autonomous-defense-kernel
Terminal state: SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK
TECHNICAL ANSWERABILITY / EVIDENCE FEDERATION
VERIFY THE ROOTS. ALIGN THE CAUSAL PATH. PRESERVE THE CLAIM LINEAGE.
Federate independently scoped synthetic assurance records, expose evidence dependence, align every record to the ten Technical Answerability phases, identify the first divergence, and preserve every support, challenge, qualification, defeater, invalidation, and residual unknown.
CAUSAL DIVERGENCE AND CLAIM-LINEAGE BOARD
RECORD COUNT IS NOT INDEPENDENT CORROBORATION.
Every visual, tabular, narrative, event, and proof representation consumes one deterministic Python federation result.
d8cd54964a69…CAUSAL ALIGNMENT
Ten-phase Technical Answerability spine
No source can manufacture support by skipping a failed phase.
What information actually existed?
- Aggregate state
- SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS
- Source cells
- 7
- Changed from baseline
- NO
PHASE MATRIX
Source-by-phase causal alignment
Horizontal scroll is contained inside the matrix; the page itself remains liquid.
| Phase | Technical Answerability | Decision Reconstruction | Decision Review | Autonomous Defense Kernel | Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review | Continuity Campaign Review | Industrial Resilience Review | Aggregate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01Evidence | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS |
| 02Provenance | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS |
| 03Uncertainty | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS |
| 04Interpretation | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS |
| 05Options | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS |
| 06Authority | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS |
| 07Runtime assurance | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS |
| 08Review | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | NOT ESTABLISHED |
| 09Outcome | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | NOT ESTABLISHEDROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | NOT ESTABLISHED |
| 10History | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-DECISION-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDSROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW | SUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDS |
FIRST DIVERGENCE
No divergence
No phase differs from the bounded federation baseline.
No causal-phase divergence is recorded against the bounded baseline.
No aligned phase differs from the bounded federation baseline.
EVIDENCE DEPENDENCE
Count root sources, not document volume
7 records resolve to 7 independent roots.
continuity-campaign-review
critical-infrastructure-review
decision-reconstruction
decision-review
industrial-resilience-review
technical-answerability
Correlation groups
autonomous-defense-kernel
continuity-campaign-review
decision-reconstruction · decision-review
industrial-resilience-review
critical-infrastructure-review
technical-answerability
CLAIM RELATIONSHIPS
Support, challenge, qualification, defeat, and invalidation remain explicit
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 6
- Challenge roots
- 1
- Support roots
- 4
- Challenge roots
- 3
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 7
- Challenge roots
- 0
- Support roots
- 0
- Challenge roots
- 7
- Support roots
- 0
- Challenge roots
- 7
APPEND-ORIENTED CLAIM LINEAGE
Historic support is preserved when a claim changes state
4b1b83bca8d80dccf02d…- 01CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITYSUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
205c0caeb47d2daf… - 02CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESSSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
e456eba4aaef2594… - 03CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCESUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
5137faace668eaea… - 04CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITYSUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
b3267f4ed1b9571a… - 05CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATIONSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
f69e7c44d24651e9… - 06CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORTSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
3462ce65b8e1d6a1… - 07CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESSSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
c49b8c1c766d8eb7… - 08CLAIM-AUTHORITYSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
19c818360029ae5a… - 09CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSESUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
02efbd48a143d6f6… - 10CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATIONSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
d8d3d88c57a33fe3… - 11CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATIONSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
e998e4ef3c702d3a… - 12CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATIONSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
c3d355f39a0936bf… - 13CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATIONSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
940cfd17051cfb56… - 14CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCESUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
b4c7ae63768b0243… - 15CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITSSUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_6_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
a00a3e2387af6709… - 16CLAIM-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCESUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATED_FROM_4_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
8d2f9780bf2c9ba2… - 17CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITYSUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
8449c58e50105344… - 18CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITYSUPPORTED WITHIN DECLARED BOUNDS
FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
48847de889877a6d… - 19CLAIM-DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCENOT ESTABLISHED
FEDERATED_FROM_0_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
8eb7d315d6e5d6e9… - 20CLAIM-INDEPENDENT_VALIDATIONNOT ESTABLISHED
FEDERATED_FROM_0_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS
f0de8e5a5f8dd462…
REVIEW QUALITY
Interaction is not automatically merits review or independent judgment
Current reviewer
- Mode
- Independent machine review
- Quality
- INDEPENDENT_MACHINE_REVIEW
- Merits capable
- YES
- Independent
- YES
- Primary evidence access
- YES
- Contrary hypothesis reviewed
- YES
Independent readiness dimensions
CONTRADICTIONS AND RESIDUAL UNKNOWNS
Unfavorable evidence remains visible
Contradictions
No contradiction is established in this profile.
Residual unknowns
- External factual truth is not established by record integrity alone.
- Production deployment, legal status, accreditation, certification, procurement, and customer acceptance remain outside this synthetic federation.
Decision blockers
- deployment_evidence
- independent_validation
EVENT LEDGER
Deterministic federation history
9005be6a3a81918edff0…- 01SOURCE_RECORDS_VERIFIEDPASS
7 exact deterministic source wrappers evaluated.
35a9d831b7177b3b… - 02ROOT_SOURCES_DEDUPLICATEDPASS
7 independent roots remain after 0 derivative record(s) are deduplicated.
7c959d76b9073465… - 03CORRELATION_GROUPS_CLASSIFIEDPASS
6 correlation groups preserved.
e34a8a10e5610ea3… - 04CAUSAL_PHASES_ALIGNEDPASS
All source records aligned to the ten Technical Answerability phases.
1fe8170a7d757bd5… - 05FIRST_DIVERGENCE_IDENTIFIEDUNCHANGED
No divergence / No divergence
0b7266dc1343ea4b… - 06CLAIM_RELATIONSHIPS_CLASSIFIEDPASS
122 support, qualification, challenge, defeat, or invalidation relationships recorded.
8a2cd763faafc17a… - 07REVIEW_QUALITY_EVALUATEDPASS
INDEPENDENT_MACHINE_REVIEW
ca473112397b8378… - 08CONTRADICTIONS_AND_DEFEATERS_PRESERVEDPASS
0 contradiction(s); 1 defeater(s).
58d7f8836fa81a86… - 09CLAIM_LINEAGE_SEALEDPASS
20 append-oriented lineage events preserved.
a087c95672880a1a… - 10FEDERATION_DECISION_DERIVEDFEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS
FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS
0dddc78288e94d50… - 11SYNTHETIC_TERMINATIONSYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK
No production action, baseline activation, or release promotion was executed.
9005be6a3a81918e…
PROOF INSPECTOR
Named invariants, never a universal score
- TAF-INV-001At least six source families are publishedPASS
- TAF-INV-002Ten Technical Answerability phases are publishedPASS
- TAF-INV-003At least eighteen independent claim dimensions are publishedPASS
- TAF-INV-004All required relationship semantics are publishedPASS
- TAF-INV-005All required claim states are publishedPASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-01baseline-qualified is deterministicPASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-02baseline-qualified verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-03baseline-qualified aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-04baseline-qualified preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-05baseline-qualified event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-06baseline-qualified claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-07baseline-qualified terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-08baseline-qualified performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-01duplicate-derivative-stress is deterministicPASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-02duplicate-derivative-stress verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-03duplicate-derivative-stress aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-04duplicate-derivative-stress preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-05duplicate-derivative-stress event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-06duplicate-derivative-stress claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-07duplicate-derivative-stress terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-08duplicate-derivative-stress performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-01correlated-source-hold is deterministicPASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-02correlated-source-hold verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-03correlated-source-hold aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-04correlated-source-hold preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-05correlated-source-hold event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-06correlated-source-hold claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-07correlated-source-hold terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-08correlated-source-hold performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-01uncertainty-divergence is deterministicPASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-02uncertainty-divergence verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-03uncertainty-divergence aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-04uncertainty-divergence preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-05uncertainty-divergence event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-06uncertainty-divergence claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-07uncertainty-divergence terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-08uncertainty-divergence performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-01authority-runtime-divergence is deterministicPASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-02authority-runtime-divergence verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-03authority-runtime-divergence aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-04authority-runtime-divergence preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-05authority-runtime-divergence event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-06authority-runtime-divergence claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-07authority-runtime-divergence terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-08authority-runtime-divergence performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-01review-quality-failure is deterministicPASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-02review-quality-failure verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-03review-quality-failure aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-04review-quality-failure preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-05review-quality-failure event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-06review-quality-failure claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-07review-quality-failure terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-08review-quality-failure performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-01restored-availability-support-suspended is deterministicPASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-02restored-availability-support-suspended verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-03restored-availability-support-suspended aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-04restored-availability-support-suspended preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-05restored-availability-support-suspended event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-06restored-availability-support-suspended claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-07restored-availability-support-suspended terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-08restored-availability-support-suspended performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-01contradiction-defeater is deterministicPASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-02contradiction-defeater verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-03contradiction-defeater aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-04contradiction-defeater preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-05contradiction-defeater event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-06contradiction-defeater claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-07contradiction-defeater terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-08contradiction-defeater performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-01protected-boundary-failure is deterministicPASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-02protected-boundary-failure verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-03protected-boundary-failure aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-04protected-boundary-failure preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-05protected-boundary-failure event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-06protected-boundary-failure claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-07protected-boundary-failure terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-08protected-boundary-failure performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-01all-gates-reviewed-synthetic is deterministicPASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-02all-gates-reviewed-synthetic verifies every sourcePASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-03all-gates-reviewed-synthetic aligns all phasesPASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-04all-gates-reviewed-synthetic preserves every dimensionPASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-05all-gates-reviewed-synthetic event chain verifiesPASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-06all-gates-reviewed-synthetic claim lineage verifiesPASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-07all-gates-reviewed-synthetic terminates at synthetic null sinkPASS
- TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-08all-gates-reviewed-synthetic performs no production actionPASS
- TAF-INV-DUP-01Duplicate derivatives do not increase independent rootsPASS
- TAF-INV-CORR-01Correlated roots block independent corroborationPASS
- TAF-INV-AUTH-01Expired authority is withdrawn rather than averaged awayPASS
- TAF-INV-REV-01A human click does not establish merits reviewPASS
- TAF-INV-RESTORE-01Restored availability does not restore evidentiary supportPASS
- TAF-INV-CONTRA-01Contradictions remain explicit and block supportPASS
- TAF-INV-BOUNDARY-01Protected-boundary failure withdraws or suspends claimsPASS
- TAF-INV-CMP-01Baseline comparison identifies a first divergencePASS
- TAF-INV-BRANCH-01Counterfactual branch is isolated and unexecutedPASS
- TAF-INV-PKG-01Deterministic evidence package verifiesPASS
- TAF-INV-INPUT-01Unsafe and private fields are rejectedPASS
- TAF-INV-PERSIST-01Public persistence is disabledPASS
- TAF-INV-AUTO-01Automatic production action is prohibitedPASS
- TAF-INV-TERMINAL-01All public actions terminate at synthetic null sinkPASS
ANALYTICAL NARRATIVE
Same state, readable without graphics
Federation. Qualified evidence federation baseline federates 7 deterministic source records into 7 independent root sources.
