployed": false,
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"structured_rationale": "Exact verified campaign-review artifacts were federated without converting correlated derivatives into independent support. Readiness dimensions, contradictions, qualifications, unresolved defeaters, deployment gaps, and physical-system gaps remain independent and visible.",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING",
"PHYSICAL_SYSTEM_EVIDENCE_PENDING"
]
}Sovereign readiness federation ready. Exact published identifiers only. No baseline was activated.
PUBLIC TERMINAL: SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK
RESEARCH TRACEABILITY