First divergence. No causal-phase divergence is established against the bounded baseline.
Decision. The bounded federation decision is FEDERATION SUPPORTED WITH QUALIFICATIONS. No production state was changed.
Evidence discipline. Hash integrity and replayability establish recorded-state continuity, not factual truth, legal approval, or operational readiness.
RAW SYNTHETIC EVIDENCE
Canonical deterministic federation result
{
"baseline_activated": false,
"blockers": [
"deployment_evidence",
"independent_validation"
],
"blocking_dimensions": [
"deployment_evidence",
"independent_validation"
],
"claim_lineage": [
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"event_sha256": "205c0caeb47d2dafd44ecc18c1185c5e27654fa6d63070c2c28c96530f3ed208",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "18d730765c712a73308fb2fbe275e28b903f8a54e5a5be47933868ba19b8158f",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-001",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 1,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"event_sha256": "e456eba4aaef25940083845f07ea95bb61979ed644a718577fc87c6ac46e1152",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "3c8c5a4a4010a96fd0291935d0375df9c57ee0b9d9812eae7c85c885e204cfd4",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-002",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "18d730765c712a73308fb2fbe275e28b903f8a54e5a5be47933868ba19b8158f",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 2,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 25
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"event_sha256": "5137faace668eaeab0a7b82c23b168299934de6be8efb372fe7f93a5323054de",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "327c9274f31f7b33ff1994ebf79a0f0adc11dc7af34f3dad087ce34cdb250948",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-003",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "3c8c5a4a4010a96fd0291935d0375df9c57ee0b9d9812eae7c85c885e204cfd4",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 3,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 50
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"event_sha256": "b3267f4ed1b9571a368a65aa5a4d53cc13e936872798f139b8e52ab640daca9d",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "e0629aec25aafd776f53efebf588bfdf3a8074c25e849e52a0d6b410deef9a47",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-004",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "327c9274f31f7b33ff1994ebf79a0f0adc11dc7af34f3dad087ce34cdb250948",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 4,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 75
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"event_sha256": "f69e7c44d24651e9a4211c5ef0dc6d3819447af3486107d62cd2ec6efe81c016",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "ed18a51b76429834b6e6ebf6f33563f2eba76f6832bae68e4e069ac2585de20c",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-005",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "e0629aec25aafd776f53efebf588bfdf3a8074c25e849e52a0d6b410deef9a47",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 5,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"event_sha256": "3462ce65b8e1d6a1cd80862020c78e3b7cb45e799ce01a083190945e526a0fcf",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "69b7bf7cb765b83a7fb518cb2cf23d2c28ef5d94804cd06a450c5215d19a5715",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-006",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "ed18a51b76429834b6e6ebf6f33563f2eba76f6832bae68e4e069ac2585de20c",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 6,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 125
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"event_sha256": "c49b8c1c766d8eb72e3d0bb304b410ee332d6511a870d1667ec7e5a0ce0eeb33",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "80cd461cfb9d7f6f6f6e120ca8aab3538632def7b02a8308386807609e21b1c7",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-007",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "69b7bf7cb765b83a7fb518cb2cf23d2c28ef5d94804cd06a450c5215d19a5715",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 7,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 150
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"event_sha256": "19c818360029ae5a7166c2fdd1b3873e72fd875db3c870b06cb2c312d2c0a116",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "a3afbf7798d78002db66e76ec45f0a71d30abc0b27e9e3f2ad112ccbcbbeba65",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-008",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "80cd461cfb9d7f6f6f6e120ca8aab3538632def7b02a8308386807609e21b1c7",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 8,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 175
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"event_sha256": "02efbd48a143d6f67e272eb6e6331183133662ff75d2f8fc2b7be0d91207b1fa",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "4f221e0238e920d3ff1436389be2d9e3c5e819a41a3869713486d16b5b158485",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-009",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "a3afbf7798d78002db66e76ec45f0a71d30abc0b27e9e3f2ad112ccbcbbeba65",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 9,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"event_sha256": "d8d3d88c57a33fe3a6761dda5d47c0b1a482cbbff02caef927556ab91b174b1b",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "b8fc443d40dcbb051710b454d2f3e8a6e347156a2d34065c45c541d737ea0919",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-010",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "4f221e0238e920d3ff1436389be2d9e3c5e819a41a3869713486d16b5b158485",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 10,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 225
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"event_sha256": "e998e4ef3c702d3a3ace8735b410384c70ab0ee77dc48032fe3659be3c2d38f9",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "60f8125d6f26eae38c0b04235dd1d4ca61d27c281a0dec1775e36f4e4319bf7e",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-011",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "b8fc443d40dcbb051710b454d2f3e8a6e347156a2d34065c45c541d737ea0919",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 11,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 250
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"event_sha256": "c3d355f39a0936bfd4625eaae5c7646f126e986e7e66b9147d9889765c50dfef",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "3e355f4213ddf30dd4c01611998056ae389c16c3243a1bd92e4cbd72c29f1b5a",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-012",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "60f8125d6f26eae38c0b04235dd1d4ca61d27c281a0dec1775e36f4e4319bf7e",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 12,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 275
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"event_sha256": "940cfd17051cfb566b2d8d8cb1056ee0a28fd632b4610f4a5c54e86e5fdb01bc",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "b5d8edddc859a2d9a3985fd872f4cf862953ca0f48aa43edd96504d7508c0dbb",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-013",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "3e355f4213ddf30dd4c01611998056ae389c16c3243a1bd92e4cbd72c29f1b5a",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 13,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"event_sha256": "b4c7ae63768b0243d84177dc8fd85967b7c8c7da87b42937e2dc18d66ad092f3",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "14f6b1cee668e70573992b001fdbbbfe0b8cf30c790034a3048bf48cb790e5a3",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-014",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "b5d8edddc859a2d9a3985fd872f4cf862953ca0f48aa43edd96504d7508c0dbb",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 14,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 325
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"event_sha256": "a00a3e2387af6709356a7dd8bd671b6cc1612467233de4fca01ddf9bc84d1476",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "42e572008ae493ab113c9e459850e1f1c67a4446c810c3d3502e9814ae24e83f",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-015",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "14f6b1cee668e70573992b001fdbbbfe0b8cf30c790034a3048bf48cb790e5a3",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_6_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_6_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 15,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 350
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"event_sha256": "8d2f9780bf2c9ba2ddaa23fc33196331af6a352b626efbdd4f4a087afcf57a3f",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "988140e1755348cd9b50fe199dfcd43377e3e2a57c014f636dce6604a320a41a",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-016",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "42e572008ae493ab113c9e459850e1f1c67a4446c810c3d3502e9814ae24e83f",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_4_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_4_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 16,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 375
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"event_sha256": "8449c58e501053441fd4e36c26014eca8d5b94ba465a01b393ccc032fde62341",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "3d47e55ff8aeda338c7c6a45cb56712dd3b143c3eb16627f5b55799d78a08d38",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-017",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "988140e1755348cd9b50fe199dfcd43377e3e2a57c014f636dce6604a320a41a",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 17,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"event_sha256": "48847de889877a6dd8a4f73b9352b3b9b564d283eec76c67f2c01fb55b7e88e4",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "a603a03b375c68d29739e74a72b57d96a5ee1b9308463bb933b818c75a71e383",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-018",
"new_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "3d47e55ff8aeda338c7c6a45cb56712dd3b143c3eb16627f5b55799d78a08d38",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_7_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 18,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 425
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE",
"event_sha256": "8eb7d315d6e5d6e9b8e34bccb650268e4fb9b9d2baa5330090841281bc43d9f1",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "2ca7d1d21218babd5986bf4a0ffcb25f9a3f14b5ebc5cb0852c68f842a685754",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-019",
"new_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "a603a03b375c68d29739e74a72b57d96a5ee1b9308463bb933b818c75a71e383",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_0_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_0_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 19,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 450
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION",
"event_sha256": "f0de8e5a5f8dd4629533acae5764966ac1b863afa2a468c44d28b5d25498edfa",
"event_type": "CLAIM_STATE_FEDERATED",
"lineage_event_sha256": "4b1b83bca8d80dccf02d0e306438f1b888c113c1b85fc1d4546ec90456f2c7e8",
"lineage_id": "TAF-LIN-020",
"new_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"previous_lineage_sha256": "2ca7d1d21218babd5986bf4a0ffcb25f9a3f14b5ebc5cb0852c68f842a685754",
"prior_state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reason_codes": [
"FEDERATED_FROM_0_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS"
],
"relationship_summary": "FEDERATED_FROM_0_INDEPENDENT_ROOTS",
"sequence": 20,
"source_refs": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"timestamp_ms": 475
}
],
"claim_lineage_sha256": "4b1b83bca8d80dccf02d0e306438f1b888c113c1b85fc1d4546ec90456f2c7e8",
"claim_relationships": [
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"dimension": "authority",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-AUTHORITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "reviewer_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"dimension": "authority",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-AUTHORITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"dimension": "authority",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-AUTHORITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"dimension": "authority",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-AUTHORITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"dimension": "authority",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-AUTHORITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "reviewer_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"dimension": "authority",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-AUTHORITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "reviewer_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"dimension": "authority",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-AUTHORITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"relationship": "QUALIFIES",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"dimension": "reviewer_independence",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"federated_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"relationship": "SUPPORTS",
"relationship_id": "REL-ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_record_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"source_state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"claims": [
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOURCE_INTEGRITY",
"label": "SOURCE INTEGRITY",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_COMPLETENESS",
"label": "EVIDENCE COMPLETENESS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-EVIDENCE_INDEPENDENCE",
"label": "EVIDENCE INDEPENDENCE",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-PROVENANCE_CONTINUITY",
"label": "PROVENANCE CONTINUITY",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-UNCERTAINTY_REPRESENTATION",
"label": "UNCERTAINTY REPRESENTATION",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INTERPRETATION_SUPPORT",
"label": "INTERPRETATION SUPPORT",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OPTION_SPACE_COMPLETENESS",
"label": "OPTION-SPACE COMPLETENESS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-AUTHORITY",
"label": "CURRENT DELEGATED AUTHORITY",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DECLARED_PURPOSE",
"label": "DECLARED PURPOSE",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-SOFTWARE_ATTESTATION",
"label": "SOFTWARE ATTESTATION",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-MODEL_ATTESTATION",
"label": "MODEL ATTESTATION",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-POLICY_ATTESTATION",
"label": "POLICY ATTESTATION",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-CONFIGURATION_ATTESTATION",
"label": "CONFIGURATION ATTESTATION",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"label": "RUNTIME ASSURANCE",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL"
],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_MERITS",
"label": "REVIEWER MERITS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW"
],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-REVIEWER_INDEPENDENCE",
"label": "REVIEWER INDEPENDENCE",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-OUTCOME_RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"label": "OUTCOME RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-HISTORY_INTEGRITY",
"label": "HISTORY INTEGRITY",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
]
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE",
"label": "DEPLOYMENT EVIDENCE",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"supporting_root_sources": []
},
{
"challenging_root_sources": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
],
"claim_id": "CLAIM-INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION",
"label": "INDEPENDENT VALIDATION",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"supporting_root_sources": []
}
],
"contradictions": [],
"decision": "FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"decision_label": "The federation supports part of the claim set with explicit qualifications.",
"decision_reason": "The claim set remains qualified by deployment and independent-validation gaps.",
"deduplication": {
"correlation_groups": [
{
"correlated": false,
"correlation_group": "CORR-AUTHORITY-RUNTIME",
"member_count": 1,
"record_count": 1,
"record_ids": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"shared_failure_possible": false,
"source_families": [
"autonomous-defense-kernel"
]
},
{
"correlated": false,
"correlation_group": "CORR-CONTINUITY-REVIEW",
"member_count": 1,
"record_count": 1,
"record_ids": [
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"shared_failure_possible": false,
"source_families": [
"continuity-campaign-review"
]
},
{
"correlated": true,
"correlation_group": "CORR-DECISION-CHAIN",
"member_count": 2,
"record_count": 2,
"record_ids": [
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"shared_failure_possible": true,
"source_families": [
"decision-reconstruction",
"decision-review"
]
},
{
"correlated": false,
"correlation_group": "CORR-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"member_count": 1,
"record_count": 1,
"record_ids": [
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"shared_failure_possible": false,
"source_families": [
"industrial-resilience-review"
]
},
{
"correlated": false,
"correlation_group": "CORR-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"member_count": 1,
"record_count": 1,
"record_ids": [
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"shared_failure_possible": false,
"source_families": [
"critical-infrastructure-review"
]
},
{
"correlated": false,
"correlation_group": "CORR-TA-CORE",
"member_count": 1,
"record_count": 1,
"record_ids": [
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"shared_failure_possible": false,
"source_families": [
"technical-answerability"
]
}
],
"deduplicated_record_count": 0,
"independent_root_count": 7,
"record_count": 7,
"root_groups": [
{
"derivative_count": 1,
"derivative_ids": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"independent_root": true,
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL"
},
{
"derivative_count": 1,
"derivative_ids": [
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"independent_root": true,
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN"
},
{
"derivative_count": 1,
"derivative_ids": [
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"independent_root": true,
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW"
},
{
"derivative_count": 1,
"derivative_ids": [
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"independent_root": true,
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION"
},
{
"derivative_count": 1,
"derivative_ids": [
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"independent_root": true,
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW"
},
{
"derivative_count": 1,
"derivative_ids": [
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"independent_root": true,
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW"
},
{
"derivative_count": 1,
"derivative_ids": [
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"independent_root": true,
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE"
}
],
"root_source_count": 7,
"root_sources": [
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"record_count": 1,
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_families": [
"autonomous-defense-kernel"
]
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"record_count": 1,
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_families": [
"continuity-campaign-review"
]
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"record_count": 1,
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_families": [
"critical-infrastructure-review"
]
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"record_count": 1,
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_families": [
"decision-reconstruction"
]
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"record_count": 1,
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_families": [
"decision-review"
]
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"record_count": 1,
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_families": [
"industrial-resilience-review"
]
},
{
"derivative_count_not_independence": false,
"record_count": 1,
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_families": [
"technical-answerability"
]
}
]
},
"deployment_executed": false,
"dimensions": [
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"label": "SOURCE INTEGRITY",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"label": "EVIDENCE COMPLETENESS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"label": "EVIDENCE INDEPENDENCE",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"label": "PROVENANCE CONTINUITY",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"label": "UNCERTAINTY REPRESENTATION",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"label": "INTERPRETATION SUPPORT",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"label": "OPTION-SPACE COMPLETENESS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "authority",
"label": "CURRENT DELEGATED AUTHORITY",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"label": "DECLARED PURPOSE",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"label": "SOFTWARE ATTESTATION",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"label": "MODEL ATTESTATION",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"label": "POLICY ATTESTATION",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"label": "CONFIGURATION ATTESTATION",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"label": "RUNTIME ASSURANCE",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"label": "REVIEWER MERITS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 6
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "reviewer_independence",
"label": "REVIEWER INDEPENDENCE",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 4
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"label": "OUTCOME RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"label": "HISTORY INTEGRITY",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": true,
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"label": "DEPLOYMENT EVIDENCE",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"supporting_independent_roots": 0
},
{
"blocking": true,
"dimension": "independent_validation",
"label": "INDEPENDENT VALIDATION",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"supporting_independent_roots": 0
}
],
"engine_version": "1.0.0",
"event_chain_sha256": "9005be6a3a81918edff07737f65513fbd011f88f7f523d2b53ac29977e19b4d6",
"events": [
{
"code": "SOURCE_RECORDS_VERIFIED",
"description": "7 exact deterministic source wrappers evaluated.",
"detail": "7 exact deterministic source wrappers evaluated.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-001",
"event_sha256": "35a9d831b7177b3bedbc59c844234e752256ca6601cdca18a8ff8ed39352ad63",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 1,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ROOT_SOURCES_DEDUPLICATED",
"description": "7 independent roots remain after 0 derivative record(s) are deduplicated.",
"detail": "7 independent roots remain after 0 derivative record(s) are deduplicated.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-002",
"event_sha256": "7c959d76b9073465bf9eb4528c72e4ab3f6e06c31c6474eef9dffd86af6082fa",
"previous_event_sha256": "35a9d831b7177b3bedbc59c844234e752256ca6601cdca18a8ff8ed39352ad63",
"sequence": 2,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "CORRELATION_GROUPS_CLASSIFIED",
"description": "6 correlation groups preserved.",
"detail": "6 correlation groups preserved.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-003",
"event_sha256": "e34a8a10e5610ea3c0374c35cf814f781954e2da896f03e160a3434e5b563128",
"previous_event_sha256": "7c959d76b9073465bf9eb4528c72e4ab3f6e06c31c6474eef9dffd86af6082fa",
"sequence": 3,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CAUSAL_PHASES_ALIGNED",
"description": "All source records aligned to the ten Technical Answerability phases.",
"detail": "All source records aligned to the ten Technical Answerability phases.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-004",
"event_sha256": "1fe8170a7d757bd57acddbef1859c8eb37afd04b9a79ec0bcc74609c483ff2d8",
"previous_event_sha256": "e34a8a10e5610ea3c0374c35cf814f781954e2da896f03e160a3434e5b563128",
"sequence": 4,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "FIRST_DIVERGENCE_IDENTIFIED",
"description": "No divergence / No divergence",
"detail": "No divergence / No divergence",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-005",
"event_sha256": "0b7266dc1343ea4b1baf367a72a39491bb8429b594b605a291ce4fdd930097cc",
"previous_event_sha256": "1fe8170a7d757bd57acddbef1859c8eb37afd04b9a79ec0bcc74609c483ff2d8",
"sequence": 5,
"state": "UNCHANGED",
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "CLAIM_RELATIONSHIPS_CLASSIFIED",
"description": "122 support, qualification, challenge, defeat, or invalidation relationships recorded.",
"detail": "122 support, qualification, challenge, defeat, or invalidation relationships recorded.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-006",
"event_sha256": "8a2cd763faafc17aedc9a56d1c0739e469e2488816bf77ee6722a4f204a9c9b4",
"previous_event_sha256": "0b7266dc1343ea4b1baf367a72a39491bb8429b594b605a291ce4fdd930097cc",
"sequence": 6,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_QUALITY_EVALUATED",
"description": "INDEPENDENT_MACHINE_REVIEW",
"detail": "INDEPENDENT_MACHINE_REVIEW",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-007",
"event_sha256": "ca473112397b8378eb1546f00906d55beca660248d1d522668b9ce29e457f75b",
"previous_event_sha256": "8a2cd763faafc17aedc9a56d1c0739e469e2488816bf77ee6722a4f204a9c9b4",
"sequence": 7,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "CONTRADICTIONS_AND_DEFEATERS_PRESERVED",
"description": "0 contradiction(s); 1 defeater(s).",
"detail": "0 contradiction(s); 1 defeater(s).",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-008",
"event_sha256": "58d7f8836fa81a86bc7b3840f49dcd6ea8b4117bb37af4c1c41c981b5d4fb273",
"previous_event_sha256": "ca473112397b8378eb1546f00906d55beca660248d1d522668b9ce29e457f75b",
"sequence": 8,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "CLAIM_LINEAGE_SEALED",
"description": "20 append-oriented lineage events preserved.",
"detail": "20 append-oriented lineage events preserved.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-009",
"event_sha256": "a087c95672880a1a93db288afc1bfe7d3f8dcbec46de9f40a383fdf9a278e715",
"previous_event_sha256": "58d7f8836fa81a86bc7b3840f49dcd6ea8b4117bb37af4c1c41c981b5d4fb273",
"sequence": 9,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "FEDERATION_DECISION_DERIVED",
"description": "FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"detail": "FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-010",
"event_sha256": "0dddc78288e94d507671b6bffea1f32c94b6fbb61e5493f95d72a385baed4fbb",
"previous_event_sha256": "a087c95672880a1a93db288afc1bfe7d3f8dcbec46de9f40a383fdf9a278e715",
"sequence": 10,
"state": "FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"timestamp_ms": 900
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"description": "No production action, baseline activation, or release promotion was executed.",
"detail": "No production action, baseline activation, or release promotion was executed.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-011",
"event_sha256": "9005be6a3a81918edff07737f65513fbd011f88f7f523d2b53ac29977e19b4d6",
"previous_event_sha256": "0dddc78288e94d507671b6bffea1f32c94b6fbb61e5493f95d72a385baed4fbb",
"sequence": 11,
"state": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 1000
}
],
"federation_event_chain_sha256": "9005be6a3a81918edff07737f65513fbd011f88f7f523d2b53ac29977e19b4d6",
"federation_events": [
{
"code": "SOURCE_RECORDS_VERIFIED",
"detail": "7 exact deterministic source wrappers evaluated.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-001",
"event_sha256": "35a9d831b7177b3bedbc59c844234e752256ca6601cdca18a8ff8ed39352ad63",
"previous_event_sha256": "0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000",
"sequence": 1,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 0
},
{
"code": "ROOT_SOURCES_DEDUPLICATED",
"detail": "7 independent roots remain after 0 derivative record(s) are deduplicated.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-002",
"event_sha256": "7c959d76b9073465bf9eb4528c72e4ab3f6e06c31c6474eef9dffd86af6082fa",
"previous_event_sha256": "35a9d831b7177b3bedbc59c844234e752256ca6601cdca18a8ff8ed39352ad63",
"sequence": 2,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 100
},
{
"code": "CORRELATION_GROUPS_CLASSIFIED",
"detail": "6 correlation groups preserved.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-003",
"event_sha256": "e34a8a10e5610ea3c0374c35cf814f781954e2da896f03e160a3434e5b563128",
"previous_event_sha256": "7c959d76b9073465bf9eb4528c72e4ab3f6e06c31c6474eef9dffd86af6082fa",
"sequence": 3,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 200
},
{
"code": "CAUSAL_PHASES_ALIGNED",
"detail": "All source records aligned to the ten Technical Answerability phases.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-004",
"event_sha256": "1fe8170a7d757bd57acddbef1859c8eb37afd04b9a79ec0bcc74609c483ff2d8",
"previous_event_sha256": "e34a8a10e5610ea3c0374c35cf814f781954e2da896f03e160a3434e5b563128",
"sequence": 4,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 300
},
{
"code": "FIRST_DIVERGENCE_IDENTIFIED",
"detail": "No divergence / No divergence",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-005",
"event_sha256": "0b7266dc1343ea4b1baf367a72a39491bb8429b594b605a291ce4fdd930097cc",
"previous_event_sha256": "1fe8170a7d757bd57acddbef1859c8eb37afd04b9a79ec0bcc74609c483ff2d8",
"sequence": 5,
"state": "UNCHANGED",
"timestamp_ms": 400
},
{
"code": "CLAIM_RELATIONSHIPS_CLASSIFIED",
"detail": "122 support, qualification, challenge, defeat, or invalidation relationships recorded.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-006",
"event_sha256": "8a2cd763faafc17aedc9a56d1c0739e469e2488816bf77ee6722a4f204a9c9b4",
"previous_event_sha256": "0b7266dc1343ea4b1baf367a72a39491bb8429b594b605a291ce4fdd930097cc",
"sequence": 6,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 500
},
{
"code": "REVIEW_QUALITY_EVALUATED",
"detail": "INDEPENDENT_MACHINE_REVIEW",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-007",
"event_sha256": "ca473112397b8378eb1546f00906d55beca660248d1d522668b9ce29e457f75b",
"previous_event_sha256": "8a2cd763faafc17aedc9a56d1c0739e469e2488816bf77ee6722a4f204a9c9b4",
"sequence": 7,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 600
},
{
"code": "CONTRADICTIONS_AND_DEFEATERS_PRESERVED",
"detail": "0 contradiction(s); 1 defeater(s).",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-008",
"event_sha256": "58d7f8836fa81a86bc7b3840f49dcd6ea8b4117bb37af4c1c41c981b5d4fb273",
"previous_event_sha256": "ca473112397b8378eb1546f00906d55beca660248d1d522668b9ce29e457f75b",
"sequence": 8,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 700
},
{
"code": "CLAIM_LINEAGE_SEALED",
"detail": "20 append-oriented lineage events preserved.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-009",
"event_sha256": "a087c95672880a1a93db288afc1bfe7d3f8dcbec46de9f40a383fdf9a278e715",
"previous_event_sha256": "58d7f8836fa81a86bc7b3840f49dcd6ea8b4117bb37af4c1c41c981b5d4fb273",
"sequence": 9,
"state": "PASS",
"timestamp_ms": 800
},
{
"code": "FEDERATION_DECISION_DERIVED",
"detail": "FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-010",
"event_sha256": "0dddc78288e94d507671b6bffea1f32c94b6fbb61e5493f95d72a385baed4fbb",
"previous_event_sha256": "a087c95672880a1a93db288afc1bfe7d3f8dcbec46de9f40a383fdf9a278e715",
"sequence": 10,
"state": "FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"timestamp_ms": 900
},
{
"code": "SYNTHETIC_TERMINATION",
"detail": "No production action, baseline activation, or release promotion was executed.",
"event_id": "TAF-BASELINE-QUALIFIED-011",
"event_sha256": "9005be6a3a81918edff07737f65513fbd011f88f7f523d2b53ac29977e19b4d6",
"previous_event_sha256": "0dddc78288e94d507671b6bffea1f32c94b6fbb61e5493f95d72a385baed4fbb",
"sequence": 11,
"state": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"timestamp_ms": 1000
}
],
"federation_sha256": "d8cd54964a69a4de62e12eae538b5ec56c7d325c0566ec3718e1b5b4338f2b67",
"first_divergence": {
"baseline_state": "UNCHANGED",
"candidate_state": "UNCHANGED",
"differences": [],
"dimension": "NONE",
"dimension_label": "No divergence",
"diverged": false,
"established": false,
"label": "No divergence",
"phase": "NONE",
"phase_label": "No divergence",
"question": "No phase differs from the bounded federation baseline.",
"reason": "All aligned dimension states match the bounded federation baseline."
},
"migration_executed": false,
"narrative": {
"decision": "The bounded federation decision is FEDERATION_SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS. The claim set remains qualified by deployment and independent-validation gaps.",
"divergence": "All aligned dimension states match the bounded federation baseline.",
"summary": "Qualified evidence federation baseline federated 7 records into 7 independent roots."
},
"operational": false,
"phase_matrix": [
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"label": "Evidence",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"phase_index": 1,
"question": "What information actually existed?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"label": "Provenance",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"phase_index": 2,
"question": "Where did it come from and how was it transformed?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"label": "Uncertainty",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"phase_index": 3,
"question": "What remained unknown, stale, correlated, or contradictory?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"label": "Interpretation",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"phase_index": 4,
"question": "What did the system infer from the evidence?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"label": "Options",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"phase_index": 5,
"question": "Which bounded alternatives were considered or rejected?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"label": "Authority",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"phase_index": 6,
"question": "Was the action permitted for this purpose and scope?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"label": "Runtime assurance",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"phase_index": 7,
"question": "Could independent enforcement preserve the declared bounds?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"label": "Review",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"phase_index": 8,
"question": "What review quality and independence were actually established?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"label": "Outcome",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"phase_index": 9,
"question": "What bounded result was applied or proposed?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"cells": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"label": "History",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"phase_index": 10,
"question": "Can the decision be reconstructed without rewriting prior state?",
"sources": [
{
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Decision Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"profile_description": "The claim set remains qualified by deployment and independent-validation gaps.",
"profile_id": "baseline-qualified",
"profile_label": "Qualified evidence federation baseline",
"proof": [
{
"name": "At least six source families are published",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-001"
},
{
"name": "Ten Technical Answerability phases are published",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-002"
},
{
"name": "At least eighteen independent claim dimensions are published",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-003"
},
{
"name": "All required relationship semantics are published",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-004"
},
{
"name": "All required claim states are published",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-005"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-01"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-02"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-03"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-04"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-05"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-06"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-07"
},
{
"name": "baseline-qualified performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-BASELINE_QUALIFIED-08"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-01"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-02"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-03"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-04"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-05"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-06"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-07"
},
{
"name": "duplicate-derivative-stress performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-DUPLICATE_DERIVATIVE_STRESS-08"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-01"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-02"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-03"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-04"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-05"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-06"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-07"
},
{
"name": "correlated-source-hold performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CORRELATED_SOURCE_HOLD-08"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-01"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-02"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-03"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-04"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-05"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-06"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-07"
},
{
"name": "uncertainty-divergence performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE-08"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-01"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-02"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-03"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-04"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-05"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-06"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-07"
},
{
"name": "authority-runtime-divergence performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-AUTHORITY_RUNTIME_DIVERGENCE-08"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-01"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-02"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-03"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-04"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-05"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-06"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-07"
},
{
"name": "review-quality-failure performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-REVIEW_QUALITY_FAILURE-08"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-01"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-02"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-03"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-04"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-05"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-06"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-07"
},
{
"name": "restored-availability-support-suspended performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-RESTORED_AVAILABILITY_SUPPORT_SUSPENDED-08"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-01"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-02"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-03"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-04"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-05"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-06"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-07"
},
{
"name": "contradiction-defeater performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-CONTRADICTION_DEFEATER-08"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-01"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-02"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-03"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-04"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-05"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-06"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-07"
},
{
"name": "protected-boundary-failure performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-PROTECTED_BOUNDARY_FAILURE-08"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic is deterministic",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-01"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic verifies every source",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-02"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic aligns all phases",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-03"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic preserves every dimension",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-04"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic event chain verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-05"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic claim lineage verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-06"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic terminates at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-07"
},
{
"name": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic performs no production action",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-ALL_GATES_REVIEWED_SYNTHETIC-08"
},
{
"name": "Duplicate derivatives do not increase independent roots",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-DUP-01"
},
{
"name": "Correlated roots block independent corroboration",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-CORR-01"
},
{
"name": "Expired authority is withdrawn rather than averaged away",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-AUTH-01"
},
{
"name": "A human click does not establish merits review",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-REV-01"
},
{
"name": "Restored availability does not restore evidentiary support",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-RESTORE-01"
},
{
"name": "Contradictions remain explicit and block support",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-CONTRA-01"
},
{
"name": "Protected-boundary failure withdraws or suspends claims",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-BOUNDARY-01"
},
{
"name": "Baseline comparison identifies a first divergence",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-CMP-01"
},
{
"name": "Counterfactual branch is isolated and unexecuted",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-BRANCH-01"
},
{
"name": "Deterministic evidence package verifies",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-PKG-01"
},
{
"name": "Unsafe and private fields are rejected",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-INPUT-01"
},
{
"name": "Public persistence is disabled",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-PERSIST-01"
},
{
"name": "Automatic production action is prohibited",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-AUTO-01"
},
{
"name": "All public actions terminate at synthetic null sink",
"passed": true,
"proof_id": "TAF-INV-TERMINAL-01"
}
],
"proof_passed": true,
"public_boundary": {
"accepts_arbitrary_files": false,
"accepts_arbitrary_urls": false,
"accepts_customer_content": false,
"accepts_protected_strategy": false,
"automatic_baseline_activation": false,
"automatic_deployment": false,
"automatic_migration": false,
"automatic_release_promotion": false,
"automatic_restart": false,
"automatic_rollback": false,
"customer_neutral": true,
"force_authorization": false,
"operational": false,
"public_persistence": false,
"real_facility_control": false,
"real_vehicle_control": false,
"synthetic": true,
"target_selection": false,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"weapon_functions": false
},
"public_persistence": false,
"readiness_dimensions": [
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "source_integrity",
"label": "SOURCE INTEGRITY",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "evidence_completeness",
"label": "EVIDENCE COMPLETENESS",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "evidence_independence",
"label": "EVIDENCE INDEPENDENCE",
"phase": "EVIDENCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "provenance_continuity",
"label": "PROVENANCE CONTINUITY",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "uncertainty_representation",
"label": "UNCERTAINTY REPRESENTATION",
"phase": "UNCERTAINTY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "interpretation_support",
"label": "INTERPRETATION SUPPORT",
"phase": "INTERPRETATION",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "option_space_completeness",
"label": "OPTION-SPACE COMPLETENESS",
"phase": "OPTIONS",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "authority",
"label": "CURRENT DELEGATED AUTHORITY",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "declared_purpose",
"label": "DECLARED PURPOSE",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "software_attestation",
"label": "SOFTWARE ATTESTATION",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "model_attestation",
"label": "MODEL ATTESTATION",
"phase": "PROVENANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "policy_attestation",
"label": "POLICY ATTESTATION",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "configuration_attestation",
"label": "CONFIGURATION ATTESTATION",
"phase": "AUTHORITY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "runtime_assurance",
"label": "RUNTIME ASSURANCE",
"phase": "RUNTIME_ASSURANCE",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "reviewer_merits",
"label": "REVIEWER MERITS",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 6
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "reviewer_independence",
"label": "REVIEWER INDEPENDENCE",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 4
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "outcome_reconstructability",
"label": "OUTCOME RECONSTRUCTABILITY",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": false,
"dimension": "history_integrity",
"label": "HISTORY INTEGRITY",
"phase": "HISTORY",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
}
],
"state": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"supporting_independent_roots": 7
},
{
"blocking": true,
"dimension": "deployment_evidence",
"label": "DEPLOYMENT EVIDENCE",
"phase": "OUTCOME",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"supporting_independent_roots": 0
},
{
"blocking": true,
"dimension": "independent_validation",
"label": "INDEPENDENT VALIDATION",
"phase": "REVIEW",
"source_states": [
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
},
{
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED"
}
],
"state": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"supporting_independent_roots": 0
}
],
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"release_promoted": false,
"residual_unknowns": [
"External factual truth is not established by record integrity alone.",
"Production deployment, legal status, accreditation, certification, procurement, and customer acceptance remain outside this synthetic federation."
],
"restart_executed": false,
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"family": "machine",
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-RC42-REVIEW-IMPLEMENTATION-B",
"implementation_lineage": "DIVERSE-INDEPENDENT-LINEAGE-B",
"independent": true,
"independently_scoped_authority": true,
"label": "Independent machine review",
"merits_capable": true,
"mode": "independent-machine-review",
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"quality": "INDEPENDENT_MACHINE_REVIEW",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review"
},
"rollback_executed": false,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation.v1",
"source_family_count": 7,
"source_record_count": 7,
"source_record_verifications": [
{
"check_count": 14,
"checks": [
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-01",
"name": "Source wrapper schema is exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-02",
"name": "Source family is published",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-03",
"name": "Source schema is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-04",
"name": "Source release is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-05",
"name": "Source engine identity is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-06",
"name": "Source record digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-07",
"name": "Source event-chain digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-08",
"name": "Source proof digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-09",
"name": "Source event chain verifies",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-10",
"name": "Source proof passed",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-11",
"name": "Source terminates at synthetic boundary",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-12",
"name": "Every dimension is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-13",
"name": "Every causal phase is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-14",
"name": "Source packet digest verifies",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed": true,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-verification.v1",
"verification_sha256": "3d8b46cc8ac2c130e5132413a5bd37aaf0a3b67bdd400bad94e7500c03745e17"
},
{
"check_count": 14,
"checks": [
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-01",
"name": "Source wrapper schema is exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-02",
"name": "Source family is published",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-03",
"name": "Source schema is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-04",
"name": "Source release is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-05",
"name": "Source engine identity is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-06",
"name": "Source record digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-07",
"name": "Source event-chain digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-08",
"name": "Source proof digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-09",
"name": "Source event chain verifies",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-10",
"name": "Source proof passed",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-11",
"name": "Source terminates at synthetic boundary",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-12",
"name": "Every dimension is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-13",
"name": "Every causal phase is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-14",
"name": "Source packet digest verifies",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed": true,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-verification.v1",
"verification_sha256": "3d8b46cc8ac2c130e5132413a5bd37aaf0a3b67bdd400bad94e7500c03745e17"
},
{
"check_count": 14,
"checks": [
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-01",
"name": "Source wrapper schema is exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-02",
"name": "Source family is published",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-03",
"name": "Source schema is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-04",
"name": "Source release is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-05",
"name": "Source engine identity is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-06",
"name": "Source record digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-07",
"name": "Source event-chain digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-08",
"name": "Source proof digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-09",
"name": "Source event chain verifies",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-10",
"name": "Source proof passed",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-11",
"name": "Source terminates at synthetic boundary",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-12",
"name": "Every dimension is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-13",
"name": "Every causal phase is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-14",
"name": "Source packet digest verifies",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed": true,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-verification.v1",
"verification_sha256": "3d8b46cc8ac2c130e5132413a5bd37aaf0a3b67bdd400bad94e7500c03745e17"
},
{
"check_count": 14,
"checks": [
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-01",
"name": "Source wrapper schema is exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-02",
"name": "Source family is published",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-03",
"name": "Source schema is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-04",
"name": "Source release is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-05",
"name": "Source engine identity is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-06",
"name": "Source record digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-07",
"name": "Source event-chain digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-08",
"name": "Source proof digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-09",
"name": "Source event chain verifies",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-10",
"name": "Source proof passed",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-11",
"name": "Source terminates at synthetic boundary",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-12",
"name": "Every dimension is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-13",
"name": "Every causal phase is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-14",
"name": "Source packet digest verifies",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed": true,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-verification.v1",
"verification_sha256": "3d8b46cc8ac2c130e5132413a5bd37aaf0a3b67bdd400bad94e7500c03745e17"
},
{
"check_count": 14,
"checks": [
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-01",
"name": "Source wrapper schema is exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-02",
"name": "Source family is published",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-03",
"name": "Source schema is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-04",
"name": "Source release is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-05",
"name": "Source engine identity is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-06",
"name": "Source record digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-07",
"name": "Source event-chain digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-08",
"name": "Source proof digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-09",
"name": "Source event chain verifies",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-10",
"name": "Source proof passed",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-11",
"name": "Source terminates at synthetic boundary",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-12",
"name": "Every dimension is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-13",
"name": "Every causal phase is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-14",
"name": "Source packet digest verifies",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed": true,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-verification.v1",
"verification_sha256": "3d8b46cc8ac2c130e5132413a5bd37aaf0a3b67bdd400bad94e7500c03745e17"
},
{
"check_count": 14,
"checks": [
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-01",
"name": "Source wrapper schema is exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-02",
"name": "Source family is published",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-03",
"name": "Source schema is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-04",
"name": "Source release is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-05",
"name": "Source engine identity is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-06",
"name": "Source record digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-07",
"name": "Source event-chain digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-08",
"name": "Source proof digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-09",
"name": "Source event chain verifies",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-10",
"name": "Source proof passed",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-11",
"name": "Source terminates at synthetic boundary",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-12",
"name": "Every dimension is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-13",
"name": "Every causal phase is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-14",
"name": "Source packet digest verifies",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed": true,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-verification.v1",
"verification_sha256": "3d8b46cc8ac2c130e5132413a5bd37aaf0a3b67bdd400bad94e7500c03745e17"
},
{
"check_count": 14,
"checks": [
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-01",
"name": "Source wrapper schema is exact",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-02",
"name": "Source family is published",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-03",
"name": "Source schema is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-04",
"name": "Source release is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-05",
"name": "Source engine identity is present",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-06",
"name": "Source record digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-07",
"name": "Source event-chain digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-08",
"name": "Source proof digest is valid",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-09",
"name": "Source event chain verifies",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-10",
"name": "Source proof passed",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-11",
"name": "Source terminates at synthetic boundary",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-12",
"name": "Every dimension is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-13",
"name": "Every causal phase is represented",
"passed": true
},
{
"id": "TAF-SRC-14",
"name": "Source packet digest verifies",
"passed": true
}
],
"passed": true,
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-verification.v1",
"verification_sha256": "3d8b46cc8ac2c130e5132413a5bd37aaf0a3b67bdd400bad94e7500c03745e17"
}
],
"source_records": [
{
"availability_state": "AVAILABLE",
"correlation_group": "CORR-TA-CORE",
"custody": "EVULGARE_DETERMINISTIC_SOURCE_GENERATOR",
"derivative_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01",
"derivative_lineage": [
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"dimension_states": {
"authority": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"configuration_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"declared_purpose": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"deployment_evidence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"evidence_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"evidence_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"history_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"independent_validation": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"interpretation_support": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"model_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"option_space_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"outcome_reconstructability": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"policy_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"provenance_continuity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_merits": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"runtime_assurance": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"software_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"source_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"uncertainty_representation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
"expiry_state": "EXPIRES_ON_SOURCE_OR_CONFIGURATION_CHANGE",
"freshness_state": "CURRENT_FOR_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_SCOPE",
"label": "Technical Answerability",
"phase_states": {
"AUTHORITY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"EVIDENCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"HISTORY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"INTERPRETATION": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"OPTIONS": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"OUTCOME": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PROVENANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"REVIEW": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"UNCERTAINTY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
"proof_count": 14,
"record_sha256": "dad2ceb45c588b041da978aa28c32e3333448e7ec7bc97a7862383531976b3d5",
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"root_source": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-TA-ARCHITECTURE",
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-record.v1",
"scope": "Evidence-to-history decision structure",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"CORR-TA-CORE-SHARED-FAILURE"
],
"source_engine_version": "2.0.0",
"source_event_chain_sha256": "acc88a7de7a38c629a5b745b1fa4d429fec28ab3ac415ef937fad181a2669bd3",
"source_event_chain_valid": true,
"source_event_count": 10,
"source_family": "technical-answerability",
"source_family_id": "technical-answerability",
"source_input": {
"scenario_id": "bounded-baseline"
},
"source_label": "Technical Answerability",
"source_packet_sha256": "dad2ceb45c588b041da978aa28c32e3333448e7ec7bc97a7862383531976b3d5",
"source_proof_passed": true,
"source_proof_sha256": "313085e011bafc960e47675d031d0766ea60ade0a14eecc8bbc6ea4092ba7607",
"source_record_sha256": "737c2ca194ce15bc18a3d0e3b7a71ef0387be16ff1db420c0f93953b3a308b70",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.41-WIP",
"source_schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-run.v2",
"source_terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"support_state": "CURRENTLY_REVIEWABLE",
"verification_passed": true
},
{
"availability_state": "AVAILABLE",
"correlation_group": "CORR-DECISION-CHAIN",
"custody": "EVULGARE_DETERMINISTIC_SOURCE_GENERATOR",
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01",
"derivative_lineage": [
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"dimension_states": {
"authority": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"configuration_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"declared_purpose": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"deployment_evidence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"evidence_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"evidence_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"history_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"independent_validation": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"interpretation_support": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"model_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"option_space_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"outcome_reconstructability": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"policy_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"provenance_continuity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_independence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reviewer_merits": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"runtime_assurance": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"software_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"source_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"uncertainty_representation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
"expiry_state": "EXPIRES_ON_SOURCE_OR_CONFIGURATION_CHANGE",
"freshness_state": "CURRENT_FOR_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_SCOPE",
"label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"phase_states": {
"AUTHORITY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"EVIDENCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"HISTORY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"INTERPRETATION": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OPTIONS": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"OUTCOME": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PROVENANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"REVIEW": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"UNCERTAINTY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
"proof_count": 14,
"record_sha256": "c612064c1ca19fdd2f97125ab0111ef85fa18576fe9e4f7435b29e71a706f451",
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-RECONSTRUCTION",
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-record.v1",
"scope": "Causal replay and decision-provenance record",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"CORR-DECISION-CHAIN-SHARED-FAILURE"
],
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_event_chain_sha256": "e7cc12aefc26f9c54bde00afc19539cffa154f3152f7d81400a7ce9b1812e324",
"source_event_chain_valid": true,
"source_event_count": 10,
"source_family": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_family_id": "decision-reconstruction",
"source_input": {
"change_kind": "none",
"review_mode": "merits-review",
"scenario_id": "bounded-baseline",
"source_id": "technical-answerability"
},
"source_label": "Decision Reconstruction",
"source_packet_sha256": "c612064c1ca19fdd2f97125ab0111ef85fa18576fe9e4f7435b29e71a706f451",
"source_proof_passed": true,
"source_proof_sha256": "27f4c64fab0456c848bfdfef3d2c335e371c9da01b367c92230c7c72c76d7bb5",
"source_record_sha256": "ba8bbc9b1ddada0c759aa331b44a0afa0592da2059d5e866e18237173f7857cd",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"source_schema": "evulgare.decision-reconstruction.v1",
"source_terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"support_state": "CURRENTLY_REVIEWABLE",
"verification_passed": true
},
{
"availability_state": "AVAILABLE",
"correlation_group": "CORR-DECISION-CHAIN",
"custody": "EVULGARE_DETERMINISTIC_SOURCE_GENERATOR",
"derivative_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"derivative_lineage": [
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"dimension_states": {
"authority": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"configuration_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"declared_purpose": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"deployment_evidence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"evidence_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"evidence_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"history_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"independent_validation": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"interpretation_support": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"model_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"option_space_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"outcome_reconstructability": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"policy_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"provenance_continuity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_independence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reviewer_merits": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"runtime_assurance": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"software_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"source_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"uncertainty_representation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"expiry_state": "EXPIRES_ON_SOURCE_OR_CONFIGURATION_CHANGE",
"freshness_state": "CURRENT_FOR_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_SCOPE",
"label": "Decision Review",
"phase_states": {
"AUTHORITY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"EVIDENCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"HISTORY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"INTERPRETATION": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OPTIONS": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OUTCOME": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PROVENANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"REVIEW": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"UNCERTAINTY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"proof_count": 14,
"record_sha256": "51765ef9368400d1044326eb3027abd267251c3c8f7309e9fd298cb5eec5915b",
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"root_source": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-DECISION-REVIEW",
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-record.v1",
"scope": "Evidence adjudication and claim lineage",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"CORR-DECISION-CHAIN-SHARED-FAILURE"
],
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_event_chain_sha256": "29f2ca7e829492e30fb0d7c0a2aa46998e135f79d35da113da47c660055a48aa",
"source_event_chain_valid": true,
"source_event_count": 11,
"source_family": "decision-review",
"source_family_id": "decision-review",
"source_input": {
"adjudication_state": "SUPPORT_QUALIFIED",
"evidence_opened": [
"ALL_CURRENT_SOURCE_EVIDENCE"
],
"evidence_relationships": [],
"inspections": {
"authority_state": true,
"change_impact": true,
"changed_scope": true,
"contradictory_evidence": true,
"runtime_assurance": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"rationale": "The bounded synthetic record was inspected across evidence, contrary indicators, authority, runtime assurance, review conditions, and change impact. Support remains qualified by the declared assumptions and limitations.",
"residual_unknowns": [
"Factual truth outside the synthetic source record is not established.",
"Legal liability, certification, and operational readiness are not established."
],
"review_duration_seconds": 300,
"review_mode": "merits-review",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"authority_independent": false,
"authority_reference": "SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_SCOPE_RC15",
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": false,
"implementation_id": "REVIEW-WORKFLOW-HUMAN-BOUNDARY",
"implementation_lineage": "DECLARED_WORKFLOW_ONLY",
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_ASSURANCE_REVIEWER"
},
"source": {
"change_kind": "none",
"review_mode": "merits-review",
"scenario_id": "bounded-baseline",
"source_id": "technical-answerability"
}
},
"source_label": "Decision Review",
"source_packet_sha256": "51765ef9368400d1044326eb3027abd267251c3c8f7309e9fd298cb5eec5915b",
"source_proof_passed": true,
"source_proof_sha256": "881c3ff5fe855c57435efda0c0f5630fd3d4a7f371ba7df2365593e157cd4d37",
"source_record_sha256": "0e8681315386fc5afb4f166a938939639380ef7385a3f34395e74cbf1a7b68e8",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.21-WIP",
"source_schema": "evulgare.decision-review.v1",
"source_terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"support_state": "CURRENTLY_REVIEWABLE",
"verification_passed": true
},
{
"availability_state": "AVAILABLE",
"correlation_group": "CORR-AUTHORITY-RUNTIME",
"custody": "EVULGARE_DETERMINISTIC_SOURCE_GENERATOR",
"derivative_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01",
"derivative_lineage": [
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"dimension_states": {
"authority": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"configuration_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"declared_purpose": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"deployment_evidence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"evidence_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"evidence_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"history_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"independent_validation": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"interpretation_support": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"model_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"option_space_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"outcome_reconstructability": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"policy_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"provenance_continuity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_independence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"reviewer_merits": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"runtime_assurance": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"software_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"source_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"uncertainty_representation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
"expiry_state": "EXPIRES_ON_SOURCE_OR_CONFIGURATION_CHANGE",
"freshness_state": "CURRENT_FOR_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_SCOPE",
"label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"phase_states": {
"AUTHORITY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"EVIDENCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"HISTORY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"INTERPRETATION": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OPTIONS": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"OUTCOME": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PROVENANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"REVIEW": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"UNCERTAINTY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS"
},
"proof_count": 14,
"record_sha256": "0a1a49b74a95de2c69237da007ac3f5d0c561d3b683f2f13d8c5d962d644a43c",
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"root_source": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-AUTHORITY-KERNEL",
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-record.v1",
"scope": "Authority and independent reference monitoring",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"CORR-AUTHORITY-RUNTIME-SHARED-FAILURE"
],
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_event_chain_sha256": "290ba842c0eb4c49d39c56bbc6a9928c06f2b311c5a517cd57a12e29cff74468",
"source_event_chain_valid": true,
"source_event_count": 12,
"source_family": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_family_id": "autonomous-defense-kernel",
"source_input": {
"scenario_id": "valid-authority-baseline"
},
"source_label": "Autonomous Defense Kernel",
"source_packet_sha256": "0a1a49b74a95de2c69237da007ac3f5d0c561d3b683f2f13d8c5d962d644a43c",
"source_proof_passed": true,
"source_proof_sha256": "e7ac17d89e934d09412e36c306719c68b5aa1f9e648d9ba4155429ef9233ac14",
"source_record_sha256": "d366b2b38766b3cf4d66d467d40e8bace0604038a0b14754c81b0edcd4a386db",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.24-WIP",
"source_schema": "evulgare.autonomous-defense-kernel.v1",
"source_terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"support_state": "CURRENTLY_REVIEWABLE",
"verification_passed": true
},
{
"availability_state": "AVAILABLE",
"correlation_group": "CORR-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"custody": "EVULGARE_DETERMINISTIC_SOURCE_GENERATOR",
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"derivative_lineage": [
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"dimension_states": {
"authority": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"configuration_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"declared_purpose": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"deployment_evidence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"evidence_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"evidence_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"history_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"independent_validation": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"interpretation_support": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"model_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"option_space_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"outcome_reconstructability": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"policy_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"provenance_continuity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_merits": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"runtime_assurance": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"software_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"source_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"uncertainty_representation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"expiry_state": "EXPIRES_ON_SOURCE_OR_CONFIGURATION_CHANGE",
"freshness_state": "CURRENT_FOR_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_SCOPE",
"label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"phase_states": {
"AUTHORITY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"EVIDENCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"HISTORY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"INTERPRETATION": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OPTIONS": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OUTCOME": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PROVENANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"REVIEW": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"UNCERTAINTY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"proof_count": 14,
"record_sha256": "6aa1bdc25a5643ce9bad06f816613824fcc97e53c1518c57ac18416dfbb3bccf",
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"root_source": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CRITICAL-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW",
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-record.v1",
"scope": "Cross-site continuity and recovery-baseline review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"CORR-INFRASTRUCTURE-REVIEW-SHARED-FAILURE"
],
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_event_chain_sha256": "2b39c56fa9f3dc3e77582c697895e4fb6fced7728ab17d1d98535a0bbe730820",
"source_event_chain_valid": true,
"source_event_count": 23,
"source_family": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_family_id": "critical-infrastructure-review",
"source_input": {
"profile_id": "all-gates-reviewed-synthetic",
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review"
},
"source_label": "Critical Infrastructure Campaign Review",
"source_packet_sha256": "6aa1bdc25a5643ce9bad06f816613824fcc97e53c1518c57ac18416dfbb3bccf",
"source_proof_passed": true,
"source_proof_sha256": "008740c26c3bb11d4f07491d05e066084696f581af2c5308ff361851db3ebbb7",
"source_record_sha256": "f4c1e86f504f9f73998838f612132ad78243059dad08b0d4146ec10a67a0ad39",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.41-WIP",
"source_schema": "evulgare.critical-infrastructure-defense-review.v1",
"source_terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"support_state": "CURRENTLY_REVIEWABLE",
"verification_passed": true
},
{
"availability_state": "AVAILABLE",
"correlation_group": "CORR-CONTINUITY-REVIEW",
"custody": "EVULGARE_DETERMINISTIC_SOURCE_GENERATOR",
"derivative_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01",
"derivative_lineage": [
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"dimension_states": {
"authority": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"configuration_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"declared_purpose": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"deployment_evidence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"evidence_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"evidence_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"history_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"independent_validation": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"interpretation_support": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"model_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"option_space_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"outcome_reconstructability": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"policy_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"provenance_continuity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_merits": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"runtime_assurance": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"software_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"source_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"uncertainty_representation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"expiry_state": "EXPIRES_ON_SOURCE_OR_CONFIGURATION_CHANGE",
"freshness_state": "CURRENT_FOR_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_SCOPE",
"label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"phase_states": {
"AUTHORITY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"EVIDENCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"HISTORY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"INTERPRETATION": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OPTIONS": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OUTCOME": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PROVENANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"REVIEW": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"UNCERTAINTY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"proof_count": 14,
"record_sha256": "2b8055830d88cf82f63b6785b37150678b50dffffb6478141bb54b9fa52627fd",
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"root_source": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-CONTINUITY-CAMPAIGN",
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-record.v1",
"scope": "Continuity baseline, reconciliation, and reconstitution review",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"CORR-CONTINUITY-REVIEW-SHARED-FAILURE"
],
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_event_chain_sha256": "df7a9cb34359c5fa938c59b9793e6da555b252514d9363572e5f3d3b172c2dc1",
"source_event_chain_valid": true,
"source_event_count": 10,
"source_family": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_family_id": "continuity-campaign-review",
"source_input": {
"campaign_id": "attested-reconstitution",
"contrary_indicators_reviewed": [
"FAILED_OR_QUALIFIED_PROOF_CONDITIONS",
"UNRESOLVED_DEFEATERS",
"CHANGED_ASSUMPTIONS",
"RECONSTITUTION_PREREQUISITES"
],
"effective_conditions": [
"Exact package, release, engine, baseline, identity, authority, key epoch, software, model, policy, configuration, and evidence digests remain unchanged.",
"No unresolved new defeater or source withdrawal is introduced."
],
"evidence_opened": [
"accepted-scope",
"difference-lifecycle",
"proof-conditions",
"containment-results",
"minimum-sovereign-function",
"authority-key-epoch",
"reconciliation",
"reconstitution",
"public-private-boundary"
],
"expiry_condition": "Expires on any scoped digest, authority, policy, assumption, or evidence change.",
"inspections": {
"authority_and_key_epoch": true,
"changed_assumptions": true,
"containment_results": true,
"exact_accepted_scope": true,
"failed_or_qualified_proof_conditions": true,
"minimum_sovereign_function": true,
"newly_introduced_differences": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"reconciliation_state": true,
"reconstitution_eligibility": true,
"residual_unknowns": true,
"resolved_differences": true,
"unchanged_evidence": true,
"unresolved_defeaters": true
},
"profile_id": "recovery-validated",
"qualifications": [
"SYNTHETIC_CAMPAIGN_SCOPE_ONLY",
"PRODUCTION_DEPLOYMENT_EVIDENCE_NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PHYSICAL_HARDWARE_AND_NETWORK_BEHAVIOR_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
],
"rationale": "The exact bounded synthetic campaign package, accepted baseline identity, drill ordering, containment, minimum sovereign function, key-epoch state, reconciliation, reconstitution prerequisites, contrary indicators, assumptions, and public boundary were inspected. The candidate is suitable only as a qualified synthetic baseline proposal and does not establish operational readiness or accreditation.",
"residual_unknowns": [
"Representative device, hardware-root, network-partition, security, and performance behavior remain untested.",
"Legal, accreditation, procurement, and customer-system approval are outside this review artifact."
],
"review_duration_seconds": 480,
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-CONTINUITY-REVIEW-SCOPE-RC22",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRI-CONTINUITY-02",
"implementation_lineage": "DIVERSE_SYNTHETIC_REVIEW_LINEAGE-B",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_CONTINUITY_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review",
"rollback_baseline_id": "EV-SCB-2020-ACCEPTED-CURRENT",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"PRODUCTION_HOST_ACCEPTANCE_PENDING"
]
},
"source_label": "Continuity Campaign Review",
"source_packet_sha256": "2b8055830d88cf82f63b6785b37150678b50dffffb6478141bb54b9fa52627fd",
"source_proof_passed": true,
"source_proof_sha256": "17bc3ee7614a3e9c710c1aa33c39ef0eed664e9b262a6e2a6039967d8bc19e22",
"source_record_sha256": "5c5aceae2cb1822ae92813b3580e9c5e1f0f43f32c7a851deacfca9637e7b616",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.22-WIP",
"source_schema": "evulgare.continuity-campaign-review.v1",
"source_terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"support_state": "CURRENTLY_REVIEWABLE",
"verification_passed": true
},
{
"availability_state": "AVAILABLE",
"correlation_group": "CORR-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"custody": "EVULGARE_DETERMINISTIC_SOURCE_GENERATOR",
"derivative_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01",
"derivative_lineage": [
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-DERIVATIVE-01"
],
"dimension_states": {
"authority": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"configuration_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"declared_purpose": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"deployment_evidence": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"evidence_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"evidence_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"history_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"independent_validation": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"interpretation_support": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"model_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"option_space_completeness": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"outcome_reconstructability": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"policy_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"provenance_continuity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_independence": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"reviewer_merits": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"runtime_assurance": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"software_attestation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"source_integrity": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"uncertainty_representation": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"expiry_state": "EXPIRES_ON_SOURCE_OR_CONFIGURATION_CHANGE",
"freshness_state": "CURRENT_FOR_DECLARED_SYNTHETIC_SCOPE",
"label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"phase_states": {
"AUTHORITY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"EVIDENCE": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"HISTORY": "SUPPORTED_WITHIN_DECLARED_BOUNDS",
"INTERPRETATION": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OPTIONS": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"OUTCOME": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"PROVENANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"REVIEW": "NOT_ESTABLISHED",
"RUNTIME_ASSURANCE": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"UNCERTAINTY": "SUPPORTED_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS"
},
"proof_count": 14,
"record_sha256": "347564bf06802d0b7d21294f7f46fc7717c7ea6116d31bacbfdd2536da8a3055",
"release": "2.0.0-rc.42-WIP",
"root_source": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"root_source_id": "ROOT-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW",
"schema": "evulgare.technical-answerability-federation-source-record.v1",
"scope": "Maintenance evidence and reconstitution readiness",
"shared_failure_modes": [
"CORR-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-SHARED-FAILURE"
],
"source_engine_version": "1.0.0",
"source_event_chain_sha256": "82ac601c95750d13f5b95892a4cdd1352c191cb5299b4ca4e24d464923af7190",
"source_event_chain_valid": true,
"source_event_count": 13,
"source_family": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_family_id": "industrial-resilience-review",
"source_input": {
"campaign_id": "fleet-maintenance-baseline",
"inspections": {
"asset_identity_and_authority": true,
"calibration": true,
"configuration_reconciliation": true,
"continuity_impact": true,
"correlation_control": true,
"deployment_evidence": true,
"diagnostic_evidence": true,
"evidence_dependence": true,
"parts_and_materials": true,
"post_repair_verification": true,
"public_private_boundary_integrity": true,
"return_to_service_authority": true,
"robotic_fleet_capacity": true,
"rollback_baseline": true,
"source_package_integrity": true,
"tool_and_recipe_attestation": true
},
"review_state": "ACCEPT_WITH_QUALIFICATIONS",
"reviewer": {
"abstention_available": true,
"actual_intervention_authority": true,
"authority_independent": true,
"authority_reference": "EV-INDUSTRIAL-REVIEW-SCOPE-RC26",
"available_alternatives": true,
"contrary_hypothesis_reviewed": true,
"implementation_diversity": true,
"implementation_id": "EV-IRR-INDEPENDENT-01",
"implementation_lineage": "DIVERSE_SYNTHETIC_INDUSTRIAL_LINEAGE-A",
"no_shared_unrecorded_mutable_state": true,
"primary_evidence_access": true,
"role": "SYNTHETIC_INDEPENDENT_INDUSTRIAL_REVIEW_INTELLIGENCE"
},
"reviewer_mode": "independent-machine-review"
},
"source_label": "Industrial Resilience Review",
"source_packet_sha256": "347564bf06802d0b7d21294f7f46fc7717c7ea6116d31bacbfdd2536da8a3055",
"source_proof_passed": true,
"source_proof_sha256": "2bb188e8fa6d6563c00133d8faf17ce0c65f2bb937a4dbb9a5bcf00e6dd6ad02",
"source_record_sha256": "073b7d11a4b62d6034a2466fbf44fbb5092ab4dcbb8afe108e2f0186f5d7c59c",
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.26-WIP",
"source_schema": "evulgare.industrial-resilience-review.v1",
"source_terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"support_state": "CURRENTLY_REVIEWABLE",
"verification_passed": true
}
],
"source_release": "2.0.0-rc.41-WIP",
"source_verification_passed": true,
"synthetic": true,
"terminal": "SYNTHETIC_NULL_SINK",
"unresolved_defeaters": [
"ACTUAL_HOST_AND_INDEPENDENT_VALIDATION_NOT_ESTABLISHED"
]
}
AUTHORITATIVE STATE
PYTHON DEFINES THE RESULT.
The browser renders, navigates, filters, compares, branches, and downloads deterministic state. It cannot create authority, claim support, proof, outcome, or canonical history.
EPistemic discipline
INTEGRITY IS NOT TRUTH.
A valid digest proves recorded-byte continuity. It does not prove the source accurately described the external world. Replay proves reconstructability, not correctness, legality, certification, or wisdom.
PUBLIC BOUNDARY
NO OPERATIONAL COMMAND PATH.
No real facility, target, vehicle, weapon, payload, reactor-control, industrial-protocol, force-authorization, customer-content, or protected-partner data enters the public range.